Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Downloads

  • RFRQandA_036.mp3
  • audio_preview.wav

Missing 1 full-res photo, 2 files, as this post has not yet been imported.

Content

When Emperor Palpatine returned in THE RISE OF SKYWALKER, was it a violation of the Force Spirit rules as according to George Lucas? Knowing what we know, should a Sith Lord even have the capability to achieve immortality? Rob Strecker is back on the Q&A to discuss everything about Palpatine returning, including his ability to transfer his spirit into another host. Plus, we have a well-timed email about this topic via Sean from Warsaw who has been debating Palpatine's return with his buddies. This show goes into some crazy directions when Rob asks about my most embarrassing on-air moment and how I met my wife Wendy. Rob also allows me to pull back the curtain and vent with no filter about some shady treatment our show has had to endure over the years, along with celebrating our successes. Plus, Rob's birds, The Wilhelm Scream 2.0, and more! - Jimmy Mac 

Files

Previews only

Comments

Jacob Roth

Great episode! Loved the rant at the end 😉

Sean W. from Warsaw

So I literally just woke up and checked my email, saw the title of this episode, and thought I must still be dreaming! (The bad part is is that I feel in one of those half sleep stupors where I'm slightly delirious already, but now even moreso with excitement!) Well timed indeed, Jimmy Mac! Can't wait to listen!

Blake Weaver

Thanks Jimmy for the Palpatine explanation from your point of view. It helped me wrap my head around how he came back. Doesn’t change my view of the stupid sequels but helped me find some peace of mind. And always enjoy the radio talk! Between my dad and grandfather there’s about 80 years of radio history in my family between Maryland, Colorado, New York, and DC! Grew up around the radio scene.

Sean W. from Warsaw

Great conversation, guys! I feel so honored and privileged to have had my email pop up like it did. Thanks to both of you for taking the time to really talk about the subject. Jimmy, I'd totally take your analysis to my friends, but it doesn't seem they want to talk about Palpatine anymore.... In fact, they've said as much directly. They're pretty disillusioned with it. But it's just so unfortunate to actually directly say "I don't wanna talk about it." I have some serious problems with the ST, but never to the point where I want to shut others out of conversation. That's just not the way to go about it. So that's in part why I sent the email! It's very cathartic to get analysis on this stuff, especially the controversial stuff. Very honored. Thanks so much!

Javier Solorzano

Great story about working in Radio Production.....about execs. loving to blame Production; same is true for Engineering. I am a Manufacturing Engineer & our Upper Exec. Management (who don't have a clue about "how" we do engineering w/ all the software & programming), LOVE to have something to blame an Engineer for. I truly believe its because on a daily basis they really don't do anything productive (except have meetings). BUT, if something goes wrong, then, WATCH OUT! NOW, they have something to do, & someone to blame. I guess that's almost all the same wherever you go.

Jeff

SW Theory is fun. I’d love to hear him on your guys show. You are the definitive SW podcast, and he is definitive SW tube channel. Let’s colloid the wars!

Steven M DuBrey

Jimmy, Jason, always stay independent. That’s why every one of us is here supporting what you do. I may not always agree with your opinions, but I trust you, and that’s more important. End of the day: fuck Lucasfilm. You guys were here supporting them when mainstream media had written off Star Wars.

Jeremy Hopper

I totally agree with JM that Kylo was already near death when he healed Rey, which is why he died. But I disagree that Rey was fully dead yet because otherwise her body would have vanished into the Force

Jeremy Hopper

Great explanation of the moment Rey took out Palpatine...it seems to me that Palpatine was playing the long game, always wanting new younger apprentices killing his current apprentice so that he would never be taken out. He preferred to be in prime control rather than having his spirit transfer along. The only reason his plan in 7-9 is to have a new Sith strike him down is because he has no other alternative

Steven M DuBrey

Not every Jedi disappears into the force. It requires training and preparation to transition directly to the spirit form.

Steven M DuBrey

At some point in some special features it was explained that it’s because he’s the chosen one, although Luke does burn his body ala Qui-Gon so we actually never see him transition into the force. Kylo could be written off as all Skywalkers get that free pass. 🤷🏻‍♂️

Jeremy Hopper

I just don't think it's that obtuse. The filmmakers consciously made Kylo IMMEDIATELY fade into the Force, but minutes before did NOT have Rey do that, despite her clearly being one with all the Jedi at that moment. The simplest explanation often maintains: that Rey was not fully dead, she had a bit of her life left and Kylo restored the rest to bring her strength, which took all that was left of him away.