Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Go to this site: Cinebingers.ca for the unedited versions of all our content.

👉 https://cinebingers.ca/GTa5Kx7bT9 👈 for the full reaction where you do not need your own copy.

👉 https://cinebingers.ca/HTle9wPwz8 👈for the full reaction where you need your own copy.

If you are on a phone/tablet, hold down the link above and press "open in browser", or go straight to Cinebingers.ca on your browser app.

Files

Comments

Captain Kermit

"He was a man take him for all in all, I shall not look upon his like again”

Joel

So now you know why all the aliens look like humans, George!!! :D Ha! And you thought they didn't have an answer for you :P

Der heilige Stuhl

God speed Patrick..Ill raise my cup of tea to ya

TheLeftPecOfTheLord

Sir Patrick was a once in a generation talent. It’ll be very melancholy but also wonderful to see him share the screen with Ian McKellan one last time in December. And it’ll be a privilege watching you guys watch and react to the rest of his tenure as Picard for the foreseeable future 🖖🏻

James Kelly

Ever since his passing, the words "What we leave behind, is not as important as how we lived" has being stuck in my head. RIP Sir Patrick Stewart.

Here To Hurtle Your Shirts and Burgle Your Terts

Definitely a different feel watching it now but “Lessons” is a pretty personal favourite - it’s become even more painfully moving with Sir Patrick’s passing. Not only is it a thematic continuation of “The Inner Light”, it’s about the connections we can make with music and melody. As a lover of everything from Bachian counterpoint and Baroque/Romantic etudes to electro-house of Justice/Daft Punk to metal and jazz fusion, the power of music is awesome shit indeed! I will also pay my respects to the wonderful Wendy Hughes! She had a prolific body of work, with her performance in “My Brilliant Career” being an Aussie New Wave classic in particular.

Hasan Ahmad

I did not laugh so hard for a long time when George said "So the relationship is cooked" . such timing it shocked simone

Captain Kermit

The TNG cast has been together for 7 seasons and 4 movies. Around 15 years of working together, and they've worked together sporadically after that. We've been very lucky. Sir Patrick is the first main TNG cast member or big guest star that we've lost. Unfortunately, we have lost Commander Darren from Lessons, and Patti Yasutake who was Nurse Ogawa. R.I.P. Patrick Stewart

Captain Kermit (edited)

Comment edits

2026-11-12 05:00 Yes, there is a worse episode of TNG. Lessons is obviously not it. Fortunately we got possibly one of the best episodes, IMO, but, unfortunately, one of the most emotional episodes after Sir Patrick's death.
2026-11-11 13:31 Yes, there is a worst episode of TNG. Lessons is obviously not it. Fortunately we got possibly one of the best episodes, IMO, but, unfortunately, one of the most emotional episodes after Sir Patrick's death.

Yes, there is a worst episode of TNG. Lessons is obviously not it. Fortunately we got possibly one of the best episodes, IMO, but, unfortunately, one of the most emotional episodes after Sir Patrick's death.

Thall

Yea.. right with you there Simone. It had to be THAT episode of all the ones still ahead of us.

Levi Curry

Thank you for all the treasured memories, Captain. Hailing frequencies closed, Sir.

Thall

WOW GEORGE, you took the "to boldly go where no one has gone before" to HEART. Jesus Christ my guy. I love it, it's so horrible to make that joke. 🤣 Well done

ChiefKC

Star Trek Day! Picard, at rest.

Gryff

Jeeze, what an episode to land on for the one immediately after Sir Patricks passing. This was already a deeply emotional episode for a lot of Trek fans.

Pokes

I think Daren's close call was simply the final straw to any kind of notion that they could make a relationship between a superior and subordinate work. She didn't want to have to second guess other's feelings/decisions related to her, and Picard realized that he wouldn't be able to put her in harm's way ever again. Their careers were too important to them to continue on in a situation that undermined their ability to perform to the best of their abilities.

dc

I also think "Lessons" would have been better-served as an arc as opposed to a standalone episode. That said, it's one of my favorite episodes—kind of the counterpart to "Family" where Picard processes the trauma of a previous episode. Definitely a fine performance by Patrick Stewart. I'm with Simone on this; his loss hit harder than I even expected, like I lost an extended family member.

Rob Steere

What a great first episode to have after his passing. Also, how prescient was the joke "We'll go rewatch the one where he plays the flute"

Rob Steere

Majel Barrett passed a number of years ago.

Captain Kermit

I'm sorry. You are right. I did forget about Majel Barrett and obviously Roddenberry. She would be the first big guest star.

Jimazoid

This is why I love watching you both! I must have seen TNG many time over the years and I've NEVER EVER noticed the hands of Picard playing the Flute before!

Jon

The novels are interesting, the Left Hand of Destiny duology is one of my favorite. They might all be "canon" but they don't feel very cohesive going from series to series. While I enjoyed many of the Star Trek novels, I definitely preferred the Star Wars Legends, partly because of the cohesiveness they had over the Trek ones.

gfixler

I hope our Mozart in 200 years is Tim Minchin.

TalynOne

I've always hated The Chase it made the galaxy feel small with little to discover. Oh great, another bumpy forehead, we just discovered our brother/sister exists.

Gryff

39:53 I have observed that joining Starfleet is seldom solely dependent on altruism. It represents fantastic opportunities unavailable anywhere else from survival as a refugee to use of the most advanced equipment in the galaxy. So less of a life for money exchange more of a ' Gotta risk it for the biscuit' situation, whatever that biscuit may be for someone.

PIG

Shit. I teared up when Simone teared up.

Monica Alarcon

I've read more than a hundred star trek novels. No, they are not canon. The earlier ones (like pre-2000) are not even consistent with other novels. When all the shows ended after Enterprise they started a Relaunch which became known as the litverse. That was much more coordinated and a great read but they ended that when Discovery and Picard were announced. They started a new series of novels that at first were deemed canon but then the very first one was contradicted by the second season of Discovery. Still there are some really really good novels that expand or explain stuff from the series without contradicting it. I've recommended several in the comments and I've been wanting to make a blog or something that serves as a guide to essential Star Trek novels that can be read without contradicting the canon.

John Miller

The military has regulations against fraternization, for the exact reasons they showed in this episode. It's not about emotional maturity. It's about chain of command. The main issue shown was how Picard acted toward her almost dying. But it also showed the issues with the crew. Riker felt uncomfortable. And though Picard told him not to, those types of issues would still be their. Imagine someone other than Riker who needed something and didn't get it because Picard gave preference to his girlfriend. It wouldn't matter if it were justified, there would always be a sense of impropriety with some people. And you can't have that in a military chain of command.

The Real Andrew Kim

Just so everyone knows, I'm not crying the whole time....YOUR ALL CRYING THE WHOLE TIME!!! but seriously, just like picard in the episode fearing his music will no longer bring him joy, I don't think I can hear that flute melody ever again without ugly crying....

REDR58

Simone and George, you talked about watching older things where the entire cast is now dead. With Nosferatu, 1922, Loni Nest, who played a child in the movie, was the last cast member to die, aged 75. https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/125622008/loni-nest For Citizen Kane (1941), the last cast member to die was Kathryn Trosper Popper who played a reporter who asked “What’s Rosebud?” near the end of the movie. She passed at age 100 in 2016. She was also Welles’ assistant. https://www.dailymail.com/news/article-3484314/Last-living-Citizen-Kane-cast-member-Orson-Welles-longtime-personal-assistant-dies-aged-100.html

supwizy

Fun fact for george: Mass effect 1 (and a little bit of 2) was originally designed as a star trek game but seeing as they didnt want/could get the license they just made it a original thing. Sadly very much like star trek due to management influences the series switched from politics in space to action star warsy. the outside meddling got so bad that the original founders left bioware(one of the biggest reason all bioware games after ME2 were less and less RPG and more action adventure).

John Miller

The Progenitors (ancient humanoids) do exist in non canon books, comics and stories. And not to spoil anything, but they do show up in canon Star Trek. But not for a long long time.

Joe Concepts

It will add something extra to the movie. And if the story includes a very LAST appearance of Xavier, it will be more emotional than it would've been.

Kansas City Shuffler

I would love you guys to react to Jeffrey (1995) in honor of Patrick Stewart’s passing. Apparently he took the role in that film because he instructed his agent after TNG ended, “Get me a role that is as far from Star Trek as possible.”

Gryff

1:32:30 This shelf has no honor!

REDR58

Wendy Hughes (Daren) was born in Melbourne and died far too soon in 2014 from cancer, aged 61.

Robert Cooper

The. Chase is one I remember seeing in highschool. My chem teacher was a big fan and we both loved this one. Biggest retcon ever.

Adam Morgan

The novels are "Beta Canon" whilst the TV shows and movies are "Alpha Canon". Typically, something in Beta Canon is considered canonical, unless and until it is contradicted by Alpha Canon. Alpha Canon overrides everything else. Star Trek fandom has landed on a system with four levels of canon. Alpha Canon covers all the on-screen stuff -- every show and movie, whether live action or animated (although the 70's animated series is debated), and whether broadcast, streamed or theatrical. Beta Canon covers all the licensed media -- this is where the novels sit, but it also includes comics, video games, roleplaying games, technical manuals, etc. Gamma Canon covers official but off-screen stuff -- script notes, unfilmed scenes, interviews with writers, production reference material, etc. Delta Canon covers fanworks -- fanfiction, fan films, fan theories, etc. Sometimes things can be promoted between levels. Historical and biographical details are often sourced from beta and gamma canon when writers need something to fill out their latest alpha canon project. For example, Lt. Uhura's first name, Nyota, comes from beta canon. More recent Trek does this a lot more with more distinct things. Without spoilers: one of the villains used in Discovery comes from a novel series; some ships from beta canon (novels, games, etc) appear in shows like Lower Decks and Picard; some objects in the Vulcan system (like its moon) were originally delta canon but got used in Discovery and Strange New Worlds.

CouchCheese

For years I would say that Benjamin Sisko was my favorite Star Trek captain, but Picard was my first, since TNG was my Trek growing up. I think the latter distinction is more valuable though -- Picard was a role model in my formative years. There's no replacing that kind of impact, and a huge part of that was due to Patrick. Rest well, mon capitan.

TechJJ

Those arms! :-O George: "Always classical". Well, there is a metaphorical comparison that sometimes can be literal between Star Wars and Star Trek. If Star Wars is: Rock n Roll, then Star Trek is: Classical Music. This is consistent to also say Trek shows are more cerebral. Those who appreciates classical arts are considered "cultured" and therefore lots of Trek fans! :-) Inner Light Suite - a must in my playlist of "Classicals"

Sven Ketelhut

There are great and crappy Star Trek novels, but they have one thing in common: they aren't canon. Not. A. Single. One! Couldn't be, because a lot of novels have contrasting, incompatible information in them and even cotradict the TV-Shows/movies Not even the novilizations of episodes or movies that expand the plot or give more information. In Star Trek there are two types of canon: - Alpha Canon: everything that you see on TV or the movie screen --> TOS, TAS, TNG, DS9, VOY, ENT, DIS, LD, PRO, SNW and the movies. That's the official canon and screenwriters have to follow it (though there are mistakes and retconning going on) - Beta Canon: everything in novels, tech-manuals, PC-games, RPG sourcebooks, games and so on. Nice to have, but non of it is alpha-canon and can be completely ignored by sreenwriters. That said: there are a lot of great ST-Novel's I (and probably other Star Trek fans) can recommend and I (the Q-Continuum series is great, though it takes place during the last seasons of Voyager, or Q² is also great). And you might wanna look into Star Trek Adventures, it has a much, much better RPG-Rule-System than Dungeons & Dragons. By light-years as D&D is one of the worst RPG-systems I ever played. And shares it's basic rule-system with the Fallout and Dune RPGs :-)

Colin Reid

If you’re sad about the passing of the great man, just remember N.E.R.D. No-one ever really dies. At least not people like Sir Patrick Stuart. He lives on in his art. As long as there is Star Trek, there is Picard. As long as there is Picard, there is Sir Patrick Stuart. Long live Sir Partrick.

fforw

52:40 I'm kind of with George and the cop-out/reset thing. Yes, Picard was compromised in that situation, but it's not as if there are no alternatives here. If she was security chief or something, the danger is intrinsic, but she is the chief of stellar cartography. When we will she ever be in such a danger again? And why can't Picard give Riker or Data command for those mission if it should ever happen again?

Kansas City Shuffler

I am actually not a fan of the episode, “The Chase.” But there is an interesting bit of science fact here on earth. Blue Whales are known to breed with other species of baleen whales, and there is a significant amount of evidence that Blue Whale-Fin Whale hybrids are reproductively viable, including an autopsy on a pregnant hybrid. But curiously, Blue Whales are not even the most close relatives to Fin Whales based on genetic studies—Humpback Whales share a closer common ancestor. Recent genetic studies suggest that both species simply evolved genetic traits that make them sexually compatible by chance. What’s more, the genomes of North Atlantic Blue Whales show this has been occurring between the species for several thousand years. The implication to this is it is chemically possible, though highly improbable, for alien species with enough genetic similarities to be so similar that they are reproductively viable.

Johann Gambolputty de von Ausfern-schplenden-schlitter-crasscrenbon-fried-digger-dingle-dangle-dongle-… von Hautkopft of Ulm

Patrick Stewart, in addition to being an incredibly talented actor and a wonderful human being, was funny as hell. I loved it when he hosted Saturday Night Live and showed he had an equal gift for comedy. He was also hilarious in a small role in LA Story which I hope George and Simone react to. Also, if you would like an evil portrayal by Sir Pat, check out Green Room.

Christian Rennie

Yes, but I only read one novel and it was way back when the series was still going. "Vendetta" by Peter David, which was really good featuring the Borg and Guinan's race's history with them. It was like published just after the Best of Both Worlds as sort of a tie in to that two-parter.

Captain Kermit

I've read a few novels. I actually purchased around 300 ST novels at a yard sale in September. I've sold some of them on eBay, but I still have the first 30 numbered TNG novels. I haven't sold them yet. I'd love to read them someday, but I'm not a fast reader.

Captain Kermit

I've always struggled with Star Trek and Star Wars books. I've read a few, but I'm not a fast reader and both book franchises are slower reads than normal for me. However, I bought around 300 ST books a couple of months ago at a yard sale. I've sold some of the non-TNG series, but I still have a ton of TNG books, including the first 30 numbered in a row. I really want to read them, but I suck at how slow I actually read.

StonyD

I don't know. Maybe I process grief differently. I grew up with Picard being "my generation". Kirk was my Dad's and Picard was mine. And I loved every second of Picard (until the show "Picard S1 and S2" and couldn't watch that revisionist trash) and Pat Stew's acting throughout the franchise. But, when I heard he passed I thought "Well he was 86 or so" so it wasn't this "tragic shock" that I see others expressing. He was done playing Jean-Luc Picard. We were never going to see him in Trek again for any substantial reason. Jean-Luc's story was over with Ps3. So, I guess I don't understand the tragedy of his passing. I respect and honor and have such fond memories of his work. And even better, I can watch TNG any time I want and see Picard. But I didn't know Patrick Stewart, the man. I don't know if he was a "good person" or a "bad person". He was just a really amazing actor. So, bittersweet he has left us. But, I honestly never expected to "see" him again. I'm not his friend. I'm not a family member. I never worked with him. And Picard, as far as I believe, died in his sleep surrounded by family at some point. So, I kind of wonder why so many people are feeling actual grief over his passing, versus just acknowledging that everyone dies and we have so much to celebrate about his life. I think maybe people muddle his character of Picard with the actor Stewart. Maybe that's it. But there was a definite difference between them. And while I love Picard......I don't feel sad at the actor's passing. He wasn't young. He wasn't robbed of a life. He accomplished more than many and will be as immortal as all the other Trek actors, via his character. And Jean-Luc Picard will continue to be with us forever.

REDR58

“Masaka is waking!”

REDR58

Lessons George, TNG frequently uses Classical music (and sometimes Jazz) because it’s easier for licensing as you guessed. Also to make it timeless. Starfleet needs drones and also robust underground shelters in these crazy fire planets if they insist on putting people in such hellscapes. George, these sorts of resets from this kind of episodic TV at the time are very typical. TNG doesn’t really have an overarching story and there really isn’t that much character growth. As I’ve gotten older I much prefer season-long story arcs in TV series. DS9 will have more of that, as does Babylon 5, its contemporary.

Christian Rennie

I’d say Vendetta is worth it. I’m a slow reader too. Like 25 pages an hour-ish. So it’s like two hours for a 50 page session. So Vendetta would probably just take about a week-ish

Hammond of Texas

Thank you for allowing us to share and process our collective grief.

Fedora The Explorar

I agree with your criticism of Lessons. The reason for breaking up feels unearned and that they just wanted to hit the status quo.

Dan

Lessons: I agree that the break-up seems weird because it must be so rare for someone in Stellar Cartography to be at risk like that. And in-universe the base level risk of being on board must be perceived as pretty low otherwise they wouldn't have children just living on-board. It also seems weird that the Enterprise is so different between day and night shifts. It's a big ship with a massive crew and no consistent exterior day/night cycle. Plus encounters in space and other evens must happen at all times of "day". I'd expect it to be much more of an always-on 24 hour operation rather than more limited operations at "night". (Also it seems very strange that Picard wouldn't meet a new Commander on his ship for a week!)

Vinnero

The federation is made up of many deferent species with several non humanoid with 150 plus member worlds., so 17 none federation crew members seems about right

djKENTO

The Star Trek novels are not canon... and if I'm being honest as some one who read a LOT and i mean A LOOOOT of them in high school and college they are mostly throw away stories that wouldn't make for a good episode. there are exceptions of course... but they're definitely not canon. Especially not STAR TREK THE NEXT GENERATON - X-MEN: PLANET X. that's a real novel. it's as terrible as you think

Cc Decc

Babylon 5 > DS9. Just saying. And perhaps the first genre or other show to pioneer the Game of Thrones idea of a complete story arc prewritten and preplanned entirely out before the show even began. IMO its entirely a superior way to structure a show if you can stay on air long enough to complete the story. Moments from every episode have payoffs later on. Characters move and change. The plot reveals itself as you go, and big episodes have massive consequences. Nothing "resets to factory default" episode to episode. Its also why I consider its ending episode perhaps the greatest TV show finale I've ever seen. It wasn't one hour's worth of drama, it was a payoff 5 years in the making. In TNG, Lessons is powerful for some of those same reason. Picard gets to remember trauma and grow and not just forget everything when the hour is up.

parker469a

I feel like the only modern music that is complex is video game music. It's pretty much the only full orchestral with full choir etc. is that complex.

MacGuffinStuff

Simone getting teary got me. I'm just going to have to rewatch these episodes I was distracted, they were great, but yeah, still bummed. Last week or so have been a rollercoaster: bad news, ¡good news!, bad news again in my personal life. It is going to be different every time I see Sir Patrick now. Shameless plug for Excalibur, I kind of assume maybe you've both seen it, but I would still love to see a reaction to that movie regardless, Patrick Stewart has a relatively small part but he's still so awesome! He's so Shakespearean, and a total badass.

REDR58

I've read a handful of the TNG novels. I had "Survivors," "Imzadi" and "Ghost Ship" and maybe a few more but recall nothing about them. What I remember most about some Star Trek books is some of the truly odd-looking depictions of the various actors with some of the cover art, many of which you can look through here: www.coverbrowser.com/covers/star-trek-books The Trek books subreddit is worth. look through, but as always, be warned of spoilers. www.reddit.com/r/trekbooks/ \ Also, “Ghost Ship” features an upside down rendition of a Battlestar from the original Battlestar Galactica TV series!

REDR58

And here is that X-Men/TNG Marvel comic crossover. It’s from 1998 and coincidentally features Patrick Stewart’s likeness of Picard interacting with Xavier, though Stewart’s Picard is not on the cover.

REDR58

Ugh, meant to reply to djKENTO about the TNG/X-Men comic here, but accidentally made a new post above.

REDR58

I generally agree. I really like DS9, even more than TNG, but BS9 is really something special. It is by no means perfect but it has some really amazing characters who go through all sorts of fascinating changes, as you say. It really is a character-driven show. I really hope S&G check it out here.

REDR58

The Chase This episode is directed by Jonathan Frakes. Simone and George, you didn't recognize Special Appearance guest star Norman Lloyd! He played the Headmaster in Dead Poets Society (and the actor lived to be 106, dying in 2021): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TCfZ0WXeQXs Yridian is same race as the alien Jaglom Shrek (played by James Cromwell) that recently met with Worf in "Birthright Part 1." No explanation at all for why the Yridian destroyer was accidentally destroyed when Worf tried to disable it? Whoops, I guess. Wonder if Picard bothered to even note it in his log! “This is not part of a natural design…” Gah! Geordi, come on! That is a meaningless statement and you should know better! This episode has some interesting ideas but everything happens WAY too fast for such a grandiose and epic concept and then to top it off, Picard's tricroder is somehow physically modified by this ancient computer program to be able to emit a holographic image! AHH!!!!!, a (proto?) Founder!

Data Cable

And now I'm imaging Data absently muttering the lyrics to "Pope Song" while performing mundane tasks.

Data Cable

I had thought we lost the youngest of TOS and eldest of TNG a few days apart, but Takei is actually the younger than Koenig by about 7 months.

Joseph Schiller

"The Chase" reminds me of the Stargate TV show

Patrick - Excelsior

A modern musical composers that I feel will be our Bach would be John Williams. His work is complex and beautiful.

Patrick - Excelsior

One George, you made an errorenious assumption. In universe on the 6 seasons we have watched, 6 years has gone by. So, on average, 2 weeks go by in univesre per episode. They are having life and death situations every other week. Also, since season 1 episode 1 of TNG, about 60 crew members have died that we know of on screen. I'm sure there are many more than that off screen like we had here where 8 crew members died. That's 6% of the ships crew. That means there is a greater than 1 in 20 chance of dying on the ship. The conflict and worry by any great man/woman would be very high.} In fact, that's why in the military, spouses in which both serve are forbidden to serve under one another. To avoid these conflicts of interest. I also, as someone that served and faught in the military, that self doubts about your ability to order loved ones in situations where they are very likely to die is not cowardice in any way.

Patrick - Excelsior

620 SO the Kurlan's believe an indivual was comprised of many voices inside them represnting different aspects of there personality, otherwise known as Inside Out (2015).

gfixler

Watching again, I picked up on something I didn't in the distant past. The being in the ancient recording mentioned seeding planets in their local area, so not the whole galaxy. It was actually a very small fraction thereof. More questions than answers now, unfortunately.

Guts

I love "Lessons". It's to "The Inner Light" what "Family" Is to "Best of Both Worlds".

DanTurismo

George: You asked about everything taking place in our galaxy. Outside of a few rare episodes where they do crazy distance jumps, yes, everything is in our galaxy. Specifically, the show splits our galaxy into four 'quadrants' (Alpha, Beta, Gamma, and Delta), and TNG is set pretty much on the line between Alpha and Beta quadrants. Federation space is mostly Alpha quadrant. Cardassian, Bajoran, and Ferengi space is also Alpha Quadrant. Klingon and Romulan empires are Beta quadrant. The Borg come from the Delta quadrant.

DanTurismo

With you mentioning Vash: Found out this week that apparently Patrick Stewart had an affair with the actress that plays Vash, and it ended his first marriage. They were together for a while during the time the show was on, and were engaged at the time of QPid (the Robin Hood episode), but never got married.

Michael Daw

A thousand years later they're playing the long-dead Ressikan folk melody. The most beautiful thing.

Lex Kuzma

Regarding what music today will be viewed the same way classical music is now, there's a lot of very complex music being made today. It's sad you ended your music reaction efforts or you'd probably have heard some by now. I recommend Descending by Tool as a good example.

Matt Okeefe

Maybe this was mentioned in Dead Poets Society comments as he was in that too,but Professor Galen was played by Norman Lloyd. He looked fairly old in this episode. He just died in 2021. He lived to be 106. And he was not British as his voice(accent) kind of seemed to indicate. He was American.

Guts

TNG took us outside the milky way in season 1.

Logan Kerlee

My mom died recently, dementia was a big part of it all. Terribly depressing but at the same time I’m thankful for the time that I had with her.