Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

CIVIL WAR: Tom Holland vs Toby Maguire's Spider-man

  • Tom Holland 103
  • Toby Maguire 42
  • 2021-08-31
  • 145 votes
{'title': "CIVIL WAR: Tom Holland vs Toby Maguire's Spider-man", 'choices': [{'text': 'Tom Holland', 'votes': 103}, {'text': 'Toby Maguire', 'votes': 42}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2021, 8, 31, 5, 28, 54, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 145}

Content

Let us be very clear, this is not a debate on which movies are better. It is not the MCU Spider-man films vs the Raimi Spider-man films.This is simply the better actor and casting at playing Peter Parker and Spider-man.The debate will taker place on the next As Always Podcast. We do not give you who takes what side on these polls to make this a personality contest. But I think you know where we stand on this one.See you next week. 

- Tyler

Comments

Artem

As usual, Garfield is ignored 😡

BrownJam

I think Tobey is the better actor but Tom is the better cast of the two, but the MCU did Peter dirty so it has to be Maguire for me.

Ethan Dean

I mean if it’s casting, it’s gotta be Holland. I love Tobes but it’s hard to suspend my disbelief in the 30 year old highschooler.

Hammid The Weeb

I am sorry but if you genuinely think that Tobey is the better Peter you genuinely have something wrong in your head. Not only did Tobey look like an old ass man playing as a teenager but there were times where I genuinely couldn't get through a scene because of the cringe. As for Tom Holland on the other hand not only does he suit the role perfectly, but he is a natural when it comes to playing Peter Parker. But ultimately Andrew Garfield is my favourite Peter Parker

Disciple NickZan

Tom is 100% a better cast, but I also think he's a bit of a dickhead. Not him as Peter, him as him.

Jake Ryan

Andrew Garfield is the right answer

Play The Rules (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-15 13:00 Clearly Andrew Garfield has the best performance but if I had to choose here, Andrew is clearly the best actor. Did I do it right? 😂
2021-08-31 08:19

Harrissey

Tobey for the fuckin winnnnn!!!

Jack Nicholls

Tom Holland is a better Spider-Man but Tobeys films are way better!

Zeda

I'm not normally one to bring up the "rose-tinted glasses" argument but it seems like it is the case for this one. I think Tom is the better actor and much better fits the age they wanted Peter to be for the films. Plus he is much more fun to watch than Tobey, who at some points is really not that great at acting in the trilogy. In terms of Spider-Man, I think Tom nails the youthful charisma, whereas Toby captures the heart of Spider-Man in a way we haven't seen with Tom yet. Ultimately I feel that Tom takes the cake

Nijima

Ooo this gonna be a banger episode, Tyler's gonna go all in on Tobey.

Deivid 4082

Spiderman PS4’s Peter Parker is the best Peter Parker