Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Given the recent issue of exclusive content being shared elsewhere, I have been brainstorming ideas to avoid this from happening in the future. For context, last month all my exclusive posters were shared by a Patron on another website (themoviedb.com) completely undermining the integrity of this platform. Thankfully, with the assistance of themoviedb I was able to promptly get these removed. I want to believe this was done in genuine error by the person but I still need to mitigate this from happening again. After giving it some considerable thought the most feasible solution I have come up with is transitioning to a tiered subscription system. This would be quite a major change, which comes with its own set of quirks and problems to deal with so it's not something I want to rush into without your opinion and input.

Currently, we operate on a pay-what-you-want system where everyone receives the same rewards, regardless of the pledge amount. I've always favoured this system because it provides access for everyone, allows those who can and want to pledge more to do so, and ensures nobody is left out. But this also leaves the door open for people to abuse this system. My goal for Patreon is that supporters enjoy the rewards and are motivated to continue supporting future content, that way everybody wins. However, the effectiveness of this system hinges on the trust that all Patrons, past and future, will respect the guidelines, which until recently was the case. It's unfortunate that the actions of one person can impact everyone's enjoyment.

So here's my initial idea for tiers: (tier names are yet to be determined, so feel free to comment below with your suggestions)

ALL tiers receive priority treatment for poster requests, can interact in community polls and discussions plus get access to any timed exclusive early access poster drops.

First Tier (£1):  Minimal Support Tier for those who want to show their support but aren't interested in the exclusive monthly poster benefits. By joining this tier, you'll still receive priority treatment for poster requests and the ability to participate in future polls and discussions plus get access to any timed exclusive early access poster drops.

Second Tier (£2): (Includes all the benefits of the previous tier) A cheaper tier that gives Patrons rolling access to the exclusive content. This means that each month's content is accessible only during that month. For example, if you subscribe in April, you gain access to April's content, but you won't have access to the previous month's content. Then when May rolls around, your access changes from April's content to May's content. That way, if you stay subscribed at this tier, you won't miss out on any future content. Please note that this will require Patrons subscribed to this tier to keep a personal backup of content, as once the month ends the previous month's content will become locked and the only way to access would be with the Third Tier.

Third Tier (£5-7): (Includes all the benefits of both previous tiers) Provides access to the full back catalogue of exclusive posters. This allows people who are looking to access the extensive back catalogue of exclusive posters (over 200 and counting) to access all previous posts, and If they wish, have the option to change their pledge down to the cheaper Second Tier, but access would also change to rolling month to month as stated above. For those who want convenience, this Third Tier allows Patrons an easy way to access exclusive posters whenever they wish and not have to worry about keeping their own backup.

I hope these explanations make sense and how reward access works for each tier is clear.

While it is impossible to stop those wanting to share content, the hope is that with the full back catalogue being behind the higher Third Tier is that it creates enough of a deterrent, and prevents them from just jumping in and out for the lowest amount which the current system allows.

As stated above all tiers will still receive priority treatment for poster requests, have the ability to interact in community polls and discussions plus get access to any timed exclusive early access poster drops. In the future, I plan to add new rewards to the various tiers, such as tutorials, templates, Discord server etc, but these are still in the planning stage and I will announce them as and when they are ready.

With regards to the pricing, These are not set in stone and I am more than happy to hear opinions on them but I feel these proposed prices strike a fair balance. At first I was only thinking about having two tiers, the Second and Third tiers, but I know there are those who only use Patreon as a tip jar, so I don’t see any harm in adding this as an option for those who want to support, be part of the community engagement but aren’t necessarily here for the monthly rewards. For the Second tier, which I assume will be the most popular, I need a price that strikes a balance between the various pledges I currently have, they range from £1 to £10 with the average being £2 to £4 which fluctuates month to month. Since I don’t want to penalise current Patrons who pay less than this I feel the lower £2 price is a fair compromise. The Third Tier price is more challenging as I know this will mainly be of interest to new members who want access to the full back catalogue or for those who have been unsubscribed for a while and want to catch up on missed exclusives, and I accept that most are likely to either unsub or move down to the Second tier so I need to find an appropriate and fair price for accessing this extensive archive while not putting off new Patrons. Even with the set tier prices, Patreon allows subscribed members to increase their pledge but stay on the current tier, that way someone who wants to pledge more than the tier amount can do so if they wish.

So in summary, I am considering transitioning to a tiered subscription system to address the recent issue of exclusive content being shared elsewhere. All tiers will have access to priority poster requests, community interaction and any timed exclusives, the Second Tier grants rolling access to each month's exclusive content, while the Third Tier provides access to the full back catalogue of exclusive posters. Having the full back catalogue behind this higher tier will hopefully discourage people from joining with the sole intention of downloading everything and sharing the content on other platforms. I encourage all Patrons to share their opinions on this potential change and welcome any suggestions you may have.

Chris (DIIIVOY)

Comments

Brendan Hummel

The tiered system sounds great. No complaints from me

TheChrisK

I respect that you need to protect your creations and the tiered system seems very reasonable.

Tomate

i had idea. What if you shared your spreadsheet/plan (if it is technically possible) of what you want to do or plan to do so we know what to expect or do not send requests on stuff you already plan to do. Just a thought