Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Do you think the new animations are worth it?

  • I love them 309
  • They are alright 98
  • I don't really care 93
  • I don't like them 27
  • 2020-10-19
  • 527 votes
{'title': 'Do you think the new animations are worth it?', 'choices': [{'text': 'I love them', 'votes': 309}, {'text': 'They are alright', 'votes': 98}, {'text': "I don't really care", 'votes': 93}, {'text': "I don't like them", 'votes': 27}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2020, 10, 19, 20, 37, 17, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 527}

Content

Hello! Have you checked the new animations in the enhanced released of Chapter 5?

It's a feature a lot of people requested in the past, but I never thought I could implement it in my games. But for some reason, during this downtime, I thought about trying it. I couldn't really draw, having my arm injured and all, but I could modify existing drawings... They are really simple 2 frame drawings (doing anything else would be impossible right now) but I felt they added a really nice illusion of movements to the still images, making them feel a bit more alive.

I know they are a bit rudimentary, but they are reasonable time and effort wise to produce, but they add to the workload and production time of the game, of course. Overall, what do you think? Do you like the new animations, do you find them dull or uncanny, are you eager to see more or would you rather have me drop the idea altogether?

Files

Comments

krank404

I'm with Suricat on this. Animations don't really add much for the amount of work you need to put into this. My imagination is good enough.

Julian Harper

As long as they aren’t too taxing to make I really like them, they are subtle but do add to the scene, very well done

Breadloaf

I think that they add quite a bit to the scenes, and it seems to me like they're worth it. But I don't know how much time you have to spend on each animation, so in the end it's up to you and how much time it takes from your other tasks. There's only one Eva Kiss and you shouldn't overwork yourself, after all.

DemonKing90

I didn't get to download ot at all

dingus

I don't mind them. But I much prefer the work go towards finishing and working on the story and other scenes. Then add the animations in a later update, just because?

o iMarkus v

I would rather you made more scenes with cindy and Ian

XJ347

I would rather have more pictures than a few 2 or 3 frame animations. I'm not saying take them out, but they don't add enough value for the expenditure of time IMO. Better to just have different sex images instead.

Maj'd

I haven't played it yet. Can we get an example/demo/video?

Briz

I think they're amazing! I'd prefer to have more pics/content sooner though. It could be nice as like a post-completion thing or as a big v1.0 addition.

sbb0

Not worth any additional workload. Prefer static drawings to be honest.

Kwadwo

To be honest, I don't think they're worth it either. As you say, they are quite rudimentary, and while I certainly don't think they're completely meaningless, I just don't think they warrant the extra time they take to produce. Especially considering you've already stated ORS is taking longer to develop compared to GGGB. Also, as a side note, I think when the question is phrased as it is, you will get a lot of people who say they like them, without reflecting on what you're giving up for it. This means the answers might be a bit skewed

Johnathan F. Krapsinski

The question is how much more work they are. If an animation takes 50% of what it takes to make a new picture its not worth it. I'd rather have 3 pictures than 2 animations. But if it's more like 10% thats probably just a day more for an update.

Funky Munky

I think many of the comments above already reflect my view - I'm fine with the animated scenes, but even if it's not a huge amount of effort on your part to make them, I'd rather that time be spent on more scene drawings / character sprite variants etc. I find the art and story compelling enough, so for me the animations aren't really a value-add

Daliath

The problem for me is that you can instantly see which one is the original drawing and which one is the modified. The modded one looks out of place for me, maybe it's the composition of the drawing that is not designed for the second frame.

Dominique

Animations are - for me - almost never worth it. Given limited time and assets, I'd much rather have more story/paths etc.

Patty74

I actually voted "dont like", but not because they are not nice/pretty. They seem to me as an extra eating up resources without bringing something substantial to your game. I see your drawings "move" either way in my imagination (yes, they are THAT good...) no need to actually animate them.

Hotdog25

The animations look good, of course they're a bit clumsy, being just 2 animated images, but for now it at least adds some motion to the overall scenes. I would say mainly it depends again on your workload, if it's adding too much for your working hours and will impact too much the release dates, then I would say it's definitely not worth it for now. Maybe later on, whenever you have support of extra people, which can do the job in parallel, then it should be definitely a yes. The ideal of course would be (at least from what I've seen) the full videos like in "Treasures of Nadia", the videos there (especially in latest versions) are really awesome, just imagine implementing something like this in ORS. it would be then definitely a perfect game and take all #1 spots ;) but that of course can only happen I assume, if you get more people in your team.

Phing Lee

I've noticed that Ren'Py doesn't seem to like animation.

Robert Arctor

Animation is usually not worth it in VNs, in my view. It's not a reflection on your work, short loops out of nowhere just don't seem to fit with the medium, 2d or 3d. Dedicated animation, in the sense of watching a short of the order of 10 minutes or so, is a different story.

Christian Schulz

I love the idea of animations yet when push comes to shove I almost always would prioritize more choices, more dialogue, more character interaction. So add a few when it makes sense and you have the time, but you don't need to invest too much in them.