Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Go to this site: Cinebingers.ca for the unedited versions of all our content.

👉 https://cinebingers.ca/SxCfAGCGB9 👈 for the full reaction where you do not need your own copy.

👉 https://cinebingers.ca/2i2jiXUEF5 👈for the full reaction where you need your own copy.

If you are on a phone/tablet, hold down the link above and press "open in browser", or go straight to Cinebingers.ca on your browser app.

Files

Comments

Actuarial Lurker

Amok Time- Spock in Heat. Pan Farr. The very old woman T/Pau officiating is shown as a young woman in the Series "Enterprise" in the 2150s showing how Vulcans live to be 180+ years old. In Universe Humans routinely live to be in their 130s due to health care advances. T'Pau is one of the most important philosophers and political figures in Vulcan history- I won't say more to avoid spoilers.....

Actuarial Lurker

Chekhov was added to the crew to show that the Earth was united including Russians. They also made him a young guy since it was the same time that "The Monkeys" were popular as a boy band" and the studio was trying to get teenage girls to watch the show thinking he would be a "heartthrob"

Amos T Fairchild

Nice to finally get Chekov and Sulu on the bridge together.

Actuarial Lurker

So the Greek gods WERE real- but aliens who left Earth when people stopped believing in them. Apollo is played by actor Michael Forest who is still alive at 95... I'm not into anime BUT his official bio sys he is a MAJOR anime voiceover actor- wonder if George or Simone know him from that....

Da Big Appa

Now you guys can watch the movie The cable guy.

Actuarial Lurker

This episode has gotten mediocre ratings since it is essentially a rehash of Squire of Gothos- an Alien with lots of power linked to a power source- ship destroys power source- bad guy defeated- other than Trelane being a "spoiled kid" and Apollo being a spoiled Greek god, same story arc- except the idea that ancient religions were alien visitoprs playing to a common conspiracy theory/trope- also rehashes part of Space Seed- weak woman historian is in S&M with Khan and weak woman classicist here seduced by S&M like Apollo

Sergio Meira

Aaand we get the first ever Pon Farr episode. Ah, the deep, deep lusts of the Vulcans...

Amos T Fairchild

And yes. Walter Koenig wore a wig early on. It was for the younger audience apparently. Looked like the Beatles or the Monkees or whatever.

Happy Hanukkah

Is that a god or a very naughty boy?

mky

Woohoo, Amok Time! Lirpa lirpa lirpa...I just like saying "lirpa".

Brandon

The actor that plays the Vulcan that wanted to be T'Pring's champion played a Romulan back in 'Balance of Terror'. I could have SWORN that Spock's father Sarek appears in this episode, but I totally misremembered it. Sarek's played by Mark Lenard, who also appeared in 'Balance of Terror' as the Romulan commander that squares off with Kirk. He ended up playing the character Sarek for years in the original series, the films and even a few times in Star Trek TNG. I think they mentioned previously that they would like to see these episodes with the older original effects... but I think they already are watching the older version? When they arrive on Vulcan in 'Amok Time' there's shots in the version I'm watching on Netflix that are different. There's a wide shot of the crew walking across a high land bridge that isn't in the version they're watching in the reaction. Their version just has an extended shot of the crew walking on a very obvious set. Despite the shot differences, the episode still remained in sync. The remastered version took the time to give us a better idea of what the terrain of Vulcan actually looks like from above. Also the exterior shot of the Enterprise passing Vulcan has way more detail in the remastered version on Netflix - there's is just a red cloudy ball with not much detail at all. So it's definitely the original version they're watching. I can't wait until they get to 'Doomsday Machine' later in the season. It's a favorite of mine AND the effects shots are quite different between the original and remastered versions.

3dbadboy1

Lol they wanted a Davy Jones on the show as well as a Russian.

Zinphad

Have always held the belief that the original title was Spock Amok

dc

You two are definitely watching the original effects. I honestly wish the original affects were available on streaming in the US—the remastered editions, though a labor of love, fall short for me. Also, yes! They add the vocals for Season 2. I believe it's Nichelle Nichols, who plays Uhura, who sings them! We always called the vocals "the Star Trek singers". 🤣

REDR58

Fortunately the new visual effects don’t seem to affect the length of the episodes.

REDR58

Yes as mentioned elsewhere here they are absolutely watching the original visual effects. Amazon Prime in the US has the revamped effects as well, and if you buy the Blu-ray set for TOS you can choose which version to watch. They are all on the same discs.

Monica Alarcon

Amok time is awesome! The mood, the music, the fight. Who Mourns for Adonais is not as good but it's also a classic and it sets up a great storyline in Star Trek: New Frontier...

Monica Alarcon

Also finally Chekov!! He's my favorite. And he's here to stay. Actually according to Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan he was already there...

dc

"Amok Time" is one of my favorites. It has such strong writing. Leonard Nimoy's acting is top-notch here. I have always loved his response to T'Pau's "Live long and prosper"—"I shall do neither. I have killed my captain, and my friend." It's so emotional, while still so Vulcan. The music helps too—the episode is known for the iconic fight music, but the motif that's played on the bass throughout the episode, and at the end while Spock is talking with T'Pau, it's absolutely perfect. Also, the phrase "having is not so pleasing a thing as wanting. It is not logical, but it is often true"...extraordinarily well said.

3dbadboy1

It was the 60s, a lot of things could have been better (the title, etc). To add to your joke, Stonn was a-Stonn-ished that kirk was killed.

mky

For a long time, I used the "Amok Time" combat theme music as my ringtone...except I used a version featuring Joel and the Bots from MST3K. :)

3dbadboy1

FYI, the Anglican (lazy ol' 'Murican English) pronunciation of Adonais is Adonis, lol.

Monica Alarcon

In the Eugenic Wars novels he was already on the Enterprise but he was not bridge crew yet. He leads a revolt against Khan...

Monica Alarcon

Oh yeah. Chekov did wear a wig at first because his hair wasn't long enough for the Davy Jones look they were going for... It's much more noticeable in some early episodes...

dc

I'm guessing that's because it would have thrown off the audio track?

Mark Barger

I’m really glad you’re continuing with the series.

Mark Barger

And if you’re looking for another short series, has anyone mentioned HBO’s “Deadwood”? Short and incredibly well-acted and I would love to see your reactions to some western-themed shows.

Raven Dark

Haha, that would have been hilarious. I would have loved it.

Simone's Coconut Squire

As to the title of the first episode, if you swap the word emphasis it works better. It looks like it should be "amok TIME" but if you say "AMOK time" it makes more sense. E.g. "Oh look, it's 4:30, it's my amok time"

dasgrove

As a fellow CR fan, I want to thank Simone for tying two things I love together in a single video

Actuarial Lurker

George has recognized the over-used fight music!. Simone and George- if you pay attention ALMOST EVERY episode uses the same quirky music for a hand-to-hand fight, an encounter/battle with an alien, the backing track while they are going around with search parties on a planet, when there is a "Kirk getting it on with an alien woman" scene etc

Actuarial Lurker

Hey if you had to wait 7 years to get some action you would be in deep lust too...

Cory Garron

I can't wait for next week. I remember seeing episode 4 back in the mid-, maybe early 90s, and really liking it. It was late at night, and I couldn't sleep. I think I've seen it once since and was very "meh" on it.

Kurt Hockenbury

You know what gets me sometimes? How some of the antagonists get done in by their own impatience. Imagine if Apollo had just said "Hi there, I am the Apollo, yes, the one from Greece in the days long ago. Great to see you guys again! I would like to invite you, or any members of your race, to come live here on this planet with me, where you can herd sheep, play the pipes, and worship me." First off, historians would be tripping over themselves to get there to interview him. Second, such an invitation sent out to the Federation could easily appeal to far more than the 430 crew aboard the ship, if even 1 in a million persons thought "hey, you know that sounds pretty good to me". Instead it's "Finally! You are here! I'm going to force all of you to settle here and worship me, and I'll destroy your ship so you can't leave."

Alan Kobb

There is a story behind the addition of Ensign Checkov, the Russian helmsman. During the first season, the Russian newspaper, Pravda, printed an article criticizing Star Trek for not having a Russian character because the Russians were the first to get to space and had many achievements in the Space Race. The story goes that Roddenberry would include a Russian character, but would make him "VERY" proudly Russian. We're not 100% sure that this story is true, but it's a fun story regardless.

JBK405

Pavel Chekov's inclusion came from three-fold behind the scenes reasons (Two of which were already mentioned in other comments): 1) They wanted a younger crew member who could tap into the current pop culture. Specifically resembling the actor/singer Davy Jones from "The Monkees". 2) They wanted to show a Russian character on the bridge as part of the message that this is a united humanity working together. 3) Since the Soviet Union was the other major participant in the Space Race (And may have even been said to be winning the Race at that time), to NOT have a representative from any Soviet country was viewed as an insult given the premise of the series. ---------------- Several of the props and costumes used in the Vulcan ceremony were re-used from the Romulan props in "Balance of Terror" (Most noticeably the helmets worn by the background characters). Strictly speaking this is just a coincidence -- in both instances they needed to cover their ears so they wouldn't need to go to extensive makeup for a dozen background extras -- but it does make a lot of sense with the idea that Romulans are a long-lost offshoot of the Vulcan people. If these costumes are part of ancient Vulcan customs predating their current society, then the Romulans might have taken them with them when they first left the planet.

REDR58

And that actor who played “Decius” in “Balance of Terror” and “Stonn” here was named Lawrence Montaigne.

Badger

George goes from saying Vulcan Spunk (great band name BTW) to "that was a poem" by someone I have never heard of..such funny!

Robert Evans

"In a pig's eye' is a slang phrase for something impossible or unbelievable. "I had lunch with Speilberg. 'In a pig's eye'" it's principally American and has fallen out of favor but was still common in the 60's.

Dee Aitch

It's kinda nutty that y'all are enjoying the same campy TV show that I watched religiously after school as a kid. Maybe there's something magical about it and not simply something that a scifi starved child could only enjoy. Also nice to see that you can accept the horrible views on women. Simone does have an idea of how the show did progress with the times. And they do try to counter the stereotypes that the lean into with the counterexamples of Uhura and Chapel (somewhat, she can be a bit weepy as well). Also, I don't even wanna think about how they would have "improved" the shots of the giant hand holding the Enterprise. So glad y'all are watching original effects.

djKENTO

The remastered versions are actually REALLY great. They look era appropriate. It’s not glaring terrible CGI like the Star Wars Special editions. They try to make it look like it could have been done in the era if they had the time and budget. Here’s the comparisons. They also don’t change the timing of the show at all. https://youtu.be/8N0OvJOXJy0?si=8B_KsGxANLilyWr-

Ron

If you guys are interested, there is a fan film sequel to this episode called, Pilgrim of Eternity. It's the first episode of the Star Trek fan series, Star Trek Continues. This episode is notable because they got the same actor, MIchael Forest, to reprise his role as Apollo. It's also notable because one of James Doohan's sons, Chris, plays Scotty. It's available here on YT: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3G-ziTBAkbQ Update: Almost forgot to mention that the opening music with the operatic singing was originally intended to have lyrics which were written by Gene Roddenberry himself. It was Roddenberry's (unsuccessful) bid to get half of the royalties of the theme song.) I prefer it w/o lyrics. STAR TREK THEME LYRICS --------------------------------- Beyond The rim of the star-light My love Is wand’ring in star-flight I know He’ll find in star-clustered reaches Love, Strange love a star woman teaches. I know His journey ends never His star trek Will go on forever. But tell him While he wanders his starry sea Remember, remember me.

GAB

The line "Who mourns for Adonais" comes from the elegy "Adonais" published in 1821 by the poet Percy Bysshe Shelley. Shelley's second wife, Mary Wollstonecraft Shelley, wrote "Frankenstein; or, The Modern Prometheus" and was the daughter of the feminist philosopher Mary Wollstonecraft.

Michael Nemo

Watch the sequel episode in STAR TREK CONTINUES later on.

REDR58

Totally agree. I really like the remastered version. But it’s great to be able to choose.

gfixler

Amok! Amok! Amok! −Sarah from Hocus Pocus

gfixler

There's an interview with Nimoy, where he talks about coming up with the Vulcan hand "V" salute, for this episode. It's actually a very old Jewish sign, which he saw as a child in a ceremony in an orthodox synagogue with his grandfather. He says it was a revered moment, and you weren't supposed to look, and the rest of the people had their eyes closed, heads bowed, but he peeked, and saw the rabbis chanting and making that hand sign, arms extended. I just saw it again recently during the Democratic National Convention. The rabbi who came out to bless the ceremony did it, and everyone in every chat and comment thread everywhere asked if he was a Vulcan 😆 So Nimoy says that he was supposed to meet the most important Vulcan in the script of Amok Time, and just talking to her felt a bit lacking, so he asked if he could have some kind of salute, and remembered the sign he saw in the church as a boy, and the director liked it, so they just went with it. From Wikipedia: > In his 1975 autobiography I Am Not Spock, Nimoy, who was Jewish, wrote that he based it on the Priestly Blessing performed by Jewish Kohanim with both hands, thumb to thumb in this same position, representing the Hebrew letter Shin (ש in Square Script, or Paleo Hebrew 𐤔‎), which has three upward strokes similar to the position of the thumb and fingers in the gesture. The letter Shin here stands for El Shaddai, meaning "Almighty (God)", as well as for Shekhinah and Shalom.

Joe Concepts

That opening scene is one of those handful of weird sexist-seeming things in this series. Where it's usually progressive. Though just having a lot of women working as officers all over the ship WAS progressive for the time.

Joe Concepts

I appreciate the old effects, too. Definitely something "classic" about them. But I do think at least some of the remastered episodes work a little better because they now and then solve problems by showing some things the old series simply couldn't. Mostly in space scenes, like having some ship to ship fight scenes make more sense, etc.

Joe Concepts

I don't think the writers were concerned about getting the exact details of Greek mythology right for the audience George. But we appreciate your knowledge. :)

Joe Concepts

I believe that "leading a revolt" thing goes back even further to some of the 1980s Trek comic books.

Spacedone

They don't change the timing overall but there are some minor changes here and there that occasionally require a brief pause in one or the other video to sync up again.

Dee Aitch

I watched the comparison, and my fears were founded. They added a whole ass planet into the hand scene for no reason. And that CGI ship looks so horrible. Agree to disagree.

Robert Evans

That is a title of a 'Star Trek: Strange New Worlds' episode where Spock is having 'issues' with his heritage. He even has a nightmare fighting himself at the site of koon-ut-kal-if-fee to the same battle music.

gfixler

George: Weak-willed woman. Rita Vrataski: *does a push-up* George: *leaves friends and family behind forever*

SpankTheMonk

Soooooo excited that we/you are going right into Season 2!! 🎉🫶🖖. I think there are many science fiction tales of walking away from the gods. I know you haven’t watched Legend with Tom Cruise but there is a point where a figure like a god asks to be worshipped and engaged with. But as in Star Trek you are still captive to their desires.

SpankTheMonk

Also there is historical cultural context, Star Trek isn’t immune to their societal norms even when attempting/being progressive.

SpankTheMonk

I know Amok Time is well known and I believe popular, but to me it feels a little incongruent to the idea of Vulcans. But as I and others have mentioned the “Western in Space” had a quota of judo chops per season. And they were writing the “canon” of the aliens and universes live so to speak. Also it may seem obvious after, but having a unique alien species with their quirky culture, rituals, and needs would be kind of really important to know them before they could come on board- so they don’t shank your captain.

Zinphad

Thanks @Robert Evans, had not noticed that title (don't notice titles for most Trek shows).

Michael

I don’t know why you’re pronouncing it AMUCK time, it’s an O sounds like mock

Bombaatu

You guys should check out Star Trek Continues on YouTube. A really GOOD fan series that gives TOS a 'finale'. In one of them (mebby the first?), Michael Forrest reprises his role of Apollo.

GAB

"Amok" meaning "violent frenzy" or "disorder" is a Malay loan word brought back by 17th century sailors. It's also spelt "amuck", which is where the variant pronunciation comes from. According to Merriam-Websters dictionary: "Typically, the afflicted person (usually a man) attacked bystanders in a frenzy, killing everyone in sight until he collapsed or was himself killed."

Angzarr

I was laughing out load at your comments at the end of 202. I never thought of it that way, but you're right. Kirk is going to have SO MUCH paperwork to do!

Angela D. Mitchell

I really love "Adonais" -- it starts out seeming predictable but ends with that unexpected pathos, and Carolyn actually displays courage and intelligence, loyalty to her ship, and to science. This also includes two of my favorite guest actors on the show -- the wonderful Leslie Parrish, who was insanely beautiful and is a part of film history thanks to The Manchurian Candidate. Parrish is also a really cool person -- she was formally trained to be a concert pianist despite poverty, became model and then an MGM star in Hollywood, then stopped acting because she felt objectified, became a producer, and ended up doing a lot of brave work as a political activist, opposing the Vietnam War. She also married writer Richard Bach for 20 years -- a marriage he wrote about in "The Bridge Across Forever" and "One" (the books are super New Agey but she comes across like a really smart, cool person). Unfortunately, Bach was also an arrogant jerk, so she divorced him (he instantly hooked up with a woman 30+ years younger). She now lives on an island in the San Juan Islands up here in the Pacific Northwest and works tirelessly for conservation causes and creating wildlife sanctuaries. I remember Michael Forest, the guy who played Apollo, from several shows when I was a kid and teenager (yeah, I had a total crush), but he's continued to work across the years in that classic "working actor" way that I always respect, doing a lot of voice work. He's also had small roles in lots of things -- he was the pilot of the plane in "Cast Away," for instance.

Angela D. Mitchell

Oh, I would love for them to react to "Deadwood." It's the perfect length too -- just 3 short seasons and a movie. And what gorgeous dialogue and performances.