Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

For more than a decade, the investigation into the Gilgo Beach serial killings was stalled by corruption and apathy. But in 2022, a new task force would identify a clue that Suffolk County police had held in their possession since the very beginning of the investigation. A clue that would lead directly to the worst serial killer Long Island had ever seen…

Team:

Anonymous Host - narration

Erin Munro - research, writing

Mike Migas - production, music

Anthony Telfer - audio editing

Files

Comments

Miss Tury

Great research and reporting, as always. One minor correction: Theodore Heuermann served in the U.S. Army Air Forces (not the U.S. Air Force); the Air Force didn’t come into being until 1947.

Bob Trenwith

Sad that they regard a homicide clearance rate of 74% as good. Comparison between US and Australia: The US has 13 times Australia's population. The US has 6 times Australia's homicide rate. The US has a clearance rate of 50% compared to Australia's 90%. Together, these stats mean that the US has roughly 400 unsolved homicides for every 1 in Australia.

Chasing Amy in the Dark

Thank you! Can’t wait 🙏🤞🫠😇🫣🤦🏻‍♀️🤩😎💕✌️🍦

Gale Hogsten

Those poor families and I’m grateful the police and DA were all changed.

Kayla

I’ve been following the Gilgo Beach murders for years, and let me just say, you all did an absolutely amazing job clarifying each victim and breathing life and honor to them. This case is a doozy and the timeline is so long and complicated, but truly, excellent work. I can’t help but agree that Shannan’s death was a tragic accident, but the fact that she was also a sex worker and that her case led to the unraveling of such horrors is so strange and insanely coincidental. With the ongoing advances in forensic science, I can’t help but think about all the uncaught killers who lose sleep every single night, wondering when the truth will catch up to them.

Alan

Respectful and well-done. May they (and the families) rest in peace.

Charlie B

Move to Australia then?

Keely

You did so much more justice to the other victims (not those known as the Gilgo four) compared to the Netflix documentary gone girls. I finished that and immediately was thinking what about the others? They didn’t even mention them at the end. Thank you for that

A Kayyy

Felix find a good take challenge

Tessa

Why are you defensive about those stats lol

Bob Trenwith (edited)

Comment edits

2026-10-04 18:00 Huh? Defensive? That would first require someone to attack me. So NOW I am being defensive. Seriously ... you keep following me around like a mossie. Is it blood you're looking for?
2026-10-02 12:05 Huh? Defensive? That would first require someone to attack me. So NOW I am being defensive. Seriously ... you keep following me around like a mozzie. Is it blood you're looking for?

Huh? Defensive? That would first require someone to attack me. So NOW I am being defensive. Seriously ... you keep following me around like a mozzie. Is it blood you're looking for?

Tessa

I was actually defending you, Bob. I was referring to Charlie being defensive.

Bob Trenwith

The only comment I can see from Charlie B is "Move to Australia then?". There are two hidden comments, one of which will be mine. Not sure how you could see a comment that says "Comment hidden" for me.

Tessa

I genuinely don’t understand how I’ve become the bad guy in your mind? Charlie is literally telling you that if you don’t like it you should move to Australia, and I asked him why he’s so defensive about the homicide conviction rates in the US. The irony is that I have never actively disagreed with you Bob - I’ve actually liked several of your comments in the past because I frequently find myself agreeing with you. And yet you’ve called me a man hater and now a mozzie 😂 bzz bzz I guess

Bob Trenwith

I quoted from an episode: "Any criticism, especially when he considered it unjustified, stoked a deep-seated resentment and a craving for retribution . . . . lies became a defensive strategy he relied on to maintain control, while feeding him a smug sense of superiority." I suggested it sounded like DJT. In response you said that sounds like most men. My response to that was entirely justified. You would have reacted equivalently if I had made a general negative statement about "most women", and rightfully so. Nevertheless I apologise for triggering off your comment ... but it never occured to me that you could be referring to the other guy's comment, which I saw as innocuous. Perhaps we should both learn to address our comments in future. (I haven't addressed this one because there can be no ambiguity). BTW - I already live in Sydney's Lower North Shore, and would never consider even visiting America for a holiday. I see that as only slightly more appealing than taking a vacation to North Sentinel Island.

gia

incredible — one of my favorite casefile series yet ❤️