Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Update April 19 2024: Turns out I am not actually trans and I am still genderfluid! I kind of knew that writing this post, but I refused to truly look into it as I wanted so badly for that chaotic arc of my life to end, so I pushed on ahead and hoped it would come true. It was heartbreaking when it wasn't, and my mental health collapsed for all of March 2024. Since then, I've gotten a handle on techniques hacking my synesthesia and sense of balance that let me somewhat control the genderfluid shifts, even if they falter in tough moments of dysphoria. If you need to lock my pronouns down, I am fem often enough that she/they pronouns are a safe assumption (even if the pronouns are still truly it's/complicated), but also... fuck/it, who cares? Gender is a rigged game I lose if I play by the rules, so I'm either not engaging as the only winning move it not to play, or I am penciling in my own rules of engagement.

Despite that contradiction with what the crux of this post was, most of it is still accurate and will not be edited as it still did a decent bit of what I wanted it to, such as... well, I was going to write a list of bullet points, but that's unnecessary. Just know that while I am making great strides, I am still on a personal journey to accept that it's okay to be masculine without an overall masculine gender identity (and that it's okay to have femininity without an overall feminine gender identity), that I'm not as emasculated of a man as I think I am because my feminized body (particularly my chest) doesn't define me, and that I don't need to feel ashamed that I only have limited femininity as a non-binary woman and shouldn't let myself feel pressured to seek out more than I have.

Edit February 19 2024: typo fixes, clarifying a few points, new drama!

Alright, let's do this again, but keep in mind...

Source: Gugure! Kokkuri-san


Hi folks, CaptainCaption here.

You probably know what this means. The genderfluid arc is over (or at least in the background enough that it isn't destroying me). <Author's Note: lol.> Exactly one year after realizing I wasn't cis, which is coincidentally both Valentine's Day and my grandpa's birthday (if you've read re:Dreamer's fourth anniversary, you know how much his legacy meant to me and how much weight I felt from the expectations that I'd match it), I'm finally accepting myself as a trans woman, She/Her and all (maybe She/They but that is something I will need to explore more with my therapist and by myself). <Author's Note: It's safe to default to Them/They or She/They for me.>

Unlike last time, I realize this isn't a jovial occasion worthy of celebrating or even to take lightly. I'm not here for a party; I'm here to explain things in a clear and confident voice despite my fears. I don't want congratulations for anything but finding the smallest bit of peace and mental stability for the first time in about a year and surviving so much bullshit to get here.

From my depressing Friday Updates and re:Dreamer's fourth anniversary release, you've likely seen that the last year of my life has been hell. Here's an incomplete list of how broken I've been and the topic of writing with 7 points that'll I'll elaborate on as we go:

  • I tried to kill myself at least three times (but when you lose track of that number, that's a sign that it's probably even worse than that). I'm not at liberty to explain the details of why I didn't commit suicide when I've been enraptured with the idea of finding an end to the pain and taking my exit to life before my health collapses from corticobasal syndrome, but it's not from my choice. My self-inflicted death will trigger unacceptable consequences and I won't be able to die at my own hand unless I am willing to sacrifice more than myself, and the person I am (whoever that is) can't do that. I want to share the worst day of my life to explain just how awful living at the bottom of a pit of despair can be.

  • I got hurt in vital areas and betrayed by those who I trusted and were close to me that left me with lasting trust issues, especially because the ways that I was belittled, insulted, and manipulated were done to hurt me and those doing so admitted to it during more heated moments. There's no ambiguity left. These people, who used to be friends I trusted enough to be my server mods, are malevolent toward me and I don't have a logical explanation for their behavior besides me not being who they wanted me to be and me not giving them more and more control of a hunting ground. As you'll see, no amount of control will ever be enough for people like this, and I'm tired of giving any. I just want to be left alone and for them to stop trying to control me, but thankfully, many wearing rapiers are afraid of goose-quills.

  • I saw an ugly dark side to a marginalized community I'd been trying my hardest to repent to as penance for earlier transphobia about 7-ish years ago (warning: that linked screenshot isn't pretty) that made me fundamentally question if this group I was fighting for was worth it when they accused me of transphobia while defending the worst of their actions against those who want to see them erased. I've been ashamed of thinking of myself as a trans woman because it means fitting into a Venn diagram circle of the same demographic as some of the worst people I have ever had the displeasure of meeting, especially when being transgender is so important to them that it is their identity, but despite everything, I still want to fight for trans rights. I'm just choosing the battleground on my own terms.

  • My brain became a muddled mess of conflicting memories and two incompatible identities, and I don't just mean the dream of my hypothetical life as a cis woman, wife, and mother as I try in vain to reconcile what I was in that dream and who I have to be in reality (more on that later). I've been splitting apart at the seams trying to be both a man and a woman with no control over the incontrovertible binary fact of my gender identity. Standing on shifting sands and working with sandcastles has left me with no stability to make progress on finding who I am, but that recent stability has come at a heavy price of a sad, lonely stillness that hasn't been worth what is ultimately a more difficult sidegrade to my life.

  • The blueprints of a life I can never have got implanted into my brain during a dream and the cognitive dissonance is splintering me worse than any chaos genderfluidity ever could. I'm in agony that life wasn't real, I feel like I had the cruelest joke possible played on me when I realized it never happened, and I'm bitterly disappointed that I didn't just die in my sleep instead of waking up and having to exist as me. A part of me got left in that dream that I can't get back, and I feel utterly insane for having to explain the circumstances because I have no words to truly explain the psychosis-inducing madness and sorrow I feel.

  • My physical health has been deteriorating as other scary and unwanted changes happen to my body caused by hormones. I've been cripplingly lonely yet I'm terrified of leaving my house lest someone notice what was happening to me. I've spent several days in bed afraid to pull the covers off and get up because it meant admitting my body existed and that I had to do more than think. The thought of making any social transition scares the shit out of me and my instincts are to go to extreme lengths to get out of that inevitability, but I know this is my last real chance to live as who I am, and I can't do that if I never go outside.

  • I've realized my parents are exactly who I thought they were and not who I wanted them to be. Living at home, there's been so little love and so much disappointment that I'm not who they wanted me to be that I feel nervous to be in the same room as them. My dad has been so cold and distant that even when we're in the same room he's not there with me. My mom has tried to out me (and even succeeded) a few times, not respecting me or my clear instructions of who can know or how to refer to me while blaming me for making her life more difficult. As painful as this is to admit and as scary as this is to take a chance on, whoever I will be in the future can't exist under their thumb.

So, let's break down my breakdown, rebuilding, and what comes next.


1. The Call of The Grave

There's no witty comment here. This just hurts and is sad.

Because of privacy concerns I am asking you all to please respect, I can't talk about the details about how I have nearly killed myself in the last year and why I haven't despite wanting to, so I'll instead ask you a blunt personal question and tell a personal story of comparable tragedy to stand in for why staying alive since my realization has been such a struggle for me.

Have you ever wanted to die by your own hand? And by that, I am asking you if you've ever wanted to just throw in the towel and give up even if you know that the end of your suffering also means an end to the wonderful gift of life you've been given and all the things that make life worth it?

I have. I got diagnosed with Parkinson's disease on my 21st birthday while at university. It was not only the single worst day of my life but almost my last one.

The diagnosis was later something else similarly awful, but it seemed conclusive at the time based on my family medical history, a SPECT scan, a PET scan, an MRI, and reviewing my symptoms. When I finally told my sister a few months ago about my better-fitting diagnosis of corticobasal syndrome and the process of how I first got misdiagnosed with Parkinson's disease, she instantly called foul for malpractice, but if anything, it was the opposite. This was a diagnosis that was only given after weeks of tests to thoroughly eliminate other causes for my symptoms of a sore and numb right shoulder and right pinky finger and shooting tingles in my right arm and wrist.

By this part of the process, I was starting to suspect something terrible was happening, and that this wasn't a simple but stubborn case of repetitive strain injury. After all, I'd been writing a lot of essays recently after switching majors away from Mechanical Engineering and what I'd always wanted to do after my OCD killed my ability to do math without second guessing myself and to Classics/Ancient Mediterranean History. That OCD diagnosis was fresh, and I better knew its symptoms and how to fight the ruminating anxiety, but I went into my campus health clinic for hand pain and got referred to the local hospital where I was put into an MRI machine more than once. It's hard not to worry about that, and I started to slip into a bad habit of gnawing on my saddle joint on my left thumb out of anxiety and stress. I have that scarred callous to this day. The skin cracks in cold weather, and even if I live down south, I've had plenty of those days.

To say I was nervous while waiting in that doctor's office in the early afternoon of my 21st birthday would be a gross understatement. I'd been trying to self-diagnose my condition for weeks with WebMD, but that list had stuff like osteoarthritis or Kienböck's disease. All of those are terrible diseases that make you lose the use of your hand, but something as awful as Parkinson's disease wasn't even on my radar. I'm never going to forget how I felt when those words were said to me even if the precise wording has slipped.

If you're ever gotten truly horrible and unexpected news, it's different than what you think, or at least it was for me. Being stunned and left with a slack-jawed expression was the first part. My conscious mind didn't even understand what had been said at first, but my subconscious mind did, and it knew it was bad. Then it clicked, and a nervous smile appeared on my face to replace the color that had drained from it. My grandpa had died of Parkinson's a few years back. I'd watched him waste away for six years and shrivel from being a bundle of boundless joy to a knot of endless pain. That was going to be me now.

My heart started to beat faster. There was slight hyperventilation and a cold sweat all over my skin that left this prickly feeling. I started to shake so much that my teeth briefly chattered, and it wasn't from the cold or the Parkinson's disease that I now knew I had. I'd always been uncomfortable with my mortality, but this wake-up call to that was more like a freezing waterfall to my soul that was drowning me.

I shoved that panic attack into a box, put a big smile on my face, and responded with an unfittingly cheery, "Wow, really?!" to hide how scared I was. I tried my hardest not to make eye contact for the rest of that conversation that I could barely pay attention to. My body got so numb that I couldn't feel my racing heart beating in my chest even as I got a tension headache and could feel my heartbeat on my skull.

I was really kind and pleasant as we discussed my treatment options, and at this early stage that meant giving me a prescription for carbidopa-levodopa and seeing how I responded, which was okay but not as well as my doctor had hoped.

But that would be something later that "confirmed" my diagnosis. For now, of all the emotions I felt, like terror, I couldn't stop being angry at myself because I couldn't stop trembling and shaking in terror. I had some vague fear of, "Stop, he's going to think you're faking symptoms and you won't get help!" as I berated myself for not staying calm.

If I can fault that doctor for anything, it was not noticing my mental health and shoving me into the "early onset Parkinson's" category of ages 21-50 instead of juvenile Parkinson's disease for those younger than 21. I don't blame him for that. I fit the diagnosis age range even if by a razor-thin margin, and I don't know enough about the specifics of when a first diagnosis technically counts, like if it's when symptoms are first reported or if it's when a diagnosis is reached.

No, I blame him for the fact that he didn't notice how badly I took the news, not wanting to contribute much in the way of sympathy, or even simply telling me how Parkinson's at a young age progresses very slowly for a long time. I was handed a bunch of fucking pamphlets that told me I had a decade or less to live and that a bunch of fucking hospice facility contact information and even referrals in them.

I don't know if that counts as malpractice or not, but that didn't soften any of the blow of what was a devastating diagnosis and I walked out of that hospital falling into a bottomless pit of despair and wanting to commit suicide, and I got so close to killing myself on the bike ride back to my dorm. I was maybe five seconds away from intentionally speeding off the sidewalk and into oncoming traffic against a semi-truck, but I backed out at the last moments. I made it back to my dorm room alive and collapsed on my mattress and stayed motionless and wanting to cry until I fell asleep.

I then got woken up from my blissful oblivion by the guys on my dorm room floor who had figured out I could now legally drink alcohol and wanted to party and use me as an excuse, so they took me to another dude's room and told me to drink with them. I think someone started a chorus of "For He's a Jolly Good Fellow", but I was pretty drunk because I poured back can after can of Pabst Blue Ribbon and shot after shot of cotton candy Burnett's Vodka. If I couldn't die, and I couldn't sleep, I would settle for being too drunk to think.

Thankfully for any fledgling career of being an alcoholic I was developing (if you don't know, Michael J. Fox, a personal hero of mine for his activism with promoting Parkinson's disease research and awareness, was extremely alcoholic after his PD diagnosis at 29), I woke up vomiting on my bed and didn't have the energy to clean it up, so I went back to bed with a pounding headache and slept next to my putrid alcohol-scented puke, and developed a strong distaste for hard liquor from that. I'm not even sure if that was still on October 7, 2014, but it'd fit with the rest of that awful day.

Like Zach, I wish I didn't know what it was like to have a very bad day sour an entire month let alone the month of my birthday, but I do, and it tastes like vomited cotton candy vodka. That's why re:Dreamer released on October 7th in the first place. I distract myself on my birthday to not think about the worst birthday I've ever had, which is also why its first day in the story is October 7th. It's an important day for blessings wrapped in tragedies. Because of that day, I went down a long and winding path that led me here. I now make a game that means the world to me, and while not intended, I figured out I am trans from that... or at least, I'd like to say it was all through my own effort, but one of the many issues is that it wasn't.


2. Crazy Bitches with Sledgehammers

Damn, that actually kind of sounds like a cool porno or cheesy action flick...

I'm the most surprised of anyone that re:Dreamer ended up a "trans girl" story (even if it and Zach's identity are broader than that). Sure, I'm bad at reading a room, like how I make inappropriately snarky jokes in serious situations and drop extremely serious topics in casual conversations, or how it took re:Dreamer's Discord server rejoicing when I put a forceful stop to the egg cracking to notice that they had hated it, but this has to be my biggest failed read of all time (but maybe my own gender takes the cake).

Like seriously, what the fuck are these survey results? Ignoring the fact that the world has more awareness of gender issues now than it has ever before and the sampling bias aside, these are terrifying numbers. Again, the demographics of a gender bender visual novel aren't the same demographics as the average population sample, but I don't know how I feel that my half-joking statement of "re:Dreamer is only slightly less dangerous to a man than a game of Russian roulette" isn't even that inaccurate.

When I'm being clever, I try to think of it as "my writing is so good that it frequently destroys people and I get thanked for it." When I'm in despair, I try to think of it as "I have no idea how anyone can learn who they are from re:Dreamer when I don't know or don't like who I am." When I'm being optimistic, I think of how blessed I am that I have a unique opportunity to put a piece of my soul into a creative project that will outlive me and for it to be received so positively that I can alter the trajectory of many peoples' lives to what is (hopefully) a more truthful and rewarding existence.

But the thing is, I never intended to do that or anything but making a gender bender game I like and telling a story I find interesting. Everything that has happened has been unintentional, and I've slowly learned to accept in a limited capacity that I am making a difference to people and able to influence gender identities even if I don't want that power.

Of course, people who did want that power to influence gender identities and who saw me as one of them soon congregated around me, and that's where the trouble began.


It started small, like all tragedies between people do. A few trans women showed up and told me they liked my work, and I was receptive to the praise even as they kept pushing me to make the game even more trans in a way that I didn't want and felt like shallow pandering. These trans women brought their trans friends to the server, and they started to treat it as their general hangout. Discussion of the game took a backseat to this being the watering hole of a number of trans women, many of which I became friends with in a way that finally shut the book on my transphobia.

But then I blinked, and somewhere along the way, the place changed without me realizing. There were frequent fights, and the drama was constant. I had to jump between being a bartender at a transbian dive bar, the parent of an open-invite slumber party at my house, the token cishet male in a group of trans women that my friends kept insisting was actually one of the girls like them, and an ally for trans women who was starting to be seduced by the power I was being pushed to use or abuse.

I was also being taken advantage of; in particular, a woman (W) who I now know is a literal rapist (and she even self-admits to this) stopped being active in the server and made her own server because she got mad that I didn't want to throw autistic people she hated under the bus yet stayed around because she treated my server as a hunting ground for growing her polycule harem of women she forced to build dependencies on her. If I weren't trying to prove a point, I'd be naming her here because god damn this fucking woman deserves to be on a fucking sex offender registry because she is a rapist and a groomer (she's dated women she started talking to when they were still a minor and given HRT to women just after they turned 18 and told them to rely on her for further supply). These were the type of people who were around me and whose red flags I ignored because they were charismatic, they became my friends, they convinced me the rules didn't apply to them, and I was an idiot.

I never wanted this, but I adapted to a certain degree even if it meant having to step up moderation and making concessions I wasn't quite comfortable with to make the server more trans-friendly (in ways that I now know were borderline hostile to everyone else). I recruited mods from friends who asked. I added a semi-private space that you had to be a regular to have access to which was meant for more serious discussion, then another space for the overflow of childish flirting (that finally closed a few weeks ago). I had to mediate issues core to transgender ideology from the outside and was forced to take sides that cost me friends. I just wanted to write a fucking gender bender porn game, and in order to do so and not spend all day moderating drama, I had to give power to people I trusted.

Unfortunately, I chose badly and put two vain narcissists ((N) and (J)) and one genuinely psychotic crack addict (C) at the helm as mods.

This latter one (C) had realized the demographics of the server, and she abused her power of having access to my ear and the join-leave logs to badger anyone who joined as a male by insisting that they weren't, and she talked with glee every time she noticed that someone had changed their pronouns roles from He/Him to She/Her.

To this day, even after all the shit that has happened, I think (C) started off with good intentions by trying to provide guidance for those who she saw as repressing or otherwise denying who they were from themselves. She was willing to be patient and not be pushy even if she did bring an agenda to the table, she really took the time to "make sure" before she started swinging, and she did this at a low volume with men who were miserable.

But then she ramped up production of her egg cracking (a term I fucking hate now; if I call you one, consider it a bitter insult). It soon stopped being about what someone else wanted and became about what she wanted, and she wanted the numbers and the secondhand gender euphoria she got from cracking people. The only explanation I have is that she was truly an awful person from the start who lost sight from success and ego and let her mask slip, or her girlfriend (J) and best friend (N) convinced her to give into her worst instincts and corrupted her into a person I barely recognize.

Things went too far when she launched into someone's DMs within minutes of them joining the server to convince them they weren't trans, took the outcome of every crack victim personally even though she had just met these people, got incredibly upset whenever someone she cracked decided they weren't trans, possibly blackmailed those she cracked attempting to detransition (as a disclaimer, my leads went quiet after telling me but it's been told to me more than once), and generally gave the server a terrible reputation as being unsafe.

When I nearly killed myself the first time after my crack (which had been after years of people trying their hardest to convince me I was trans, such as (W) convincing me to take HRT as payment for a gift and watching in glee as I had a rush of euphoria soon followed by a week and a half of severe depression (with neither of us learning anything from the experience), being ridiculed by (C) for admitting I thought I was bigender or agender, and near-constant comments from at least a dozen regulars expressing disbelief in me being cis), I asked the mod team if we should put a temporary "no egg cracking" rule into place until we figured out what the hell we did from here because I couldn't live with myself if someone from the server was successful in killing themselves after they realized they were trans because of the server like I had almost been. (C) made this about her and acted like a child throwing a tantrum because I was threatening to take away her favorite toy. I explained other bad examples of trans women struggling after (C) helped them, and she had a nervous meltdown of apologizing and saying she didn't know (which is kind of indicative that she should never have done this in the first place).

I was misinformed with one of these cases and mistakenly combined the stories of two different women into one story, but (J) (who if you'll remember (C) was dating) decided that I was a liar. She got angry at me and leaked these mod logs said hours after a suicide attempt to the server (J), (N), and (C) had made that I didn't know about (at the time) with the excuse of it being for a gender bender game that has since been cancelled but the reality of it being a place I was denied access from as they poached friends to it while abusing their powers as mods, spread lies about me and said I was transphobic for being confused and hating what was happening to me, and generally just built their own echo chamber.

When I'm comparing the actions of people to a rapist (W) who these women fucking hate, they have gone too far.

What followed was months of manipulative gaslighting (yes, I am using that word accurately; I got told that I was misremembering conversations I could find in message history). I was paralyzed with anger after the full magnitude of all of these callous betrayals came to light, and even typing this now, I am feeling a rush of that righteous anger. re:Dreamer's fourth anniversary update covers that better than here with specific examples of how badly they treated me.


But despite how angry these women make me and how much they have hurt not only me but others, I've never wanted to ruin them with something like a doxing. I even tried to warn (N) of a potential doxer attempting to enter their server not even a month ago. I didn't need to do this as I'd told this person under no circumstances were they to attempt to get revenge for me and they were unlikely to get into that server anyways since invites are closed and they've been hemorrhaging members, but I did anyways.

But I wanted to make it a test. I asked (N) to get a firm commitment from (C) to never crack anyone ever again or I'd use what I know to "really go scorched earth." I referred to (C) as her, but paused and remembered she'd had a non-binary arc right as we stopped talking to each other, so I asked if she was still She/Her.

From (N), "you threatened her and now are concerned about her pronouns" as I realized a screenshot of a DM from (C) to (N) that (N) had sent me showed (C) worried that I was threatening "her friends and family."

I clarified. "I'm not a fucking idiot, (N). Attempting to do anything with your dox is gonna get someone killed. I am fully aware of how dangerous it is to paint a target on the back of a trans woman who I have shown as doing deplorable things, but imo this is a woman who should have a court order to not be allowed internet access."

I also clarified that this only applied to (C). She was by far the biggest offender, (N) already said she wouldn't try to crack anyone ever again, and I didn't trust a word out of (J)'s mouth ever since she showed screenshots of me talking about crack victims like the morning after my first suicide attempt with the explicit intention of making me hurt more in one of the worst events of my life.

I eventually got the commitment from (C) that she would never try to crack anyone ever again, so I handed over the concerned individual's Discord @ and user ID.

In return, (N) told me, "Im taking tha bar in Feb. This is a showing of good will, if you need any legal help I will provide it to the best of my ability for as low as a cost as I can do."

My first thought was, "I don't even get pro bono service after you fucked up so much of my life?" Instead, I said "I would not really trust you to represent me, but thank you, even if the point I have consistently made with you is that your offers to help me have invariably led me down paths I regret taking."

(N) and I fully agreed to go our "separate ways" after this, only for (J) to report me to the Student Transfer developers as if I had been threatening her personally, and I got banned from their Discord server for threatening a member of that server (which (J) was) while to my knowledge (C) is the only person I know who hates body swap more than I do and would never join the Student Transfer Discord server.


I was distraught, but instead of retaliating despite wanting to so badly, I found I didn't have the stomach for it. I just told (N) she was a horrible person, she should never have shared the conversation with (J), and to tell (C) I was sorry that I made her have stress from thinking this was over doxing (it was over finding receipts of the persons telling me (C) had tried to blackmail them with their IRL dox and showing that to mutual friends to force a "it's them or me" situation, but that's a likely empty threat from someone falsely reporting (C); nevertheless, it is accurate to say that this was reported to me).

I pleaded with (N) to talk to (J) for the next day or so, trying my hardest to get her to convince (J) to recant (and being told in the process that (J) knew the threat hadn't applied to her but that she had wanted to hurt me anyways) as I desperately tried to salvage the situation with the Student Transfer devs who hadn't already blocked me.

That latter part went about as well as it could have. I explained the situation with as much details as I could, it got forwarded to the other devs while also saying,

I regret giving those egg crackers any space or platform to operate. I am currently on a character arc of making sure everyone gets the chance to safely explore who they are or will be accepted for who they say they are without judgment like I had been denied, and I feel ashamed that it took me until it personally affected me to get involved and put my foot down.


I do agree that a ban was on the near horizon, but as someone with a high-profile GamesDoneQuick for doing nothing and being accused on false charges, this really stung. I wish I could have had the opportunity to at least give a statement before the ban came down as I would have left on my own from seeing the writing on the wall, but once again, I got left out of the loop.

By and large, the devs seemed to appreciate the extra context, and I further sent a letter apologizing to the devs for being an ass and dragging them into this drama while acknowledging that I definitely had a ban coming on the horizon.

Hi, CaptainCaption here.


I thought about turning this letter into me emphatically re-stating my case of how I'm not a doxer or some other variety of person who is capable of deliberately trying to hurt and ruin another person even after they've tried to hurt and ruin me several times, but I'm not going to do that. I already gave the complicated details of what happened to be passed along, and while I hope you've all seen it and decided I'm not a vindictive villain, I can't control how other people think, nor should I. Instead, let me say that I am sorry this whole situation has just been kind of fucked, and I don't just mean this new drama.


The last year of my life emphatically being the worst so far does not give me an excuse for how I have been in the last year and before that, and I am sorry you had to put up with me like this. I wish you all could have known me better a decade ago, but all of you caught me in a weird period of my life after the death sentence of a diagnosis for a neurodegenerative disease, then my identity collapsing, and then a constant string of drama similar to the one that led to my ST server ban. I've been a scared, sad, angry, depressed, untrusting, and a chaotic mess of emotions and identity in a fluctuating mix of proportions for a while, and I clearly have not been doing well mentally. I am not saying any of this for pity but to explain that I know this isn't sustainable and I have been getting professional help for months. It's a slow process since there's an entire Gordian Knot to untie and cutting it isn't an option, but there are gradual improvements. I am feeling less despondent these days and for the first time in a long time I feel hope, so do not worry about me doing something stupid because of this ban, and that includes harmful things to myself or with ST, such as trying to start drama with the game, its devs, the server, or its people.


Frankly, I am thankful and surprised any of you were this patient for me for this long. I truly have no hard feelings about the ban, as if it wasn't going to be for this, it was going to be for something else before long, and it's not your responsibility to run damage control with an ongoing train wreck on a collision course with something on the horizon you can't even see. I've been argumentative, belligerent, egotistically defensive, and jumping at shadows to see the least charitable versions of things I can see. I don't like being this way, and I regret my actions from being this way, and not just because I've burned a lot of goodwill with you but because I failed to live up to being the type of person I want to be and know I can be. If there's anything I can critique on your parts, it was a lack of clearer communication with the status of a proposed change to a route I wrote, precisely how my conduct had been in violation of server rules with specific examples, and giving me a way to properly respond to the allegations that resulted in my banning and explain the complex circumstances, but a lack of communication does not justify my behavior.


I fully acknowledge that I have earned this ban, and not even for the stated reason, but I hope that I can one day prove that I have earned the right to be back in your good graces and be downgraded from an indefinite ban to one of a year or two. But even if I can't, I wish each of you good luck all the same with V8 and beyond and hope you can keep making ST better and better.

I don't know if ST dropping routes I'd like to read again is actually going to happen (I did make a promise to read Magic Allie to its dev and I intend to honor that despite this ban) or if I am ever going to get unbanned, but it doesn't really matter. The apology was passed along, it hit the mark I wanted, it was appreciated, and the words I typed are genuine and I feel that way. I might not be able to salvage a reputation with the entire dev team, but the folks I still want to talk to and I seem to still get along and we can still be cordial and even friendly.


On the other end of this, (N) just emotionally manipulated me for a day and half as she acted insultingly powerless to my desperate pleading to get her to convince her friend (J) she was wrong when she knew she was wrong or even to contact the ST server to state my case, but it went nowhere and left another dagger in my heart from someone I had attempted to trust the slightest bit only to get hurt yet again because I'm such an idiot when it comes to getting hurt in the same ways that I'm starting to look like a masochist.

But in a way, this actually provided the closure I needed. While complaining how hurt I was by this newest drama and betrayal in re:Dreamer server's semi-private channel, (N) messaged me "Please don't talk about is anymore in dreamer or anywhere else."

I had used (J)'s @ when another member asked if this was the same person, not trying to target her but to get clarification. I was asked to not do this by another girl (A) (who I am cool with) who leaked that to (N), but something suddenly fucking clicked with me.

(N) was more concerned with her reputation than my mental health or being a good person.

It was so obvious (abusers never care about those they abuse but that they got caught), and it was so pathetic that it just fully made me understand who I was dealing with. This is a woman who said she didn't care yet kept spying on me, either through a friend or through an alt, and was trying hard to make me do PR for her when she wouldn't correct her friend lying about me.

I said to (N), "I've deleted the @ but frankly you have no fucking right to tell me this."

(N) responded "I do and I have over and over since we are doing them same. Considering the fact that it has 'inspired' someone to try to infiltrate us…"

And I shot back, "consider that if I accurately report the actions of your friend, and people hate them enough to try and infiltrate you... does that make your friend worth defending?"

And then "ngl I kind of need to thank you. I wanted closure and I wasn't expecting it like this. You all wronged me and fucked me up, but seeing you like this is kind of vindicating."

I soon got her to get a mutual block with me, and after this, I am done talking about these three unless they try to contact me again.

Hey, funny tangent time to prove my point! (N) did in fact try to contact me when they learned I was typing this! Or more accurately, she contacted my best friend.

What followed was just pathetic and hilarious.

The cutoff text is a screenshot of what I was working on here, but it's been edited slightly in light of this.

Wow.

Also, I didn't know what (N) meant. I recently warned a server owner of (W) being a rapist and the debate in DMs eventually resulted in a bunch of people related to the re:Dreamer server drama getting banned from her server ((N) being one of them). I was moderately upset but this wasn't even a server I was in anymore, the owner had made it pretty clear she didn't want me there, and I didn't particularly want to be there after having so much shit thrown my way from certain people as they invalidated any thoughts I had on my own femininity with, "Well, you're not trans."

(N) blocked me after this, but she and (C) were still in my friend's DMs and I told her to just block them since she was uncomfortable being a "drama secretary."

Yeah, so, lmao.


Now, I want you to compare how (N) acted with me to how I acted with her and (C):

This was that "threat" that kicked everything off.

To fully clarify, me going "scorched earth" would have been going to mutual friends with the fact that a dude from the ST server DM'd me that (C) had tried to blackmail him after he detransitioned on her by holding his dox from a sent gift as leverage to keep him on HRT, but he ghosted me for follow and that was almost so long ago in my DMs that I can't even scroll that far back to find it and I can't ask in the server anymore. The other person who told me something similar did so in passing, and it might be extrapolating to call it blackmailing but (C) (allegedly) tried to use this person's address to threaten a call of a wellness check by paramedics and implied it was something (C) already had. The second story rings more true than the first but both were very likely at least exaggerations of the truth as I still get the occasional, "Yeah, this girl tried to tell me I was trans minutes after meeting me and got mad when I said I wasn't" every few weeks, and it's been months since she left the server and my life. It might not be a fact that (C) did this, but it is a fact that people told me she did.

The reason I have not acted on this information is because of its sketchy nature and the seriousness of the accusation, but after seeing how they've acted to me, I am liable to assume almost any negative story of their actions to people they dislike is true or at least has kernels of truth. These women have lost all benefit of the doubt from me. I don't believe what they say after I've caught them lying to me several times, how they've gone out of their way to harass me and report me, and how they've harassed my friends about me in a way I haven't done to their friends (the most being telling one to stop sharing information about me said in a semi-private channel as it threatens the confidentiality of the space).

For a notable example of how little I trust these women, my Twitch channel just got permanently banned under weird circumstances when I haven't streamed anything but the first 45 minutes of a SFW game in over 3 months, and it got banned exactly 20 hours before this post went live at 10:39 PM (I tried to make it publish at the exact minute I said "I think I'm trans" in someone's DMs). I didn't notice until after this post went live, so I've gone back and added it alongside fixing some typos I noticed after publishing.

While these women said they are not responsible (and that they told their server not to act against me despite that breaking their "we never talk about you in there" explanation), I think the timing is just too coincidental; plus, it was this same song and dance with the Student Transfer Discord server ban of denying involvement until (J) just spilled the beans in a screenshot (N) shared with me, so I could totally see (J) having gone rouge to report me and lying to her friends about it. I could maybe see a recent sweeping Twitch policy where they reviewed all old clips, but I had not heard of that, it would have had to have been automated review as there is no way a company that is losing money like Twitch would do that with employees, and I refuse to believe they are so incompetent that I got permanently banned from an automated report trip on an old clip.

But again, these women said they didn't do this, but I think they did, yet you have to draw your own conclusions.


Anyways, back to that DM relating to my Student Transfer Discord server ban... I cut out some rambling text below about how shit my life has been the last year since it's a bit repetitive and you already know the details.

This is the screenshot you will see below.

This is me stating what I was asking (N) to get out of (C) (and me respectfully doing a pronoun check). I vaguely realized this came off as a doxing threat in the middle of this, and while I clarified that it wasn't, I didn't spend much time on the point or apologize for it as I was trying to get a promise out of (C) and changing gears would have lost momentum.

I got what I wanted, so I gave over the user @ and user ID of the user who had threatened to infiltrate these girls' server to dox them.


I could include screenshots of (N)'s weird offer to be my legal representation or hooking me up with legal representation, me telling her I was sorry that got a bit tense while telling her once again that I won't dox any of them, her saying "good im holding you to this as well," me saying (paraphrased) "lol you could swat me and kill me and I don't think I'd care because you've already fucked up my life so much", and her saying "yeah im not one to doxx or swat" before her finally saying "now lets go our separate ways, but if any of our 3s personal info shows up online, we are holding you responsible" and me agreeing, but there are some sensitive personal details that I do not have the right to disclose in that conversation that I do not have the right to share and editing them out would be a pain in the ass.

Instead, I'll just jump to how I acted once I got banned from the Student Transfer server (I got DM'd by a dev "I'm not going to mince words. We've received credible evidence of you directing serious threats toward another member of our server." / "We take this very seriously and cannot tolerate it." / "We feel you are no longer a safe presence in our server, and as such we will be banning you indefinitely." and then blocked before I could ask for clarification):

And yeah, I didn't retaliate with any identifiable information after that, and even after being legally threatened (but let's be honest, this was more chest bumping than a serious threat; this woman either knew she was lying to me about this being a legitimate legal claim or she is either going to fail the bar exam hard), I won't do that. I wouldn't even dox the rapist I've been talking about when I know her address because I've driven to her house, so what makes these women think I'd dox them?

I wouldn't even talk about the blackmail accusations (C) got in a courtroom if they tried to take me to one given the weight of that in a permanent legal record and I know (C) expressed panic attacks I would "render her unemployable" if I did that or if dropped some pastebin when emotional, which is why I am clearly stating I won't do that and that this online drama stays online. If I haven't done anything like that by now, I will never do that, not only because it would kill my career in a nanosecond and I love my job more than I hate any of these people, but because who I am as a person can't. But maybe it's too much of an ask to have people I distrust so much trust me even when I think my character has shown I cannot do that and that this, mentioning them by letters that won't show up in a Discord search, is the worst I can do?


I could show more screenshots, but editing those is boring and it's honestly just tiresome back-and-forth of me being suicidally depressed and spiraling while pleading with (N) to talk to (J) (who confirmed she leaked the worst snippets of this conversation to the ST devs), and it's kind of pathetic on both our parts: me for how depressed and sad I am for caring this much, and her for being emotionally manipulative and just plain cruel pretending she was powerless.


So, draw your own conclusions about who we are as people. This was not a situation I planned for, but this was genuinely poetic as (N) proved all the points I was trying to make about her and those like her for me while equalizing that I did in fact fuck up and not fully clarify that what I said wasn't a doxing threat, but even after that I think I get a passing grade for how I handled this. Maybe not an A or a B, but at least a C. The only reason I am even showing any more of these screenshots isn't to drag them as people but to clarify just who the type of people who tried to tell me who I was as they tried to take over my server are, how badly years of thinking these people were my friends messed me up, and proving that these are the types of people you side with when you think egg cracking is okay: narcissistic bullies who care far more about themselves than anyone else and who should be the last people in charge of leading anyone else's gender journey.


When I block or otherwise cut off contact with someone (which is rare), I usually say some variant of, "I hope you have a good life and become a good person but please do so far away from me." I think the overwhelming majority of people can be redeemed, but I don't think I feel that way with these three women; instead, there's anger, and it's justified. Saying it isn't is giving these abusive people power over me, and I'm done being the victim of unhappy people who hate themselves more than I could ever hate them, and after all this, I'm not even sure I feel that much.

I know these girls will be reading this post despite saying they want to move on, so I'll be writing as if I were talking directly to them for a bit (don't worry, general audience; you too can read even more droning words from me!):

I really just want you to fuck off far away from me after I post this and to stop trying to control me, which is what you have been trying to do. You say you've moved on, but your lines of "we've stopped talking about you" don't hold water when you share DMs of my conversations between you all to discuss them (despite a promise from (N) that she would stop doing that so conversations would stay between her and I). You've shown you've kept an eye on my activities because you knew of very specific ways I have said, "these people have made me sad and angry" in the re:Dreamer server's semi-private vent/support channel and nowhere else and tried to either pressure me into silence or told lies about what I was venting about in some weird attempt at gaslighting me so that I would recant that specific information. You've pressured me into silence while you've found new avenues to harass me, such as through my friends, Patreon DMs, my producer, and threatening my income.

You have gone out of your way to lie about me, lie to me, and hurt me, yet I have gone out of my way to reconcile with you, apologize to you for perceived wrongs, warn you of threats, make sure that you still get a fair shake by at least listening to your side of the story even if all I get back are manipulative lies in poor attempts to silence me, and that I have accurate information about events and am not spreading something I might have misremembered while making sure no identifiable personal information is in my reporting. You lied to me for months about not just the existence of but what you were doing with a side server while abusing your power as mods and my trust in you to turn mutual friends against me, you have lied about what was being said about me in places I couldn't defend myself or even what the purpose of that space was, and you have lied about chances of reconciliation from omitting key pieces of information that made any of my attempts at putting out the burning bridge of our once strong friendship hopeless.

I could be here for hours posting receipts of your lies, your bullying, and your manipulative and controlling behavior, but my story isn't about you and I think I've made my point about how much your behavior has hurt me. Don't blame me if I accurately report the severity of my trauma as I take my life back, because you played (note the past tense) a key part in my descent to rock bottom and it's all uphill from here. I wish I had stood up for my past self, but I can't. I'm standing up for myself here, and this is how I am doing it.

(J), (N), and (C)... fuck all three of you. In different ways, you are cunts of the highest order. Even if I am a woman (in no small part due to the efforts of you and people like you), I shouldn't use that word, but as the almost certainly apocryphal quote from Alexander Hamilton to Thomas Jefferson goes, "There are approximately 1,010,300 words in the English language, but I could never string enough words together to properly express how much I want to hit you with a chair."

I don't want to hit you with a chair, or dox you, or cancel you, or even force an unfair "it's them or me" situation with mutual friends like an asshole. I want you to stop hurting people and to stay far away from me, and that means to stop harassing my friends to change my mind about you for you or contacting my producer with a vague cowardly intimidation of killing my source of income with legal threats. If I have to stand up for myself to do so, I will, but I also want you to know you've lost a friend who would have happily taken a bullet for any you at one point (and in a way, by caring so much about a reconciliation and doing everything possible to unsuccessfully make that happen that it further broke me, I did, to say nothing of giving you the gun you used to shoot me).

I'm now a lifelong enemy, and not even to you specifically, but to anyone like you.


3. The Cunt of Monte Cristo

It's a play on the title of my favorite book and I'm huffing a few vengeful chuuni vibes right now, okay? I thought about the "The Countess of Monte Cristo" but that didn't have quite the same ring to it.

It wasn't just these three girls (a word I am using pejoratively because they want to be cliquey high school bitches so badly that they don't act like adults). It wasn't even just (W) who is a literal rapist and groomer. It's the trans women who go along with this and feed on their worst instincts. All too often along the way, what for the vast majority starts out as a sincere and even innocent desire to help other trans women (and other potential trans women) and a compassionate strength to stand in solidarity with their sisters leads to fervent transvestigation (yes, that's what fucking egg cracking fucking is) that would make a transphobe tell you to slow down and making excuses for a literal rapist or grooming or all the other shit one might have thought wrong at one time but now turn a blind eye to or even gleefully participate in.

I know what I'm talking about. Not only have I seen the conversion happen firsthand, and not only have I seen more than one trans woman have a meltdown from hating how she has participated in that type of culture who was so distraught from guilt that she wouldn't listen to the fact that I not only forgave her but never blamed her in the first place, I am one of those women.

Up until a few weeks before my first suicide attempt after realizing I wasn't cis, I was doing more than turning a blind eye to (C) and others going around looking for men to destroy or someone forming a polycule that I knew would end in disaster with people getting hurt.

I never did the latter myself (I am an awkward person romantically but I don't ever see myself as having anything but a monogamous relationship to say nothing of my problems with intimacy, which is ironic for a writer of a pornographic visual novel that is shaping up to be quite romantic in some areas), but I "talked shop" about who I thought was an egg with (C), felt like a girl who wanted to trust her endocrinologist over the advice of trans women online was being a bit silly, and even tried to coax the woman out of someone who was at the time drunk and clearly showing signs of being alcoholic.

That person might be dead now, and I don't just mean myself and how I acted. I am utterly ashamed of my behavior, but attempting to distance myself from it by pretending it never happened is not something I can do because it'd be like minimizing how wrong that was and making excuses for myself.

No amount of apologies to myself, other people, or this person regardless of whether or not they are still alive can excuse me. My actions have possibly led to a person's suicide, but they certainly contributed to a person being miserable about who they are in a way I know all too well.

Like, Jesus Fucking Christ, I even bragged about the conditions and actions I took part in that might have led to someone being dead or at the very least made their life spiral downwards:

Hell, I (not the visual novel) actually cracked someone in voice call last night. According to someone being told the story, they had a Linux penguin as their profile picture and coded in C++, so it's not like I did anything that impressive.


I'm still weirded out by how good I was at it and that I, a cis man and one of the few in the server regulars, was the person bluntly explaining to someone that they seriously needed to be introspective about their identity as what they were doing was making them miserable, and that they get one shot at life that they need to make their own and not the one that everyone expects of them... but I won't deny that it felt a little nice helping someone to that degree. Only a little though, and I'm still quite conflicted about it because this person came into a VC for the first time, while quite drunk, and got sucker punched hard by an impromptu therapy session about issues they've been ignoring for decades and I still feel like it isn't my place to be doing this because I do not have the answers they are looking for, only questions they can ask themself.


Again, it was still weird doing this, but I guess someone was possibly right when they said that the new arc for CaptainCaption is the unironic egg cracker one. You know, putting an end to the unintentional (not ironic) egg cracker arc that's been running for 3 years.

I am disgusted with myself and want to punch that smug fucking smile off of my old profile pic's face.

Right here IT'S THIS ONE.

My insane face.

Which admittedly isn't even that different than my new profile picture's, but I swear, I have learned from my mistakes...


It doesn't matter if it felt right at the time. I know now it was wrong, and I won't pretend I was right nor hide from that. The Patreon posts are not being deleted from shame, but they (or relevant sections) are being prepended with disclaimers about my changed stance on egg cracking.

But it's not enough to know I was wrong and publicly share it. I have to call this type of shit out now, because as Alucard says in Castlevania: Symphony of the Night (a game I used to speedrun; my PB is 12th place which is kind of not the best but keep in mind this was the big boy (or girl) category the experienced runners went to and being just over 5 minutes off world record in a hard category with lots of tech is nothing to scoff at): "You must always remember that the only thing necessary for evil to triumph is for good men to do nothing…"

I'm not a good man, let alone a man. I'm not even a particularly good person. I'm a bit of a fucking vindictive bitch, but maybe that's what I was meant to be.

Like Alucard, I am making the choice to commit my life to standing against the evil that made me act like a bloodthirsty addict, because yeah, it's hard not to call caring so much about your gender while willfully breaking the simple golden rule of "treat others how you would like to be treated" in regards to the gender of someone else as anything but wrong and evil.


It's the height of hubris to think every attempt to coax a repressed gender out of someone will go well or will even be an improvement. It didn't and likely won't for me despite having what should have been an ideal support group with eager 24/7 availability and so much else going for me (I am less than a year into HRT and part of the reason it went badly was I got HRT results so good so fast that it made others jealous of me mere months in that got expressed in ways that fucked me up because they blamed me for causing their dysphoria).

Frankly, it'll be a bit of a miracle if I'm even happier than I was before I realized I wasn't cis. But even if I don't want to be a woman, I am uniquely empowering myself by breaking out of the mold the horrible people who pushed me here tried to get me to fit into by proving I am not like them and not what they wanted me to be.

From now on, I will follow my own convictions as a trans/non-binary woman, but as history shows, any strict adherence to the ideological purity of a code of conduct inevitably causes one to become a victim to it. That's why I'm not going to be a sword to preemptively strike but a shield to defend others, yet as another Captain has shown, a shield can be a very effective weapon and a symbol of what can make us great, and like him, I am aware of the propaganda yet I fight for the dream because I believe in it, which means:

  • Cracking down on "egg" rhetoric (fuck me I swear that was an unintentional pun). That was originally a term meant to refer to your past self alone, but it's been expanded in a terrible way. It's never okay to assume someone is someone else when they tell you who they are or trying to take that into your own hands, and the people I have seen trying to do that have invariably ended up the worst people I have ever met. When you do that, know that you side with a rapist groomer, sociopaths who are insane on levels that make me look well-adjusted, or those who are so insecure in their womanhood that they can only get validation from projecting that onto other people. Respect other people and their gender like you would like yourself and your gender identity to be respected, or else you are a hypocrite without a leg to stand on, and no, thinking it helps people or saves lives isn't a good excuse when there have been people who have died from being cracked and you don't know enough about a person to make that judgment call. There are rules. You do not get to play God and decide who a person is for them nor push that onto them, those doing so the most clearly show it's about helping their ego and validation and not a struggling person. Even if you are "right" with a suspicion, you are wrong with your conduct as you rob someone of the security of knowing they have found their own identity. The whole point is self-identification and self-actualization, and you can be there to answer questions and expose someone to new ways of thinking, but explain your own biases if you have them and never force a person to ask questions or find answers they might not want. I am not giving an inch of quarter to those who don't understand that.

  • Being a brake who can take the pressure off those questioning who they are by telling them it's okay to take time to think it over before making a decision (or making no decision at all). If someone tells me who they are, I will accept it and make sure others accept it as we sit on the sidelines without any agenda besides making sure that person makes a realization that is wholly theirs because that is one of the most valuable experiences anyone can ever have and to deny them of that regardless of outcome is robbing them of the right to affirm that they are who they thought they were or the right to have peace in their conclusion about their identity that they know is their own and not what someone else gave them.

  • Fighting apocryphal doomsday notions in trans spaces that lead to rushed decisions being made (i.e., "No, you don't need to transition at 18 for perfect results since I know a 50-year-old trans woman who started 5 years ago passes perfectly as a 35-year-old cis woman", "Breast size is a genetic dice roll not that correlated to age and you're looking at it all wrong to think they're the end-all-be-all metric of affirmation or passing; look at me, as I don't like my chest even though I got 'blessed' with 38E (or 38F, or 38D, or 40F, or 40E, or 40D; as I've learned, manufacturers are inconsistent with cup sizes and I fit into all 6 of those sizes within the last month)", "I'm 30 and got hip rotation past the supposed cutoff date at 26 (when your pelvic bones finally fuse as the immobile joints vanish) because the part that matters is ligaments and muscles moving and your hip sockets can adjust from that alone; I got enough that I shrank by two inches (I am 5'9" on my driver's license and now barely pass 5'7"; this sucks because I liked the thought of being somewhat taller as a woman)").

  • In particular, calling out one of the worst parts of the notion of "you're never gonna pass if you didn't start hormones at 18" and related fatalistic mindsets about not starting hormones as early as possible with those expressing remorse that they never got puberty blockers to block their first puberty (HRT is in effect a second puberty). Everything I have seen from puberty blockers has made me scared or at least cautious of them, and I don't even mean the New York Times and the bullshit of journalism about trans healthcare issues but medical science I can go and read for free. Notably, there's no sufficient long-term samples of their effects for a proper study (zoomers, you are the test subjects for that future study), the studies that exist have obvious conflict of interest issues that should have prevented their publishing, my best friend says her friend coughs up blood from hers, I know someone with bone issues from them, and this shit is just dangerous. There is a reason GnRH agonists, infamously Lupron, are sometimes given to pedophiles and sex offenders to chemically castrate them and why many insurances outright deny coverage when even cheap insurance will gladly turn your copay for hormones and antiandrogens into a fraction of the over-the-counter price. You should never be seeking out kids to give them hormone advice or giving that advice at all (unless you're a freak who thinks a child can meaningfully consent, but think carefully about who you side with if that is your line in the sand), but if you're in that situation naturally (say, a relative or your own kid) and you have to weigh in with an option that isn't "don't" to prevent disaster of the worst choice, bicalutamide is an antiandrogen alternative to GnRH agonists comparable in effect that is far safer (but still not "safe" and it's insanity to think it's okay to dose up a child who has to ask permission to use a bathroom like they know who they want to be for the rest of their life; I knew kids who wanted to be time travelers and spaceship captains). Making sure medicine is ethically practiced is far more important than moderately better transition results, and there will never be perfect transition results so you might as well try to be safe.

  • Insistently telling anyone around me looking to transition get a gender dysphoria diagnosis and stay in-system and warning that informed consent has issues. I personally think that a sufficiently desperate person in that situation who wants hormones and has been told to prioritize them over therapy by other trans women can and often will say whatever is necessary to get them, but even if it's better than nothing, you should always go to a therapist alongside any transition. I am especially cautious of DIY as far too many get on it and don't monitor their levels after. That's never a good idea, and with bicalutamide specifically, that can cause severe liver damage, and that's to say nothing of the risks involved with DIY with scams, fake products, and even someone deliberately poisoning HRT and labeling estrogen as testosterone (and vice versa) to "own the libs" or some such nonsense. All three rungs of getting hormones exist for a reason (i.e., informed consent can have use if you are desperate and can't get a diagnosis because of limited psychiatric resources in your area), but you assume extra undue risk by staying further outside the system. So many people come through the re:Dreamer server just after realizing they are trans and wanting to start their transition, and I think it is of utmost importance that I put my foot down and point them to experts instead of helpful but inadequate online resources. If you are trying to take yourself and your transition seriously you should actually visit an endocrinologist (ideally one specializing in hormone replacement, like QMed/QueerMed). Remember, "trust the experts, not your own research."

  • Fully telling people that you do not need to make any social transition to be trans and that hormones don't make you trans, and that anyone attempting to treat you as less valid or not "truly" trans for not starting hormones or not wanting to social transition is wrong since being trans and transitioning are separate steps. I just want people to be safe and shoot their shots accurately since this is so important, and if anything, this is a wider and more accepting definition of being trans than those who will insist you get on hormones ASAP. I need to think more about whether or not you even need dysphoria to be trans, but right now I am leaning toward the fact that you do not need that to be trans. I know I might come off as truscum or adjacent to truscum with all these militant points, but I am not (does saying "you don't need hormones to be trans" or "I don't think you need gender dysphoria to be trans" sound truscum to you?). I'm a big enough person to admit I'm going to have a few raised eyebrows if you start talking about being trans while making no effort with a social transition or hormone replacement therapy (and this goes on for a long time), but I'll be respectful enough not to ask as you might have circumstances I do not know about. It might not be safe for you to transition as I've seen that a few times, you might live in a country with long waiting periods for a gender dysphoria diagnosis and HRT, and you might be blessed with being trans without dysphoria or the need to make a transition, but in an ideal world, the only pressure you should feel to transition is a desire to be yourself.

  • Pointing out that gender dysphoria is often treated as a rubber stamp of a diagnosis and that getting the medications for it takes less effort that getting the medications for any other mental illness I know of. Yes, current psychiatric science says that gender dysphoria is a mental illness (and depending on some loose interpretations I disagree with it can even mean being trans is itself a mental illness), but it's important to clarify that alone doesn't make it something to stigmatize and nobody who gets offending by calling gender dysphoria a mental illness is qualified to weigh in on the subject. We live in the 21st century and issues like depression, ADHD, and anxiety disorders have ways to medicate for them, but even if the treatment for those and gender dysphoria is a combination of therapy and medications, I've seen people tell me they've had shitty gender therapists who have not only rushed into a gender dysphoria diagnosis without question (it took me all of 5 minutes for mine with a therapist I've had since I was 8 and who was shocked I was telling her this), but some even push that diagnosis onto patients; likewise, I've seen therapists refuse to give a gender dysphoria diagnosis. There is consensus that therapy and then hormones (if needed) are the proper steps for treatment, and I'm okay with a month of gatekeeping that other diagnoses already have with introductory sessions to make sure people get this right when it's so important. That means going to a therapist and being honest, not saying what you think they want to hear to get a gender dysphoria diagnosis or pretending that therapists are to be ignored.

  • Warning people that many still treat hormones with this reverence and humor themselves as being more informed that endocrinologists based on the sketchy pseudoscientific data of personal anecdotes while also treating them as recreational drugs as part of a sexual lifestyle and fetishizing transitioning (looking at you, edited "You have become addicted to estrogen" Fallout: New Vegas screenshot and all the memes about sneaking estrogen on people). I've seen that give some trans women false confidence to claim "your doctor is lying to you" just because an endocrinologist wanted to start a patient off with 1 mg/day of estrogen monotherapy instead of 2 mg/day estrogen and an antiandrogen, I've seen women talking with joyful excitement about how they've got an upcoming injection and want the euphoria rush (to say nothing of how progesterone is treated as this mythical ambrosia when it's so much more than the "you get horny and further feminizing characteristics" drug), and I've seen women talk about taking 200 mg of progesterone (the daily limit) right before sex or a masturbation session to make it feel more intense when it's not a recreational drug to be used like that. If you want to make personal choices about what you put into your body as part of a sexual lifestyle, all the more to you as long as you're safe about it, but you need to not fucking push them onto other people like this. I've seen multiple women try to expand their transbian polycules by trying to recruit a cis man into it before offering hormones, someone in a relationship having their partner push a trans identity onto them to for a spicier sexual life and more control, and someone tell me they got offered progesterone for the first time before having sex for the first time. That's sickening and absolutely fucked, but even more so when some trans people push hormones as an easy fix on people who aren't properly informed as a toxic way to live vicariously through their results.

  • Telling those who want to pursue gender-affirming surgery of any kind not to seek out any medical advice from their friends except about what doctor to contact (and to try safer methods of enhancing your appearance and find comfort in yourself before jumping to those). I thought about linking a ton of recent studies showing things like complication rates and rates of having to go in for return surgeries to fix things, but doing so diluted the point I am trying to make (some people have the weird view that surgery is always necessary), shoving a bunch of studies in your face with more stuff to read is a big ask in a post this long (and you need a bit of prerequisite knowledge to know how to read a medical study), and I am not a doctor who is qualified to discuss the risks (and neither are those around you). I don't know as much about our masculine affirmations and presentation helpful to masculine-presenting non-binary folks or trans men counterparts as I should, but if anyone is interested in further feminization, things like makeup, style changes, laser/electrolysis hair removal, better shaving equipment, weight loss, and voice training are far easier, healthier, cheaper, safer, and more rewarding options than surgeries. They, not the cheat button that can all too often be the monkey's paw wish, are what you should be pursuing first, yet I've seen those who haven't even gotten 6 months into HRT talk about how they need surgery to pass while others tell them that they'll be "complete" once they get their surgeries. As someone with OCD, I can understand that fraught anxious panic can make you listen to your worst fears ("I will never pass!"), ignore reality ("I am ugly!"), and do something irrational ("I will never pass because I am ugly, but surgery will fix me!"), but there's only so much of a leg for this "I must pass at any cost" mindset to stand on; for example, I once told (W) (while she was complaining about not having a chest and wanting more) "you have goddamned C-cups and you've caught me staring at them in-person; you have a passing chest" and her responding "I don't want to pass; I want to be hot." I know that breasts (and voice) are the shortcuts for passing, and maybe there's a bias because I have a chest and I don't know what it's like for someone who wants breasts to not get satisfactory ones, but for God's sake, if you want a larger chest or just want to look hotter, you can just stuff a bra, stack bras, use inserts, use gels, or do something besides getting an expensive and risky surgery I have seen people budget themselves into poverty or take loans out to have when there are better options for passing. Take it from me; large breasts you cannot get rid of are not worth it.

  • Shoving trans bullies into lockers using their tactics, especially those who try to force their definition of femininity onto others. I personally am looking to be a masculine woman (paraphrasing something someone told me, "Cap, on a scale of 0 to 100, with 0 being a fully masculine woman and 100 being a fully feminine woman, you look like you're trying to reach a 20" and I agree with that assessment). If I gotta get mean to protect other people, I now can, and the HRT plus the security of my identity especially in regard to my femininity vs masculinity ratio lets me. You want to act like a vapid high school bitch who relies on her clique to intimidate people? I'm gonna be the fucking butch lesbian gym teacher who is gonna make you run laps when I catch you. You wanna call a girl ugly and act like you're better than her because you have the luxury of money and the state of mind to put more effort into your appearance compared to the person you are bullying? I've seen a pretty girl with an awful personality make fun of a trans woman who seemed to be extremely depressed and unable to afford things like nice female clothes or treatment like laser or electrolysis hair removal, so I'm gonna go out of my way to remind you that the woman who hates her large breasts has something you don't and is more secure in her femininity despite being rather masculine and tell you to sit down and shut the fuck up and not enforce beauty standards. You want me to respect your gender when you fail to respect the genders of others by being that type of bitch who uses cis as a slur like you're rubbing being "default" in someone's face, especially when you do that in a way that makes it harder for everyone who is trans to be accepted and to encourage those mad at you to treat the word trans as a slur in response? Well, I can't really use trans as a slur with you nor deliberately disrespect your gender identity, but damn, I'm going to think you're an awful person not even worthy of pity and make sure you don't have a soapbox in my server or around my friends.

  • Expressing honesty about someone else's appearance, especially about passing. Passing privilege sucks. I wish it wasn't a thing, but it is, and I'm not going to be any help to anyone trying to overcome it if I'm anything but an honest critic with constructive feedback. I'm never going to just tell someone they are ugly. Not only do I know there are harmful stereotypes about how trans women are not just uglier than cis women but ugly overall, I've never seen a trans woman who I thought was at unsalvageable levels. Most are just... kind of boyish before a year or two into transition, and then they might stay a bit boyish but even at the worst they get into a fuzzy territory where the face is a bit androgynous but not on a level where it can't be overcome with basic makeup, voice training, outfits, or even just posture (which is surprisingly huge, according to a few women I know; for instance, it's far more feminine to have your palms resting outward rather than inward for reasons that basically boil down to "it's more open and submissive" and while I think it sounds a bit like horseshit I've been told it enough by women I know who pass very well and even my own AFAB sister so there's probably truth in it). Never in my life have I come across someone whose appearance I can't find some part to give an honest compliment about with less than ten seconds of looking. You just can't put nothing in and expect something, and HRT alone isn't going to be a magic bullet for looking like the woman you want to be. This stuff causes a second puberty. Your first puberty took a while, as will your second one, especially facial feminization (which I guess I ended up focusing on), but as you wait for hormones and what is basically a second puberty to work, you can learn so much about how you want to present yourself as a woman in the future and there are whole industries dedicated to selling a bounty of products for that. You can find a style that will work with you and make you happy.

  • And relatedly, calling out faked hyper-femininity when I see it. I can understand wanting the quick fix of validation with a girlish presentation of femininity, but I've seen so many grown-ass adults acting like childish middle school girls that I had to make an overflow channel in the re:Dreamer Discord server for containment of the constant flirting and teasing (that only recently closed as the server culture had finally shifted away from that over half a year since that channel became necessary). Not only would no cis woman act in public like how I've seen some trans women childishly acting on Twitter and Discord, but we should have some respect for the culture we want to be a part of so much by not infantilizing it like a perverted funhouse mirror with pink glass. Sure, I've known grown women who are a bit girly (and they are fun to be around), and I've known some who are a bit childish (or even just immature). I'm not going to say that having some outlet for a bit of flirty fun is fine (seriously, HRT has made me a bit sadistic; I now enjoy being the conversational equivalent of being a brat tamer from time to time) because it's basically the genderswapped equivalent of the back-and-forth roasting a lot of my guy friend groups did, but that needs to be done in moderation with an understanding that you are not the role of that and that the point of expressing yourself is you be yourself and not a role that is a cartoonish infantilization of yourself.

So yeah, congrats to those that tried so hard to turn me into a woman. You might have got what you wanted in the broadest sense, but I am taking that power you took from me back by protecting people from the likes of you. If that means being a noisy stick in the mud to make sure that those around me approach the topic of gender in a serious and safe way whilst accepting who someone says they are without an agenda as that was a right that I didn't get, I will gleefully be a bit of a bitch.

I'm not even doing this as an act of petulant rebellion or from internalized transphobia (but I'll admit that those are there to a certain extent even if they're far from being deciding factors). I'm doing this because these are my own convictions I have built through my own understandings and my own experiences, so don't get the impression that I'm an internally transphobic self-hating woman who wants to lock off femininity from others because it makes me suffer and I regret finding out I am trans because that's simply not the case. Even if I regret not getting the right to self-identify and properly self-actualize, I like many parts of being a woman, such being a momma grizzly bear ready to fight to protect people by ripping faces off.

And that's especially to say that I'm not aligning with transphobes or being their useful idiot (they won't even approve of me, and I don't want them to). Transphobes are fucking assholes but they're still human beings, yet even if I have some modicum of sympathy toward them for getting hoodwinked into hatred, transphobes are still bigoted idiots. They have access to the same information I and everyone else does, but they reach very different conclusions for very different reasons, such as how self-righteous hate feels so good when you can tell yourself that you're doing it to protect the innocent (i.e., children), or that they're delusional psychos who are convinced we can all literally ascend into heaven if we pray hard enough and cleanse enough of the impure out of society. Seriously, the recent "gender critical" (transphobe) coverage of Briana Ghey has been inexcusable and repugnant; even if this proves to be a watershed moment for the general public of TERF Island where they understand how cruel and inhumane "gender critical" people can be, a child is dead and the only way her parents could grieve was publicly. That it took this is a moral failing, and one that makes me very scared about how tribalistic humans can be toward those they view as outcasts.

Despite that, I don't feel hate for rapid transphobes or for rapid transfem egg crackers (a term I am treating as close to a slur now). I feel pity and a lack of patience for both, a bit of that smugness to try and prove I am right by cutting my own path, a borderline maternal instinct to make sure those around me are safe, and the moral duty to have the courage to stand up against what is wrong while not falling into the level of deplorable tactics my opponents use nor being corrupted by an ego that says I can do no harm because I know every situation and every person is unique and there will never be a purely black and white moral choice for any of this.

I also know this whole section has sounded like me riding a power trip, but I must reiterate that is not the case. This isn't the rant of a deluded knight in shining armor tilting at windmills or the heady chuuni notions of divine vengeance of the Count of Monte Cristo. This is the wailing war cry of a bloody, broken survivor of people trying to take away something very important from me who is filled with guilt for letting that happen to me and others by contributing to those victims being deprived of their right to find who they are, and I am making sure nobody goes through the pain I did to reach here. Finding out you aren't who you thought you were doesn't take egg cracking, a rapid support network not willing to listen to doubts nor willing to be patient, a wannabe high school clique of bullies, emotional manipulation, hollow affirmations, misinformation about surgeries, perfect HRT dosing, starting HRT before your first puberty, rigged genes, sexualizing femininity or masculinity, infantilizing femininity or masculinity, or anything but courage, conviction, and a bit of safety to come out on your own when you are ready or even to just admit it to yourself privately.

This isn't an impossible dream we will never reach, and it isn't an idealistic fairytale either. I've seen it happen in the months since with folks I'd had private suspicions of who are finally comfortable sharing that part of who they are or trusting enough to open up about it in any way as they admit they don't have answers while I listen and don't push answers on them. I'm proud of them, but I'm far prouder of this supportive culture with a kinder and more honest hands-off approach that I'm trying to build around me than I ever was of the street gangs of sledgehammers who I thought were my friends but were more like crack addicts desperate for their fix. This is the type of solidarity I want to fight for in a small community I have started and am very much a part of as well as the larger trans movement. I want to be a part of this, not whatever has gotten into the heads of some people that makes them always think they are right and that being trans means you have to be ideologically pure like a cult member while trying to find new converts. I think that is wrong, but I am often wrong myself. I might be wrong here, but I will always take the time to sit down and talk with people who think I am to understand why. You're just going to have to bring some very convincing arguments to the table to get me to change my mind on some key points, and so far, nobody has done so.

Far from this arc being a repentance or an attempt at absolution from my own guilt, this is what I hope is the start of a legacy I can carve into my own little corner of the internet and pass onto those I am close to who will outlive me, and it feels so important to me as my second goal in life after re:Dreamer. I can't effectively do this as a man the same way I could as a woman (allyship from the side vs solidarity where this affects me personally), but I don't need to be a useful idiot or "one of the bad ones" to stand up for the type of community I want. I just need a sense of right or wrong, and for the first time in a long time, I have that strong moral compass in me, and it is telling me that this is right.

But what if I told you that I now feel more lost than ever?


4. Life, Part Four (or Part Two)

Relax, here we go, part two, check me out...

Before we begin Part Four, I want you to listen to "Luv(sic) Part 2" by Shing02 and Nujabes. Don't worry, I'll wait. After all, it's only 4 minutes and 30 seconds long.

So, that's one of my favorite songs. It's a little bit hard to fully catch the full meaning of a rap song the first time you hear it, so here are the lyrics from Genius if you need them.

I use my words for a living, but this writing uses a song I like and chooses to let its lyrics help speak to and for me while adding my own chorus to tell a story. Think of it as a curated soundtrack much like re:Dreamer's. Please don't be afraid to listen along with me as I write this. In fact, just right click the video I linked and put that song on loop. After all, I've had it on loop while writing this.

I feel like Shing02 is almost overlooked on this track. He wrote and sang the lyrics, but Nujabes is often credited as the artist for providing the song's admittedly fantastic beat that served as Shing02's inspiration for his truly heartfelt confession to his love of music and love itself.

Maybe that’s why there's a natural dichotomy in the song. Shing02 is the God and the devil who saw the devil and God in the listener. I don't want to think that there's any sense of jealousy or resentment between these Shing02 and Nujabes, but maybe that's because I'm too proud of a person to not think I'd feel that in Shing02's situation.

As Shing02 says, "The beat plus the melody's the recipe / Your vibe surely brings out the best in me." He frequently collaborated for close to a decade until Nujabes' untimely death from a traffic accident in 2010. One has achieved postmortem artistic immortality as the person most people think of when they think of lo-fi hip-hop. The other is a relatively inactive artist who is all too often a footnote to a creative partner. Who is to be envied more? Shing02 wrote in the Luv(sic) Hexalogy's notebook, "...it was important to write something personal, a song that spoke about my own vulnerability about wanting to have a lasting relationship with music," but was Nujabes' untimely death why Shing02's relationship with music seems distant? Did they need each other more than they knew?

Luv(sic) Part 2 in particular was written by Shing02 as if it were a letter to someone that "he had lost touch with." Nujabes is dead. Shing02 isn't. It's hard not to interpret the song in a modern light as something touching meant for Nujabes. It's... deeply sad when viewed in that light.


Music matters a lot to me (sound in general does; I wouldn't have picked up a hobby about making your daily computer peripheral sound good nor spent so much time on re:Dreamer's audio design if it didn't). Not only have I grown out of being that edgy INTJ boy who thought music was a wasteful use of human effort (seriously, never in my life did I think I'd be a writer as my career), but listening to seems to help my corticobasal syndrome by naturally increase my dropping dopamine levels and lifting my mood. Was I ever that edgy INTJ boy?

While there are still many unanswered questions about why, music therapy often proves helpful for Parkinson's disease where more traditional therapies like physical therapy might not provide many benefits. My doctors still aren't quite sure what's going on with my complex neurochemistry (that whole "my brain collapses getting off estrogen" part in particular really threw them for a loop), but decreasing dopamine levels are a thing I am struggling with, and as the form of art that decorates time, music makes the room less lonely. Because it's lonelier than ever.

I can't even begin to count the number of times I've slip into a flow state (insert genderfluid joke here) while writing and listening to music, to say nothing of being a former speedrunner and that whole hobby is about entering flow state and getting the dopamine trickle from practice while chasing the euphoric dopamine hit from a personal best (and the collaborative grassroots effort to dismantle a game in theory and in execution). You see, it's working together that achieves results.

I may enter a flow state as part of my work and play, but rap artists do it as part of their life. A song can live or die based on the flow of the artist. My flow has solidified.

Rap is the genre of music closest to writing that exists; in fact, The Epic of Gilgamesh, humanity's oldest written work, was a poem rapped by priests. I don't write music or lyrics, but I often worry about the sonorous quality and the flow of a paragraph as I write it. There's an important voice missing.


Until very recently, I identified as genderfluid. Unlike how some support servers I was in treated it (or how the "Gender Fandom" wiki treats it), it wasn't validating to me or a way to freely express myself and I would never have typed "I love being genderfluid!" or "I am deciding to be a man today." It was a chain holding me down to the floor and limiting my options between "male" and "female" with next to zero wiggle room and without control over which I had, and that turned out to be a key link in the chain of how I worked that changed a decent bit about who I was.

I want to state clearly that the only part of my identity that shifted was my gender identity and that this wasn't DID (which is something I think the vast majority of people who say they have are faking; I'm gonna stop taking you seriously the second you start using "alters" to describe yourself) or OSDD (I do have that, but for a different reason).

I might be on an arc with wholly accepting a person's self-reported identity, but a mental illness isn't an identity. Show up with a formal diagnosis or I'm going to ridicule you like I do when people claim to be OCD without a diagnosis.

In a sense, my gender identity was a spinning compass, and I had no stability to find who I was because that identity wasn't stable. Forget the ability to control who you are, it's frightening to not have the ability to rely on yourself.

I relied on being a man, far more than I have relied on being a woman. I liked being a man, and not just because it was simpler and easier or that most of my interests were "male-coded" (but as I've been coming to learn, gender is a bit of a self-perpetuating lie). For me, being a man wasn't the awful existence that I've had some trans women say it was for them. I wouldn't be the person I am today without him and erasing that life or idly wondering what my life would have been like had I been born female is akin to erasing myself. That life, had it existed, would have been the life of a sister my age who had no knowledge of me. Sacrificing myself for her is utterly detestable to me. I absolutely refuse to subscribe to the idea that the first 30 years of my life were a false start or a waste of time (especially when I'm dead within a decade), but I can't help feeling this disgusting feeling that the last 9-12 months were.

I've pushed through mountains of heartache and drama and almost wound up dead, created tests as close to empirically valid as I can, done things right by being in the system of mental healthcare and endocrinologist visits instead of listening to the cavalier opinions of crazy jerks and taking DIY hormones, and thought a lot about who I am. I've come to an answer beyond a basic "I'm me and nobody else" or even a childish "I am Sam. Sam-I-Am."

I'm not Guy-Am-I. I'm a trans woman (or at least, I'm very close to being a trans woman), and I don't particularly like that.

Even now I feel that warning bell in my head telling me this isn't who I am, but my brain is out of tricks to get me to believe I'm still a man after everything I've done to wiggle out of this revelation.

This is that stability I wanted for months, but it's melancholy and even lonely to finally get here. I needed this, and even if almost everything is pointing to this being who I am and ultimately the decision I came to for myself without anyone pushing me, it's sad. I feel like I'm mourning myself. I don't even know what killed the guy in me this much or when it happened, and it wasn't a big dramatic Old Yeller moment. I think he, I... just faded away. If this had to happen, is it selfish that I wanted a fairytale sort of conclusion with a tidy bow as I tied up the loose ends of being a guy? There was so much left to do, and now I never can. I have to pass the baton to myself and do my best to carry it even if it feels like I'm beating myself back and over the head with a stick.

C'est la vie, as they say L-O-V-E evidently, see every song has a sequel / Never same, everything but the name, all fresh just like back then, how we do every day / C'est la vie, as they say L-O-V-E eloquently, see every dream has a part two / Never same, you got to keep it tight, always just like back then, now hear me out...

The name isn't the same, and it isn't like it was back then. It never can be again. I simply can't be that person again.


A few weeks ago, I fought back a shift to masculinity. It was a struggle to resist that floating feeling I get as I lose my sense of balance like the floor was shifting on me, but I ultimately succeeded even if I was incredibly worried I was doing serious psychological harm from some new form of repression, but I was desperate because being a man fills me with such crippling dysphoria over my feminized and still-feminizing body that I am paralyzed by it.

Still, much to my surprise, I kept being able to fight back the identity shifts. Loosely, the key seemed to be telling myself that gender is a wider avenue than I gave it credit for and itemizing how I am a woman, but it relies on rapidly finding a mantra of some kind to tell myself based on whatever is seeming to trigger the shift (as it's almost always an environmental trigger).

That got me curious during one of my moments of female dysphoria: Could I do the reverse? I didn't fight the next shift and even tried to speed it along, but it ultimately didn't even cause my gender identity to flip. I just felt intensely uncomfortable. The next time two days later, I didn't push it or resist. I just let what was going to happen, well, happen, and that happened to be nothing besides brief but intense discomfort.

As I realized, I couldn't even force a shift to masculinity. I've been able to do that thrice with femininity, but the converse hasn't applied. That left me in a really frightening place of thinking I got exactly what I had wanted for months only to end up hating it.


That was about a week ago, and things soon reached a head with what I was thinking not lining up with what I was thinking, and I was falling apart at the seams. I needed to take a step back, sit down, and work this out.

As I told the server:

I'm gonna be stepping away from the server for a few days to focus on work and my life. Not only am I trying to coordinate a move out of an abusive household, "my house" is an utter wreck and I need distance and quiet to figure out if I'm okay with where my life is headed.

Well, fuck, that's kind of spoilers, but fuck it, that is the verbatim quote.

As I told my best friend who knows how complicated gender identity and finding stability in it is:

I don't want to leave you on that cryptic note because you're my best friend, and please don't ask for more right now because I just don't fucking have answers, but I'm in a situation of never wanting to make a social transition and not wanting to have this feminizing body but being completely unable to think of myself as a man anymore and feeling like there are newly built psychological walls inside my head that weren't there 2 weeks ago.


It's scaring the shit out of me, but I need to come to my own isolated conclusion about this.

So, how I did that was by doing something incredibly stupid and dangerous. I cut my 4 mg/day of estrogen and 50 mg/day of bicalutamide in half (starting from skipping a dose; I tried to do a full cold turkey but that was just fucking hell and I had to compromise), and if you know my neurochemistry and how badly things have gone with me while cutting a dose, that was extremely reckless.

I had my sister's engagement party that weekend (unlike the Christmas party, I was able to show up and bind for the two hours of it), so my progress was a bit slow, but I sat down and worked on this list of pros and cons for getting off HRT + detransitioning vs staying on HRT and socially transitioning, and to remove as much bias as possible, I worked on this both while identifying as a man and while identifying as a woman (turns out dysphoria with a half HRT dose was so intense I shifted back, even if it was only for 3 hours!)

This was a painful affair. Not only was my right arm trembling and cramped as shit (just barely working enough to type), but I was taking a hard objective look at myself that I've not done in a while. Writing is how I solidify my tumultuous thoughts and give them weight, and even while trying to balance the scales for my masculinity as much as I could, the results are kind of damning.


First, I apparently didn't like being a guy as much as I thought I did (but to be honest, some of those memories are slipping in a very uncomfortable way; I have memories of liking things about being male but am having a hard time connecting to those emotions). I can't describe the emptiness I felt as a man trying desperately to explain what I liked about being a man and coming up with that little. It was like realizing I was a hollow paper mâché doll and that I'd only ever seen my brittle plaster and paper covering, and it was peeling apart.

Sure, the cons of being a female aren't good, but you can see some of that was scraping the bottom of the barrel looking for reasons to hate it with excuses that started to tread the line on being rewording of other reasons.

But what pushed me over the top wasn't that nor the cons of being a man, it was the pros of choosing to be a woman. That big block of text you saw me paraphrase for part 2 of this is the obvious highlight, but I want to focus on 3 parts:

Something in my head feels "right" about being a woman that I am not sure feels "right" as a man, even pre-HRT. This one is hard to describe, but there are moments of absolute certainty where my female gender identity cannot be ripped from my head and that seems to be a firmer truth than the moments when I think of myself as a man (especially in the last 3 months).

This is such a conviction that it feels like a mental illness. I feel like I could have someone hit me in my soul with the most intense transphobia possible tailored for my specific fears, and with the exception of one key point (motherhood), I'd probably just laugh. I am a woman. This is a fact. Anyone attempting to argue otherwise won't be able to convince me.

Honestly, who cares if it's a delusion when it's this strong? Forget someone else doing it, I'm not able to convince myself that I'm a man when I'm like this.

This is going to be a big decision and even if it is a mistake, it will not be (by definition) me burying my head in the sand of my own life and letting it pass me by, which is something I am very afraid of.

God, that is a powerful notion. I am a woman not because of those who tried to get me to be a woman but despite them. I have burned bridges and fought against them to prove that I'm my own woman, not their version of a woman (some parts of which frankly disgust me). It is taking my life by the fucking throat, ripping its head out of the sand, putting it into a chokehold, and making it look me in the face and understand that I am the one who has control now, not it, and especially not those who tried to take it from me.

I told you HRT made me a bit more sadistic, right?

I have 3 decades of a dream life and about a decade's worth of dream memories rattling around in my head, and those memories seem so real and too important to discard like this.

Yeah, so...

U-Uh... more on that in a bit...


Regardless of how right this female gender identity might feel, choosing to act on developing it and share it with you all is a choice. I used to worry that making a fuller commitment to be a woman gives power to some of the worst people I have ever met and no amount of telling myself that I am doing this because I found who I am despite what they tried to do to me will let me spin this story as anything less than "they were right for the wrong reasons," but that's not true.

Even if these women had the best of intentions, they were unilaterally wrong because:

  • I in fact liked my masculinity (and still do even if I now have to express it in different ways which I am still discovering).

  • I was pushed onto this journey without my consent by those who think masculinity is an enemy to be eradicated (and let's be honest, trans women who hated themselves for being trans more than I hate myself for being trans; if they didn't, they wouldn't bemoan how they needed surgeries to pass, or had frequent meltdowns about their appearance, or burned their male clothing in a dramatic attempt to create a before and after in their life that doesn't exist, or cut ties with hobbies they used to enjoy as men but now viewed as too masculine, or recklessly gone around with sledgehammers, or tried to live through me).

  • I was shamed for not having enough femininity for those who wanted to live through me (and to this day, I think those early months of my transition created traumatic triggers with my dislike of my chest, the infantilization of me as a person, and seeing others treat those starting their gender journey or on the cusp of starting it like they treated me).

  • I started to hate being a woman because of how differently people were treating me as one (again, some people took advantage of me and turned me into the cutesy server mascot, and I had to fucking put up with it until I put my foot down and felt awful from being assertive to what I still viewed as my friends).

  • I had to escape from the pressure to a non-binary identity (which felt necessary given how hard people wanted to shove me through a mold of what their ideal trans woman was and acted insulted for me not wanting to take outfit suggestions or even name suggestions). That arc was valid.

  • I was told some of the meanest things I have ever heard all because I was identifying as non-binary (for instance, I got told by (N) I had gaslit myself into being trans or non-binary simply because I write a gender bender porn game; seriously, if you are trans or any flavor of not being "default" with your gender, how do you think you would feel if your identity got invalidated because someone told you it was just a fetish you were confusing with reality?)

  • I lost friends and suffered personal betrayals simply from not being what people wanted me to be from their own expectations they set for me (do I even need to clarify further why this is fucked?)

  • I endured months of chaos as a non-binary (and soon thereafter) genderfluid person (the lack of control was terrifying, and I felt so helpless that I couldn't even plan the next day because I didn't know who I would be let alone what I would be months or years from now). This arc was also valid.

  • I was told all my opinions on femininity were invalid due to my non-binary identity (seriously, what the fuck is wrong with a person when they tell me to shut up because I expressed that having a big chest was like a monkey's paw wish that wasn't worth it; even cis women with large chests feel that way about theirs).

  • I lost the respect of my parents (they were sort of on-board with the "hi, I'm Samantha, your trans daughter" thing, but they didn't understand the genderfluid aspect despite trying my hardest to explain "please stick to Sam and they/them for when it's just us or my sister and/or her fiancé, and use DEADNAME and he/him otherwise" and blamed me for making things more complicated for them).

  • I spent thousands of dollars on a very specialized gender therapist to undo the damage my "friends" had done (and he was horrified by the stories I had told him about how I had been treated), and $1,200 a month isn't a cheap expense.

  • Getting here nearly killed me, it killed parts of me (notably, my masculine gender identity and I am grieving for him almost like he was murdered), and it killed my starry-eyed innocence (or rather, "ignorance") to the worst parts of transfem communities (even if I belong in this Venn diagram now, I don't really "belong" in those social circles).

This was not an issue of a lack of support (again, there were dozens of friends who were beyond eager to help me), DIY hormones gone haywire (there was that, but mostly with the CBS in that I couldn't get off of them), poor HRT results (if anything, I have "Barry Bonds" numbers for being so strong they look fake and people suspect I did something extra to dope myself up; I got accused of Day 1 progesterone use or being intersex to explain my results), internalized transphobia (I was liking myself as a woman up until a week or two before my suicide attempt, and I am liking parts of myself as a woman now), a lack of trust in those around me (quite the opposite), a bad living situation (things were tense with my parents but not unbearable until I tried to walk back parts of coming out), or really anything else but the obvious.

I repeatedly got told who I was and trusted those who told me who I was more than I trusted myself.

I won't mince words or try to make excuses for myself as I was ultimately responsible for everything. Nobody forced me to do anything with a gun to my head, but a number were emotionally manipulative on levels I have never seen before. After my revelation that I wasn't cis, I was like a dumb newborn baby bird who tumbled from the nest. I relied on those around me for guidance while ignoring my inner compass like an idiot until it broke. It took me what felt like forever to find a heading again, and it's not in the same direction those who pushed me tried to point me in. I am here not just despite them but to spite them, but hopefully more of the former. I need to move on with my life and this writing.


As I boldly take my first steps to take my life back by getting to define what my femininity means to me and reject the definition thrust onto me (what did you think this was?), I have time to look back on the past moments of my identity as they inevitably disappear below the horizon. It's natural to have regrets, and I have more than most, but I'll focus on the whole of those phases of my life with the subtitles being at least sort of relevant lyrics from "Luc(sic) Part 2" and hopefully stay coherent.


Part One: Well anyways, I am not a perfect being, yes I am a man full of S-I-N.

I was a man. I refuse to subscribe to the idea that I secretly never was a man because that's a definition of who I am defined by other people, and I am done with those. I was often not happy as a man, but I also often was, especially in the last few years writing re:Dreamer. Had someone come up to me with a sledgehammer back when I was in college and in lower points of my life where I thought I was going insane from OCD and schizoaffective hallucinations and could have been convinced of almost anything, I don't think what came after this would have been so hard to walk on, but it just as easily would have led to an even worse outcome.

More than anything, I am glad I was a man and got the chance to be one. I don't hate that 29-year-long arc like I've seen all too often from trans women, and I especially don't want to replace it with the arc of some hypothetical me who was AFAB. She might have been happier than me, but she wouldn't be me, nor would she have wound up nearly as interesting.

As cliché as it is to say, the masculinity built character, and it's character that I'm glad I got the chance to build from something that wasn't suffering.

I've joked that I'm basically Calvin's dad before.


Part Two: The rhymes will heal cause I believe in music.

I started the first trans arc like it'd be the defining moment of my life or even the victory lap, but I soon got lost on the road from bad directions. You don't need me to reiterate how frustrating all of this got. It was like having at least a dozen backseat drivers who insisted they could do better than me, but, like, I drove for a living for several years. I was good at it, and before my CBS started messing with my spatial memory, I knew where everything was and never got lost while barely relying on maps. More importantly, I was a safe driver, so I'm not going to take criticism from a woman (W) who had a car that her boyfriend refused to let her drive because she was such an unsafe driver and a woman (J) who drove 30 miles above the speed limit everywhere (her friend described her as a maniac behind the wheel and he felt genuinely unsafe being in a car with her) and who later had so many accidents driving a car that she shouldn't have bought because it was outside her budget that she couldn't afford to keep it from the insurance increases and sold it.

All of these are true stories, by the way! Not gonna lie, I'm kind of proud how I got this all artfully wrapped into a metaphor about how these women couldn't drive and sucked at trying to steer my transition where they wanted it to go when I was a good driver who used to always know where I was going but later had to rely on maps and directions.

Just gonna give myself a little pat on the back here for being a clever writer while reminding you this sticker is called "SmugLesbianWriter" for reasons (and it was called that before I realized I wasn't cis).

If I'd had a car, it'd have broken down here. I didn't. I was walking, and the soles of my shoes wore down. Maybe I got jumped by some crack addict who took my shoes? Either way, I now had to proceed barefoot.


Part Three: Knowing hardship appreciate the best of both worlds.

What came next was the most treacherous footing for sure, starting with what was nearly the end of my road. It's hard to know when the vaguely non-binary road turned into the genderfluid road, but that arc of my life was real. I know for a fact that I alternatively thought of myself as both a man and as a woman, and both parts were with nearly the ironclad certainty I have now. I'm not quite ready to say that my genderfluid arc is done before I have a long talk with my specialized gender therapist about it, but he's out of town at conferences for the next two weeks. Maybe I am still genderfluid. From what I've been able to research, it's a coin flip to be a transitory state into a more solidified identity or a permanent identity in and of itself, but I suspect that I am leaving that territory soon. Maybe I'll get a summer home here... you know, those second houses you can get when you get rich enough that have shittier versions of your possessions? The fluidity was hell, but in a way, it was an interesting experience to be a tourist with two gender identities even if I had so little control over it.

One part I did have control over was who I presented as, even if I always chose to publicly present as male just for the convenience of it (and because I know I don't pass as female right now). One of the things that made me hesitate on seeing myself as a woman is that I actually don't get dysphoric of others seeing me as male. I've even had a weird bit of enjoyment doing "guy things" with a female identity; in particular, I have enjoyed over-accentuating my use of gendered language for myself.

As an example, I was at a phone repair store and the employee and I were talking about how the Pixel 8s have had way too many quality control issues and because I had used an MRA with Google itself I now was stuck using them for all future repairs if I wanted to keep my warranty, so I was complaining about how I got an Android to get off Apple's ecosystem only for Google to do the same thing but decided the talk was going nowhere and I said, "I could keep going, but I'm starting to rant like a crotchety old grandpa and you've got another guy waiting behind me." It didn't feel like I was being honest saying that stuff, but I still liked it, like I was cosplaying a more outgoing and dorkier version of my male self, and there wasn't a single bit of discomfort knowing people saw me as a dude, but I wasn't thinking of myself as one.

I think part of why I embraced this play was that I knew this was the last hurrah of my ability to present as male. I'm for all intents and purposes stuck on HRT for the rest of my life and any attempt to get off it would be fraught with danger, and as the genderfluid arc had dragged on, I'd gained confidence as a blossoming woman, but it had come with a crippling despair of being a man who has been this emasculated with no way to stop it.

To let Oingo Boingo's "Dead Man's Party" and Danny Elfman (yes, that Danny Elfman; Oingo Boingo was his band) sum this up for me: "I'm all dressed up with nowhere to go / Walkin' with a dead man over my shoulder." This isn't a party for me, yet maybe this is his sad yet happy funeral? It'd fit the dichotomy of my last few months.

"Don't run away, it's only me. / Don't be afraid of what you can't see."


Before I start to wrap this up, I want to explain that even after all of this, my gender does not define me as a person. My gender is important to me, but it is far from the most important aspect to me... unless I want to pretend something like "writergender" is a valid gender identity, because if it is (it isn't), a gender identity where "one feels being a writer is inherent to their identity to the point of being their gender or eclipsing whatever their gender is" hits the nail on the head.

I think far more than most, there is and was always an inherent plasticity in my gender identity (which would explain why I gravitated toward the subject matter and the term "AGP" to explain the fetish, which I've always treated as a study of similarities, contrasts, and changed states rather than an envious worship of femininity).

Had things been different, I think I could have lived comfortably as a man, a static non-binary person (be it bigender, agender, or a muddier mix), or even a genderfluid person (this would have required work to master the shifts, but I proved one part of four was possible; after all, I am kind of the gender bender on more levels than I thought possible with my work, unintentionally with others, unintentionally with myself, and intentionally with myself).

Had (C) and others not been doing things like this to me for years, I think this is what I would have settled on, but even if I "knew" who I was I made the conscious decision not to pursue the understanding of my own gender because I in fact liked being a guy.

God, the fucking awfulness to respond with this to someone in the middle of a panic attack from realizing they weren't cis and hating it who was only sharing that revelation because "what I’m feeling right now is so intense that I need to actually explore it and not bury my head in the fucking sand."

But I don't live in those parallel universes that don't exist where my stated gender identity was respected or I am content as a man but always feeling like I was missing something from my life. I live in this reality (mostly) and I'm a woman, even if I am always feeling like there is something missing from my life.

As weird as it is to say as someone who I think only got here because she couldn't get off feminizing HRT, I think that the missing ingredient is masculinity. I'm a woman wishing she could be more than that, and a man specifically, but that part of me is either gone or buried deep. I think it's the latter, because I can still kind of feel his presence, and he's tired. Maybe I was in a car all along and the person behind the wheel finally tapped out from exhaustion. Maybe he didn't do a good job, but I know he did the best he could. I am proud of him for going this far, and I don't blame him for passing the wheel. I can take over and get us to the finish line, but I hope he doesn't mind if I change the song after this verse. Our rule on long road trips (of which I've done 5, 2 of which were with other drivers) is that the driver gets to play their music, and I'm sick of hearing this one song on loop.


Understand the time has finally come to realize the great power of one / All formulas equalize under the sun, amen.


And now, a change of drivers and a change of song. Fitting that it's before the song ends...

"Luv(sic) Part 2" was... no, is one of my favorite songs, but now I have a new one that is emphatically my favorite: Death Cab for Cutie's "I Will Possess Your Heart" and fittingly, the music video has a hot redheaded woman on a long journey as a hypnotic bass drones on like the hum of a car engine does after hours behind the wheel or an obsessive thought after it gets stuck in my head.

But don't worry... I won't be stupid enough to drive with a video playing even though it's kind of sad I'm missing out on a stereotypical validation as a woman by being a bad driver. I'm a good driver, maybe a lost driver, but above all, a safe driver, and I'll keep my head down. There's two of us in here now, remember?

Man or woman, I will still like Halo, and I will still like being a total dork who makes awkward references that don't quite fit, either as one-off jokes, longer jokes with callbacks, or even entire scenes.

Huh, maybe I won't have to sacrifice as much as I thought I would to be the type of woman I want to be...?


And now, after so much, I'm finally here.

I thought about a "good boy" here, but even I have at least some shame (says the woman writing a porn game for her job).


Part Four: I will possess your heart.

I'm a trans woman. She/Her, or She/They, but either way, a woman, and one who is more trans than not to the point that I no longer feel like it'd more accurately fit to call myself some flavor of non-binary instead of trans. I'm probably more alone and vulnerable than ever and I'm acting like a bit of a yandere control freak like the other Sam(antha) to compensate (not to mention a weird goofball because I know what's next and I'm scared of it so I pretend I can get out of it by padding my word count), but I'm in my element behind the wheel and I'm looking ahead, eyes on the road and being safe. That road ahead of me is so long and unfamiliar, and I might be a chaotic mess, and that road might be a treacherous mess, but I am pumped to drive it to the song I chose.

I just wish I didn't have such a clear map leading to a destination I can't reach no matter how much I drive...


5. Re:re:Dreamer

Alternatively, "reeeeee Dreamer" (dats me yellin into the void).

Bluntly, that dream from December fucked me up.

I want you to take a look at this. This is the tip of the iceberg of how much this fucked me up. There are more "memories" of that fake life than the time I have left in my own life. It is truly that dense, and even if some broken part of me keeps procedurally generating those memories based on environmental triggers, they still feel so real. Usually that feeling is devastated sadness.

I am only able to function by putting a tight lid on that fake dream life and all that I remember, but that lid loosens right before I go to bed, when I randomly wake up in the middle of the night (I've got big tits and roll around in my sleep, remember?), or when I wake up in the morning. It is currently 1:24 AM as I write this exact sentence. I have a fairly early doctor's appointment in the morning, but I am so scared to go to sleep like I am almost every night that I am working myself to the point of exhaustion so I can overcome my tight chest and anxious heartbeat and actually sleep, and I'm not sure if I want it to be dreamless or not.

I'm terrified of seeing that life again in my dreams. I in fact once did, but I likely just hallucinated it from stress because looking back at that one feels so much different than the rest and so fake that I didn't even include it in the Imgur album above. But as much as it saddens and frightens me that such an impactful event was truly a one-time thing, I'm even more scared I'll forget that experience even if all signs are indicating that I'm stuck with it (but given that I thought I was going to be catastrophically genderfluid for the rest of my life, who knows).

Remember how I said I had OSDD? On January 10, 2024, I got diagnosed with OSDD type 3 (acute dissociative reactions to stressful events), but it's not because of the obvious gender identity fuckery. The short of it is that ever since my dream, my depersonalization (feeling as if I am not real), derealization (feeling as if reality isn't real), wonky perception (how time and space seems to shift on me), and small bits of short-term memory loss have worsened. That is all greatly concerning especially since the last two can be attributed to CBS, but the one that really got my psychologist worried was the way I described my own bodily perception, even if that too can be attributed to CBS.

As concisely as I can, the shape of my body and the space it occupies were different in that dream, and I forget what the shape of my body actually is way too often. I bump into things with my shoulders, my stride is jerky, I underestimate my arm length, I eat too little for my size, and so on. Not to disparage those who get gender dysphoria (which I also got both ways), but this is body dysmorphia on another level, and I say this as someone who wanted to make medical prostheses as my career and know how difficult phantom limb syndrome is (God's cruel irony is that I got robbed of my ability to make prostheses by OCD as I am getting robbed by more and more of the use of my right arm by CBS).

I now have the mental equivalent of a broken mirror from two conflicting and incompatible sets of memories of how my body exists and operates, and I draw from the wrong one quite often. I have memories of being someone who is me yet isn't me. I want to be her so much, but I can't be her and I am going insane both trying to and trying not to.

I have a callous on the base of my left ring finger from constantly rubbing and pinching it to remind myself that the wedding band that I all too often think is there actually isn't and never was. I put Samantha Taylor's wedding band on "my" copied sprites and felt so sad that I just cried for what was at least half an hour and which only stopped as I nearly trashed my computer.

I once used stable diffusion to recreate how I looked in that dream. I got very, very close and even made a few of the outputs pregnant, but it just made me cry and I deleted the prompts and outputs.

I have memories of having kids and raising them. I know they're fake, but I can't stop missing them like they're dead. These incompatible thoughts and feelings are splitting me apart at the seams worse than the genderfluidity ever did. I feel like I have fucking psychosis and—

And now I'm spiraling and can't keep typing, so goodnight!


And now I'm back. I woke up with yet another panic attack. I'm alone, but even worse than being lonely is being haunted by ghosts my brain made up.


I don't have a precise term for what happened to me. "A vivid dream" seems so inadequate. I have spent weeks browsing oneirology and cognitive neuroscience articles for a precise term and while I have found dead links to some case studies in dream journals, I still don't have a term and have to describe it as a vivid semi-lucid dream that left me with dream-reality confusion and probably some degree of PTSD.

Fuck it, I'm already a dorky captain. I have a better explanation that dorks like me will get.

If you've seen Star Trek: The Next Generation's "The Inner Light" you will know how much Picard's dream in that episode completely fucked him up for about half a season. I just rewatched this clip of the final minutes of the episode, and the scene of him tightly clutching the flute before finding the courage to play it in a dark lonely room with the saddest and most beautiful melody is simply haunting. I relate to it on a level I don't think anyone I know ever will.

You see, I was a fucking awful cook in that dream. I have the memories of the hundreds of times I've gone shopping for groceries and cooking meals with them, likely all borderline inedible (some sensory details from the dream are fuzzy, particularly taste; lucky me, I guess).

While hormonal, sleep-deprived, and borderline incoherent, I tried to cook one of those recipes: mac n cheese. Maybe it would have been kind of edible despite being an unholy blend of Swiss, cheddar, and American cheese had I not oversalted the fuck out of the panko breadcrumbs with 1/3 teaspoon salt. That turned it into an utter salt bomb that I had to scrape in the trash after a few bites.

I kinda want to give another dream recipe a shot someday because I have a ton of them, but I barely know how to cook, and I think I'd become an even worse cook trying to make any of those. Sadly, unlike Picard, I don't think trying to explore this as a form of art will help me.

By the way, I didn't realize "The Inner Light" overlap until last month despite it being the best episode of TNG. I often wake up gasping now, but this was of a different type than the usual.

It's also not the only time Captain Jean-Luc Picard has hit me in the soul. I had no idea this scene was there and I almost fucking burst into ugly tears right in front of my parents, but thankfully one had left the room for a call and the other was half-asleep.

But wait, the plagiarism rabbit hole goes even further! This is from re:Dreamer's world information entry of Zach's Mom and is over a year old:

Samantha didn't need to study with other people, but the new phase of her plan with her future husband was to be present if Jeff ever struggled with an academic question and to gently help guide him to the answer if he ever asked for it, with the assumption that he'd slowly rely on her more and more. While at a group study session with this purpose in mind, everyone lost focus, and someone put on an episode of Star Fleet: The New Generation and it turned into a watch party instead.


This turned out to be the single best thing that could have happened for Samantha Zimmermann on her quest to become Samantha Taylor, as the episode put on, "Remain In Light," was one of the most romantic in the entire series and one widely considered as among the very best in the entire franchise.


Samantha and Jeff left the study-session-turned-watch-party together, and romance was obviously on both of their minds, although unlike Samantha, Jeff wasn't enraptured by it right now.


He commented on how intensely she was watching that episode and was curious why. Samantha's obvious answer would have been "I want that type of married life with you," but she mentioned that her dad is a jazz musician and that bit in the story with Picardy's whistle really spoke to her soul. Jeff shrugged and said the episode was very good but that he liked an earlier episode about the trial for proving Lieutenant Commander D8A's sentience better. "Now that episode is peak television!"


Samantha was a little upset at herself for not realizing that she and her future husband were both total Fleeters until this exact moment. She wouldn't even have needed to do anything for this slam dunk of getting him to like her more since she genuinely loved the franchise as it was one of the few pieces of media she was allowed to consume in her very strict household growing up.


Jeff brought Samantha back from her self-deprecating internal monologue about her failure to notice this by commenting that it was cool seeing Samantha act so passionate about something as simple as a TV show, even if it was a good show and a good episode from it. In fact, it was just cool seeing how much more passionate she'd gotten about everything since they first met. He never would have thought that meek, fidgety dork he bumped into almost a year ago would have turned out to be such a wonderful woman, but he's glad that she did.


Samantha nearly screamed in triumphant joy from this. This is what she has been waiting to hear from her future husband for over a year now!


But she played it cool and gave a coy grin and a flirty wink (she knew she couldn't quite copy all of Jeff's moves and throw them back at him or he'd start to get suspicious, so she omitted the thumbs up), and she said, "Stick around. I'm full of surprises."


Jeff told Samantha that he was going to take her up on that offer and asked if she wanted to start going out with him.


Again, Samantha nearly screamed out in triumphant joy, but she settled for a very subtle fist pump, just barely tensing the muscles in her arm.


She next laid on the charm a bit thick here (but she knew she could get away with it and that Jeff adores that seductive sultriness) and smoothly said, "Sure, but you're going to have to work hard to keep up with me."

God, I stole this woman's name, stole my profile picture twice (the second being an edit to her sprites which I stole as my sprites), stole her husband's name, stole Star Trek, stole the concept of "The Inner Light" both as what got Jeff and Samantha to start dating but a traumatic event I experienced, stole its reworked name from Talking Heads' best album (Remain In Light), and even stole some of her dorky seductive moves, yet I didn't steal her cooking skills?!


Whatever I call this (besides "unfathomably lazy multilayered mental plagiarism")... I had all the right comorbidities for something like that dream to happen. I had preexisting sleep disorders such as sleep paralysis and insomnia; depression; schizoaffective; and probably BPD. I had a very apparent identity issue and have been dissociating to deal with it which is highly correlated with nightmare disorders. I work a creative job and have a non-stop imagination. I had the subject of motherhood on my mind and was despondent over it. I had taken progesterone for the second time ever and the first time in months, and anecdotal accounts seem to point to those hormones increasing the vividness of dreams. Introverts dream more vividly, and on MTBI I flip-flop between S and N because that test is terrible for replicability. I have a bad habit of grabbing a snack before bed, which seems to influence the strength of dreams. My brain is shrinking (to a degree) as its density increases, and that white matter density seems to matter for dream recall.

Well... that last point needs some clarification. Some part of my brain clearly makes this up as I go along as a confabulation, and I can prove it beyond how it has filled in details while I had a male gender identity in ways that weren't consistent with the rest of the dream. Just doing the math of how I was asleep for 90 minutes and dreamed 30 years aka 15,768,000 minutes, with the condition that I only "remember" about a third of those 30 years, I had between a 175,000:1 to 50,000:1 speed ratio for time passed in my dream vs time that passed in reality, and I do not to believe the human brain can process information that quickly, so these "memories" have to be procedurally generated in some way.

I, uh... I am a fascinating case study, aren't I?

God, Zach and I need a lot of really good therapists...

So that's why this fan art (drawn by Caithiel; no social media) of Zach getting counseling from Kaladin from Stormlight Archives, Dagoth Ur from The Elder Scrolls 3: Morrowind, Harry Du Bois from Disco Elysium, and Captain Jean Luc Picard from Star Trek: The Next Generations is so fucking based and I am so glad to have lying around even if working it in here is kind of awkward! Caithiel has been crushing it with the recent fan art, which you can check out on Dropbox alongside all the rest of the art for this game.

So, what do I do from here? Well, that's the fucked part, ain't it? I keep saying some shit like "I believe in this dream" but there's one dream that my belief in causes so much pain, but it was too powerful to dismiss, nor do I think I ever could, so I've tried hard to scrape some good out of this experience.


Those Discord screenshots had this somewhere:

It's been two weeks since that dream. I think I can conclude that its overall message, its raison d'être, was giving me a scattered and fragmented but nonetheless detailed blueprint of the type of woman I not only want to be but in many ways can be. That person is a dorky woman in her 30s who is a bit more masculine that she would like to be and isn't sure how to explore her limited femininity in a way that isn't uncomfortable and scary, an endearingly earnest tryhard who genuinely cares (perhaps a bit too much) and tries (perhaps a bit too much) because she is a passionate and anxious worrywart who is selfish in how she selflessly puts everyone before herself, a bit of a failure with a sensitive ego that she keeps overcompensating for by boasting about her limited successes and gossiping about the faults of others even if that doesn't make her feel better, and most importantly, a person who keeps getting up again and again to keep caring and trying no matter how many countless setbacks she experiences who can trust others enough to ask for help when she truly needs it.


I shouldn't use that dream to try and turn myself into a fake mother and wife from a life that wasn't real and never can be, nor should I mourn the loss of people that never were to the point that I can't live my own life even if a part of me wants to go back there more than anything. I need to live in the future, not the past.


The experience of finding out I could only have that type of life in a dream was painful, and it bitterly hurt to examine closely, but because I stuck my hand in broken glass to pull out the important parts, I now have a guide or at least a broken map to be a better version of myself.


It's now up to me to use my best judgment to know what parts can fit, what parts can't, and how to fill in the many blanks. It will be difficult but not impossible. My brain screamed at me in the loudest way it could to give me this advice, and I need to take it to heart. After all, if I can't trust my own advice, whose advice can I trust?

Frankly, that's bullshit. My personality is drifting and it's not just because of the gender but because of these "memories," and I am terrified of who I am becoming. This shit threw threw me into a mental meat grinder and I could devote the rest of my life to explaining it the best I could but I simply wouldn't have the time, so I won't even try.

I'll just focus on the most important point, which is that there is a part of me missing, and that's being a parent... no, a mother. It is so painful to explain, and I wished to God I could still think of myself as a man to let him deal with this because I am fraying apart trying, but I was either never a man, that man in me is dead, or he's tired of being passed the fucking buck of crippling dysphoria so I can relax and not feel like I am going insane from a haywire maternal instinct that is both telling me my kids are dead and to replace them.

Some biological clock in me is ringing. Whenever I hang out with my sister, a woman who is 2 years older than me and on the cusp of getting married and having kids, I feel like a monster for how jealous I get of her and the opportunities she had handed to her from birth. I need to have transparency and tell her about this dream, not only because she's too important to me and that dream was too important to me to not let her know, but because some part of me is afraid I'm going to go fucking crazy if she has a kid when I never can and I desperately start to conflate being an aunt with being a mother and try to transpose myself onto my sister.

I already have two envy goals I can't reach named Samantha, and I don't think I can live with myself if I add a third with my sister.

Like Zach, I guess I'm doomed to live in the shadow of a mother I can never be, and I won't even get to watch her and her husband grow old while her kids grow up. If there's not a dead man over my shoulder, there's only me. I'm next in line for the scythe.


6. How Can You Live if We're Too Afraid To Die?

Fire for the hills, pick up your feet and let's go / Head for the hills, pick up steel on your way.

The thought of my own death enraptures and consumes me. Getting diagnosed with Parkinson's disease and later corticobasal syndrome was one of the most impactful events of my life, but even after almost a decade, my doctors still don't even have consensus on what I have. As Dr. Simor Lewis, a neurologist specializing in research of Parkinson's disease and Alzheimer's, can explain for me better than I can, CBS is a vague catch-all term to describe a number of medical conditions that get grouped together. It's a diagnosis of exclusion, yet based on my PET scans, I've got the messed-up tau proteins like more typical corticobasal degeneration, yet my substrantia nigra in particular is showing decay as my dopamine levels are dropping (and responding moderately well to dopamine agonists) in a way typical of Parkinson's disease. The only way to know for sure what I have is to cut me up for a post-mortem diagnosis that I will never hear.

Whatever you want to categorize me as doesn't help me escape that I am going to be dead in less than a decade, and unless some miracle happens with my health (i.e., the brain pacemaker I am trying to qualify for doing more than expected, tauopathy therapies advance as a result of Alzheimer's research, my female hormones do something my doctors and I can't predict), much of that time is going to be spent in pain and misery.

Someday all too soon, I'm going to lose my ability to type, then likely speak, and possibly even read. That scares the shit out of me as my biggest fear, maybe even more than my own mortality. This is what I am likely looking at for myself a few years from now, and that's just the muscular stuff. The fear of that alone is why I had "I will get on HRT to treat my CBS" as a Patreon goal and one which I jumped the gun on when inhalant steroids dropped my dopamine levels and I needed unconventional treatments to function before I could get booked for a more conventional medication change.

Remember, I wasn't expecting to be trans. While it is my fault that it signaled I was okay for setting myself up for a forced feminization like I knew the risks and secretly wanted to be trans, that is not the case (or at least not that I am cognizant of; my subconscious does heavy lifting but I don't need to reiterate how much people pushing me to be trans warped and broke me). This was a promise to explore the option, and at the time, I knew so little about HRT besides what misinformation I got, and I had no idea taking HRT would become a permanent decision. Had I known the latter, I likely would never have started to take it even with how desperate I was, and I in fact got off not because it stopped providing benefits like I said but because I was realized the madness of being a cis man taking HRT and worried people were going to push me to stay on it. Had I gotten the choice, I would very much rather have kept identifying as that cis male.

But I'm not a cis male (or at least, not anymore), and it's not because of how I very likely can't safely get off HRT (although even now I still worry this is not my trans arc but my desperate self-gaslighting arc), but because whatever is going on with my gender identity tells me this isn't so bad now and that I can accept myself as a trans woman. I can't state enough that I'm surprised this ended up being the case, but I'm here, I'm some type of queer, and I have to get used to it. My body and social identity are part of that package, but ones I keep trying to run away from even as I'm losing the ability to hide myself.


Let's start with the E-cups in the room (the E stands for "Elephant"):

This is the one and only proof call I am ever giving for my chest, but to explain how fucked it is for me to bind and how I am outed by it, this is a photo of my chest taken from my point of view when I'm lying on my back and my neck is craned at a 45° angle. There is a cat on my lap, but I can't really see her past my chest, and this is with a sports bra with just over 1/4" of padding inserts. Yes, it's that large, and it's even worse with all my underwire bras that I need for actual day-to-day support. If you want numbers for my bare chest removed from cup sizes, I have two domes on my chest that are each 7.5 inches (19 cm) in diameter and stick out 3 inches (8 cm).

So, can you finally understand why my chest has been such a concern for me, and why I had to out myself to my parents before I was ready? I simply can't hide them well. This is a monkey's paw wish that is more than I bargained for, and they're still growing.

Somehow forgetting my chest for now... my body has changed a lot, and it's continuing to change 11 months into HRT. I'm just under two inches shorter, my crotch isn't the same, my skin is smooth and very sensitive to heat and cold, I can't really grow thick body hair nor a thick beard, my bald spot is gone like it was never there, I have an androgynous face that feels closer to my mom's than my own and looking at in the mirror freaks me out (my condolences to Zach, even if his face was already quite feminine), my hips have thickened so much despite losing 45 lbs. that I don't fit into most of my male pants and my desk chair that was perfectly comfortable a year ago now feels weird because my butt pushes me out of the seat and my spine curves away from the back, and yes, I have huge fucking tits.

And go fuck yourself, past me...


So, like I said, Barry Bonds numbers. Even if I can't get off of HRT, my result with them are not far and away the craziest I've heard of from a transition (like how 2004 Barry Bonds was just as good with a baseball bat as he was without a baseball bat), but this is just my first season and I am competing with a trans woman who didn't know she was intersex and... wait, depending on how you look at it, my foray into HRT could be seen as me using performance-enhancing drugs...

Christ, I need to actually know my audience and stop using baseball references and puns. I keep making this joke to feel clever, but I don't feel clever when I have to explain who Barry Fucking Bonds is...


Look, I'll admit that sometimes my transition is wonderful. Sometimes I like having large breasts, I like feeling my thicker hips, I like noticing my larger ass, I like being able to look in the mirror and see a face that looks more and more feminine each week, and I like having a full head of hair. It feels right. I feel right, and I am excited about the future even if I am racing against the clock to be this woman I am becoming.

But at other times, it's at least uncomfortable and nerve-wracking, if not outright awful. I am ashamed of my chest size, upset for other trans women that the bimbo writer who usually doesn't like it being that busty wound up with that, my back hurts as its default state (to say nothing of how much my boobs hurt by default), I haven't gotten what I would call a full night's sleep without waking up in months, I have monthly nauseating pain that lasts for just under a week and I hate how helpless that makes me feel, my thinking is so scatterbrained nowadays (I want to think it's stress and the "ADHD symptoms worsen for a year on feminizing HRT" thing I heard and not the CBS), I'm embarrassed that so much of me that didn't change from HRT or my gender changing is recontextualized as being "cute" or "adorable" when coming from a woman, I laugh way too easily and even make random pterodactyl screech laughs at pictures of cute animals in a way that mortifies me, I have a harder time controlling my emotions and I cry at the drop of a hat, I'm more sadistic even if the light side of this is being more assertive, I get aroused so easily and it won't go away when I want it to, some bisexuality switch in me got flipped that feels frustrating and uncomfortable to explore, I feel so humiliated that I shrank 2 inches, and I'm... just not the same person I used to be, as wild and wonderful and weird and worrying as that is, and this is going to be the last big character arc of my life and I either need to live now or die wishing I had.


Ignoring my fear of my mortality and losing my ability to communicate for now, my third-biggest fear is what others see me as and not having control over that. Even after all of this, I think I am still desperate for approval and validation even if getting the attention to get it often makes me feel uncomfortable and embarrassed (being the extremely gifted child with so many expectations that I kept meeting up until the moment I didn't really messed me up). I selfishly want reality to follow all of my changing whims and contradictorily want the validation of being seen as a woman while not having any of the attention.

I am not going to present myself as a woman until at least a year from now (which is 2 years into HRT). I could do it right now, but I have some pretty bad social anxiety (and at least a little internalized transphobia), but you have to remember that I'm coming off the chaos part of a genderfluid arc. The two shifts I had in public filled me with so much confusion, discomfort, and dysphoria that one made me stumble and nearly trip and I am pretty certain I would have curled into a ball into a parking lot, and the other made me nearly crash my car in a Waffle House parking lot and I had to deal with the extreme discomfort of having a seatbelt over a bound chest.

All of this made me so hesitant to even go outside, and that was while presenting as male. I had work up the motivation to leave my house, and I had to time errands to safe periods a day or two after a shift where I likely wouldn't shift again since the periods of masculinity or femininity lasted for around a week each (with that time spent masculine slowly getting shorter and shorter for the 3 months before I realized it wasn't happening anymore unless I made my inner monologue scream the most internally transphobic and self-hating arguments and lies at me possible, like how the only reason I never truly put the effort into looking to get off HRT wasn't because I liked what was happening to me but because I desperately needed the medicine for my CBS). Presenting as female is going to be an entirely different ballgame, but I thankfully have two advantages: my chest and my voice.

The first was handed to me, but like I've said, a chest is a shortcut for passing, and I most certainly have one. To actually make that stand out (and for my own health) I need to lose a bit of weight (I jump between 195 and 200 lbs.), and I think getting down to 140 or so would really improve my body positivity issues and create a divide between what I look like now and how I used to look because right now I just look like a somewhat skinnier and more androgynous version of myself but with tits bolted on (unless I am binding). I want to say it's as simple as dieting and exercising, but I've often not got the healthiest meal options and my chest hurts so much that even walking at 4 MPH on a treadmill for 15 minutes causes them to hurt regardless of how good my sports bra is. I need to get back into the habit of leg lifts and squats and just commit to a stationary bike (because I need a low-impact cardio machine), but this house isn't the place to work out or be healthy.

The second boon is my voice, and I worked for this and actually feel proud of it. I pushed through initial dysphoria and feeling like I had an impossible mountain to climb (especially as my CBS robs me of my ability to more clearly articulate; I have a stutter I didn't have a decade ago) with smart practice such as recording myself in Audacity and getting a pass-through filter from my microphone DAC to my headphones so I can listen to myself as my microphone hears me with a push of a button. Being able to get that quick-to-instant feedback on my voice was instrumental in making rapid progress, and with inconsistent on-and-off practice for about a year, I sound... tomboyish. And yeah, I do sound a bit tomboyish, but you wanna know what? I can talk, and I can listen to my recording, and I can make myself blush. That is what I am looking for with a female voice. And yeah, I can make it sound a lot younger and more girlish, and I can also really make it sound very sultry and mature, but the most important thing is that I'm able to sound like the woman I want to be.

I generally put this in a more feminine lilt while trying to present as female around my parents, sister, or future brother-in-law (going from around 147 Hz or D3 to around 165 Hz or E3) and I even have one at around 175 Hz or F3. If you want yet another sample, here is me doing all three of these voices back to back to back. None but the last are what I would call "passing" but I just figured out resonance a few days ago (Jesus Fucking Christ there is so much conflicting information about what this even was; it's shoving the vibrations out of your throat and up, usually into your nose). It's a work in progress, but the important parts are to get honest feedback and to keep trying. Like the rest of my femininity, it's a work in progress.


Sure, a chest and a voice a woman does not make, but I am still in the process of finding out what that woman I want to be looks like (or at least the compromise since I can't be that woman from that dream). I've started to wear high-waisted women's jeans and plain women's T-shirts (usually V-necks; turns out breasts are heat radiators that need venting). I've started to collect references for the type of clothes I want to wear (like this). I've even gotten help purchasing the parts for an outfit or two, even if I've had to copy them like I copied my name, my sprites, and so much more.

Look, it's a good outfit, okay? And the leggings turned out to be surprisingly comfy, especially since I get cold so easily now...

Now if only I had the courage to copy Zoey's best outfit.


One thing I can't fully copy is the name. I just can't use Samantha. I love the name and would like to have the courage to use it someday, but I would go insane trying to match that character from the dream let alone the larger-than-life character I made Zach's mom because I have too many "memories" of being called Samantha when I can't be her. I am Sam, and Sam-I-Am, and for now, as I'm trying to figure out the finer details of who I am as a woman, that's okay.

Even with all of this help (especially the friends who are patient with me and respect my boundaries because the point is not presenting as what they want me to be but as myself), I think I am never going to be able to fully escape my fear of getting clocked or other social anxieties, especially when one of my more concrete social anxieties is my extended family.


My immediate family and my extended family are much like Atlanta in that it's a democratic pocket in the middle in a sea of conservatives, and I don't mean the "I want small government" kinds. Not even counting the weird conservatives the people I have a blood relation to married, my genetics are not far removed from a cousin who blames his dad's sudden heart attack (the one mentioned in this post) on the COVID-19 vaccine, a self-centered uber-Catholic German grandma who was so vitriolic to my sister after she came out as lesbian (and then bisexual) that my dad (her son) didn't speak to her for over two years, an uncle who works in conservative politics as a political organizer for fringe GOP candidates (I've checked the candidates he's worked with since 2016 and all of them have been transphobic crazies), and another uncle who is an evangelical Christian conspiracy theorist who just two days ago wore a Nazi coat with actual fucking swastikas on it to a lunch meetup with my dad (his brother), which is so outlandish even for him (and I say this knowing he wore a late 1940's "East German" coat to Valkyrie and got mad when my mom and I said it looked like a Nazi coat) that I wouldn't have believed it happened if had my dad not taken a photo of it.

I am related to this fucking person, and yes, he was smiling in this photo.


So, suffice it to say I am extremely worried about coming out to any of these people or having these people know who I am. I don't think those in my own generation are ultimately going to be an issue, but I am pretty sure me being trans kills my dad's contact with his immediate family as they'll blame his for being a failure of a father as to why I am a failure of a man, and as unfair as that is to him, I have to worry about myself.

My sister's wedding is in June. I don't know yet if I'm going to be out for that wedding, but I have made a promise to my sister that her wedding will not be co-opted by me to be my coming out as I am fully cognizant that date is about her and my soon-to-be brother-in-law (great guy, by the way; I'm happy my sister met someone as nice as him and my parents can have at least one son).

At the end of the day, I love my parents, partly out of obligation, partly because they did in fact make the personal sacrifice to raise me. I may joke about how nobody would consent to consciousness if it meant being trapped in a decaying meat computer, but even after all my suffering, I am thankful I was born because life is a precious and unique gift even if I almost threw it away several times last year and wished I could have more.

Now let's talk about why I don't like my parents and how desperate I am not to wind up like them. They might have given me life and raised me, but now I have to take that gift of life and live my life while I still can.


7. No Strings on Me

I'm not a part of your game / stop pouring fuel to my rage. / Don't think you're so hard to break. / Come close to me, come close to me. / I freed myself from this chain, / now watch me rise and reclaim / everything, I'm here to stay. / Come close to me, come close to me.

Operation Deepness is an Arknights song acting as the theme of Contingency Contract Deepness, but I also treat it as the theme of Skadi, another character who I am obsessed with and always assumed was a waifu but now realize is both that and an envy character.

But seriously, just look at her beach skin. That is capital-g Goals (to the point that I gave "my" sprites a white-haired variant to fulfill some part of my envy).


Her base form isn't great, and she's been outclassed by several operators since she's been there since launch. At her default, she's a weak unit with bad skill times and no niche, and she needs an extensive resource commitment, the best upgrade in the game, and dedicated squads built around her to shine.

Even then, despite having the highest ATK and HP stats of everyone in Arknights, she has paper-thin defense and is on the fragile side when taking hits. She's a short-lived but uniquely powerful attacker with fast redeploy, yet outside of this easily-replaced niche, she's an inferior alternative to better operators. But as anyone will tell you about gacha, they're a lot more fun when you play with your favorites (and cheaper).


I share similar traits to Skadi's mechanics. I'm a woman with a paper-thin defense who needs the best of conditions to shine, and even then, I've got an inferiority complex of being the high-investment alternative who doesn't perform as well. Despite all that, when I am in my zone and swinging, I can uniquely excel. I've seen it happen as a man, and I still want to try my hardest to see myself succeed as a woman, even if that means finding just the right environment and allies.

My house is not the right environment, and my parents are not the right allies, but let's treat this like I'm a boss slayer and target the higher-priority threat of my mom.


As I've detailed in the past (and you can see my Twitter (the one acceptable deadname) screenshots had a Skadi profile picture), my mom is capital-c Crazy. Zach's own mom is sort of her own unique beast as a blend of some of my most dramatic traits with some of the most dramatic traits of two of my relatives, but even her writer and number-one simp realizes that she's a toxic, manipulative, selfish, insane, controlling, anxious, immature, and just plain messed-up mother to the point that her having even the inkling of a redemption arc necessitates a bit of contrived writing.

Mrs. Samantha Taylor is a nicer (and sexier) reconceptualization of my mom's own brand of insanity, and just like Zoey, I am reluctant to admit I am my mom's daughter, bitterly disappointed that my own mom doesn't have someone like me around who can write her and my world with contrived writing to give her the inkling of a redemption arc I so desperately want her to have, and I'm an idiot for not seeing her as what she was until recently because I held out some vague hope that she would treat her younger daughter better than she treated her only son.

Like Zach's mom, my mom is a toxic, manipulative, selfish, (slightly) insane, controlling, anxious, and immature mother. I've covered in re:Dreamer's fourth anniversary release how my mom hasn't respected my boundaries, but since then, she's tried to out me to people (and successfully did so over Thanksgiving to her friend who was a person I barely knew), and just this month she nearly outed me to my entire family (thankfully, my Nazi uncle was the only attendee I would have been worried about).

I mentioned waaaay back at the start that my mom has been a menace about keeping my gender private, but recently for my sister's engagement party, she listed my attendee status on the invite as Sam LASTNAME and confirmed me right as she made the page, listing Sam LASTNAME right above the "Yes/No/Maybe" button on the engagement party RSVP you had to scroll down the page to see as well as the second name on the guest list which popped up right as you confirmed the invite.

Thankfully nothing came of that, but her latest "unintentional" gaffe of nearly outing me to every person on my sister's engagement party RSVP list and wedding invitation threw my anxiety level through the roof. Even if I now understand that the risk of getting outed was minimal, my OCD took control and I was deathly scared to go to the party in my own home lest someone comment on that name they saw even though I'd missed the Christmas Party from hormonal chest pain that prevented me from being able to bind and left me feeling disappointed in myself and others disappointed in me.

Before the party, my mom put a sheet of name stickers in from of my door with "DEADNAME LASTNAME", "Sam LASTNAME", and for some reason, "Little Bit" (my obese 20 lbs. cat). Not realizing that everyone was supposed to wear name tags, I tossed the sheet on my counter, showered (trying not to feel the discomfort of the beard I'd been growing for the last few days as a disguise, both from its presence and from how thin it was; my excuse to my relatives was that I had used too small of a trimmer guard and cut off too much), dried off and bound my chest (for note, you cannot have even slightly damp skin if you want to slip into a chest binder), dressed in what nicer male clothes I had that would still fit me (turns out that's a few dress shirts, a few long-sleeve shirts with buttoned collars, an oversized pair of dress khakis, and that's really it), tied up my shoulder-length hair into a ponytail (using some molding cream to hold my wispier parts down; my excuse to my relatives was that I was giving a "last hurrah" to my hair because as my grandpa's son I was destined to be balding in my thirties due to my genetics), put on cologne (fun fact: my cologne hits myself now), and went downstairs eager to treat this two-hour party as a sort of redemption arc to my missed attendance at the family Christmas party and on Christmas Day (that one was overlapping fake-PMS plus some cold that made both so much worse).

After saying hello to my sister and her fiancé as her brother, I soon realized that the very early attendees were wearing name tags. I felt a bit foolish and thought it'd look suspect if I didn't have one myself (I am cognizant that I am not the most recognizable compared to a year ago), so I wandered back upstairs to find that sticker sheet to proudly display my deadname.

What followed was 15 minutes of an anxious OCD meltdown as I desperately searched for those stickers. CBS fucks with my spatial memory in an awful way (I get lost 2 miles from my house now to say nothing of losing my phone and wallet), and I started to worry I hadn't put it on my nightstand but somewhere else. I desperately tore through my room, bathroom, and the guest bedroom across the hall from me I'd been sleeping in (I found out early into re:Dreamer's development I need at least a little separation from my workspace and my sleeping space or I go crazy, to say nothing of how stiff the mattress in my room that my parents randomly replaced one day is and how bad that is with my changing body). Remember, I was still in the trail end of the full part of my genderfluid arc at the time, and I had so many incoherent anxious thoughts that I wouldn't know who I was if I didn't have a name on me, like I was going to be a husk without a name without that nametag.

My memories are a slight blur for this (as they often are in this state; to this day I don't have clear memories of how I got from freaking out about my boobs in my bedroom to almost cutting them off in my bathroom), but I recall muttering to myself some variant of "need to find it" or "lost, hate this" as I searched. When I finally found that nametag sheet face-down on a white legal pad, I burst into tears as a small smile of relief appeared on my face, and it took me a few minutes to calm down and walk downstairs, pretending like nothing had happened and that I hadn't just missed a fifth of the party when most of the guests arrived.

Still, my sister either didn't notice my brief absence or didn't care, and she later put her arm on me and said, "glad you're here." I was too.


So even if nothing happened in that party and my mom has apologized for the RSVP error while telling me it was an accident (and I believe her, but the fact that I even have to question whether or not she is telling the truth based on how she's not respected my boundaries and tried to out me scares the hell out of me), she blamed me for being hurt by her (I sent a terse reply to her email saying she'd changed my name on the RSVP list with "I'm genuinely sick of being hurt by you. I can’t trust you and I regret coming out to you"), she threw a number of petulant temper tantrums like she was a teenage girl because I tried to get her to respect my privacy boundaries, and made me feel unsafe in the house I was raised in.

I didn't write this one down after it happened like I often do (it turns out writing is incredibly therapeutic for me!) so I'll be relying on my after-the-fact memory, but one day, when I was leaving to pick my sister up from her work that was a 45-minute drive away (she had a bit where she couldn't drive due to a health issue), I asked my mom to pick up my prescription of montelukast for me since it was on the last day of holding. My mom said she wouldn't get it and that I would have plenty of time to get to the pharmacy before it closed at 7 PM.

I got slammed by traffic and was 20 minutes late getting my sister, so I called my mom and asked her to get my prescriptions (saying it'd be only $15 or so but that I'd pay her back), and she again told me not to worry despite the way back having traffic too.

I dropped my sister off at her wedding venue with my future brother-in-law (they were taste-testing the various catering offerings that night), and I stopped to get a bite of food at Firehouse Subs (basically a moderately-better Subway) when an absolute gully washer of a thunderstorm swept in and kept me inside because the road conditions were that unsafe. The storm soon passed, but I was anxious about getting my medication as I was now going to be racing the wire getting to the pharmacy before it closed so I left my mom a voicemail asking her to please get it because my house was 5 minutes away and I was 20.

I didn't get a response but proceeded on the assumption that she hadn't left to get the pills, and I got a text 14 minutes before closing.

She had left, but she was telling me something about getting a 90-day supply. I was driving so couldn't respond much, but she had made it clear she was at the pharmacy. I sent a short text asking her not to get me 90 days and drove home.

Once home 8 minutes later, I called her and asked what the situation was. She said she was waiting for the pharmacist to fill me 90 days, but I tried to explain to her that I didn't need 90 days and in fact that this was a medication I was trying to get off of because it was likely really bad for me, and this 30-day supply was a stopgap before I had another pulmonologist appointment to get a replacement, but she interrupted me by saying, "it's cheaper and I'm paying for it!" before she hung up on me.

Yeah, this is a fucking six out of six for the very bad side effects listed on Drugs.com. I am pissed I didn't notice this until about a month ago, and I'm usually very good with checking drug interactions and side effects but had been told by my first pulmonologist that this was the go-to asthma drug and that it was safe.


My mom came inside and slammed the door and threw the pharmacy paper bag of pills on the counter, telling me to say, "thank you." I told her she hadn't told me she was leaving to get this, but then I tried to tell her that the 90-day supply was too much and that this was something I wanted to get off of when she interrupted me again to say that it was cheaper, she was paying for it, and she would take the rest herself if I didn't want them, and that if I didn't like it she would pour the pills over the wet driveway.

I'm an angry person by default and respond badly to stress, but I was cool as a cucumber for this and eerily relaxed and mature to contrast her eerie lack of calmness and maturity. I told her to she really needs to respect my boundaries and try to pay a bit more attention to what I have asked her to do and not substitute her judgment for mine when it came to my physical or mental health, but she laid into me and told me I was being an "rude brat" for not being glad she had gotten the pills and that I was making a big deal over nothing like I had made a big deal over nothing with the RSVP name.

"You say I'm transphobic, DEADNAME, and you cower behind that to justify being rude to me!" (she was calling me DEADNAME and he/him for all of this). I pointed out that she was calling me DEADNAME right then and there with, "I can't write a line that good." Neither parent knows what I do for my job, but she scoffed and said, "Sorry, Sam, but you can't blame me for this when you changed what you wanted to be called and my friends treat me like I'm crazy when I call you Sam!"

This was either a worrying admission that she slipped up on the "call me DEADNAME and He/Him to everyone I am not out with" by accident or had ignored it on purpose, but she ran off to the other room as I said, "Mom, you have a Juris Doctor. You are very smart. You can figure this out."

She went to the couch and started to watch some French detective drama as I walked over to her and tried to have a conversation with her like we were both adults. "I know this is difficult for you. I don't want to be like this either, but I am asking for some patience to try and figure myself out."

"Oh, you say that, but you never act nice to me and do the dishes! Who needs months to find out who they are?!"

I tried to go into the briefest of a summary of the identity issues, but she kept interrupting and saying stuff like, "You're not holding up your end of the bargain (in regards to your rent being chores + rent)" and "I say politely say 'Good Morning!' to you every morning and only get a 'HIUH' back!" I tried to explain that due to my health issues (fake-PMS and CBS in particular) I often had difficulty bending over and reaching down or up to do dishes and had offered to do other chores as replacement that she never got back to me about, and that due to my CBS I am often very groggy and borderline incoherent some mornings as I wait for my medications to kick in, but she just turned the volume up. I'm not sure that did anything for a show with subtitles besides drown me out.

I felt bad. I hadn't really been holding up my end of the bargain with her, and I tried to apologize and reiterate that I was really struggling most days and begging for some patience and understanding, but she said, "Bye, go away now!" as she laid there on the couch, clearly not wanting to understand or be patient.


There have been tons of other moments like this that I have typed shortly after, like when I bailed on my mom's Christmas gift of helping her spread mulch:

And her replacing my hand-stitched name on my Christmas stocking done by my deceased grandmother:

I have months and months and months of miniature tragedies and horror stories like this I could share, some starring my dad, but most my mom (I'm cutting him some slack as we still do get along okay and he's stood up for me against my mom more than once). But I don't need to, as the takeaway would be the same: as long as I live in the same house as my parents, I not only won't have a safe environment to find myself as a woman but a safe environment period.


So, that's why I'm finally moving out to find myself. It's half a year (or years) late, but whoever I am becoming can't exist in this type of environment, and the date is "by the end of March" (and don't worry, the update will be out before I move).

I thought about proudly showing off the apartments I have toured and talking about how excited I am to be living on my own even if it will be challenging, but I shouldn't be leaving dox with addresses. I thought about boldly sharing those addresses, but I not only haven't made a decision yet and would be inviting random apartments for possible harassment, I need to practice what I preach and maybe not be a foolhardy idiot who advertises where a trans woman lives by herself. I thought about just saying what I could do with the potential of the 700-sq ft or so potential living spaces (a small open office and couch in what is basically a studio with a queen bed; a bungalow townhome with a sleeping space on the top floor and a workspace on the bottom floor; a living room office with recessed windows overlooking a gray courtyard with a small bedroom), but you all will have to wait and see.

Even living modestly, moving out is going to be costly (especially after I spent $1,200 a month on therapy for several months in a row which drained some savings), but I can renegotiate with my producer my cut from the Patreon payouts to have more income since the art budget is growing faster than it's being spent.

I won't ask anyone reading this for money like I did last time because I now know that looked performative and manipulative, but I will ask for patience. A move out from under my parents' thumb and out of my childhood house is going to be a transition period all of its own, and while I think this would be an improvement for my mental health, this is going to affect my work-life balance until I get used to a new flow of things for the first time since dropping out of college 8 years ago. Please be patient as I figure things out if my output drops during this move and shortly after. I'm committed to this project for life, and the only thing that would ever stop it would be forces outside of my control.


And to those women trying to legally threaten me into silence with empty threats because I won't "stop this vindictive cycle of hatred" like you claimed to my best friend (right after attempting to puff your chest with a threat of seeing me in court for talking about how you've hurt me over and over and over again)... please don't. Don't even attempt to report this post like you told my producer you would even though I've checked with support and I am not stepping out of line as there is no identifiable information. We had at least a dozen chances to reconcile, yet you have spurned me at every last one because I could never be what you wanted me to be, which was either a woman just as mean and spiteful as you are or a puppet dancing on your strings as you went around hurting people.

If we can't have reconciliations, we can have souls, because I only have an incomplete product to leave a legacy and showcase my skills, I have no real hireable skills for a resume, I have declining health that means I won't be able to work a more traditional job with anything close to consistent hours, I might not be able to drive before long, and so on and so on and so on. Beyond the needs of creative fulfillment and purpose that re:Dreamer has given me, this is my job, and it might not just be a job that only I can do but likely the only job I can do before long. If this project dies from your hand, I will inevitably die. I will be a corpse in the ground, but my soul will not rest, and it will blame my death on you. Have patience. You will all outlive me, and you can gloat over my grave when I am gone and nobody can stop you, but don't rush me there like you rushed me into being a woman.


I wish I could finish this long, sweeping coming out post with a more positive and optimistic note, but in my desire to make this announcement line up with the 1-year anniversary of me realizing I wasn't cis, it's also lined up with my monthly hormonal cycle. Or at least I'd like to say it's monthly, but my last one started two and a half weeks ago. It's abnormal how inconsistent and strong this is, let alone that I even get this as a trans woman, especially when I am only on 4 mg/day of estradiol, 50 mg/day of bicalutamide, and 0.5 mg/day of dutasteride. Something wrong is happening, because this shouldn't cripple me so much that I nearly crashed my car while driving home from touring an apartment from a hot flash with intense back, boob, and groin pain. I don't have an explanation for why I have something more closely equating to the similar yet split symptoms of a cis woman's PMS and ovulation (i.e., I have none of the signs to point to me being intersex), but I have to deal with this handicap the best I can and not feel like this useless pain is a cruel reminder that an aspect to womanhood I care a lot about is denied to me by my biology.

As I write this, I'm doped up on coffee, Adderall (my pharmacy is out of generic Vyvanse and the name brand costs $370 a month), Midol, Aleve, and my new viral asthma medication (AirDuo RespiClick®, which has the possible side effect of worsening existing hormonal issues but it's better than the montelukast medication and I can actually feel my skin again). Despite all those medications, I have to fight against lethargic tiredness telling me to get back to bed despite getting 9 hours of sleep (whether or not this counts as beneficial sleep is up for debate), I feel weak and fatigued, I have near-debilitating arousal, and I've got a whole slew of symptoms like:

  • Nausea (I actually threw up from this fake-PMS for the first time last night; that might be tied to the AirDuo but I just started it yesterday so I'll wait and see).

  • Dizziness (the entire room spins sometimes and if I close my eyes the entire world spins).

  • Chest swelling (I think this is water-weight gain? Either way, I have to use larger bras when I'm like this).

  • Chest sensitivity (I have to use thickly-padded bras when I'm like this).

  • Chest pain (see the last point).

  • Back pain (I have a lumbar support pillow that somewhat helps but I really just need a new chair since my ass got so much thicker that I don't quite fit into it anymore).

  • Hip pain (more on the side than anything else).

  • Lower stomach pain (hi reproductive organs that aren't there!).

  • Cramping.

  • Muscle aches.

  • Bloating.

  • Gastrointestinal issues.

  • Bladder urgency (I think my record is 5 restroom trips in 3 hours).

  • Strong appetite cravings (currently, shrimp even though I don't particularly like them, but now I'm salivating over the thought of them for some reason).

  • Random chills and hot flashes.

I somehow get all of this, yet at least I don't get headaches... but that's not to say my head is clear. Beyond the uncomfortably strong arousal over nothing, my emotions are all over the place. I'm moody, irritable, sad, depressed, angry, giddy, and yes, even airheaded. My mind keeps wandering, and my OCD/ADHD brain keeps thinking about how I got to this moment in the first place and what I felt during the moment of no return last year at 10:39 PM when I said "I think I'm trans."


If you're ever gotten truly shocking and unexpected news, it's different than what you think, or at least it was for me. Being stunned and left with a wide-eyed expression was the first part. My conscious mind didn't even understand what had just been uncovered at first, but my subconscious mind did, and it knew it was bad. Then it clicked, and a nervous smile appeared on my face to replace the color that had drained from it. I'd seen the hardships of trans women around me for years now. I'd watched some struggle, toil, and work so hard only to feel like it was never enough, I'd watched some get consumed with dysphoria, and I'd seen many wrestle with the frightening prospect that they weren't who they thought they were. This struggle is something I wouldn't wish on my worst enemies, yet that was going to be me now.

My heart started to beat faster. There was slight hyperventilation and a cold sweat all over my skin that left this prickly feeling as my face flushed. There was giddiness, yet I started to shake so much that my teeth briefly chattered, and it wasn't from the cold or the corticobasal syndrome that I now knew I had. I'd always been uncomfortable with truly exploring my own gender, but this wake-up call to that was more like the freezing air whipping past me as Humpty Dumpty fell down his wall and started skydiving down toward terra incognita.

I shoved that panic attack into a box, put a big smile on my face, and responded with an unfittingly cheery mood with snarky jokes to hide how scared I was.

I'd realized when talking to (W) in a heated argument, which I briefly covered here.

This was the night I got the second-worst news of my life, and it bears shocking surface-level resemblances to the day I got the worst news of my life.


But I'm not Humpty Dumpty, I'm not Moby Dick, and I'm not Pinocchio. I might not be a real boy, I might not be a real girl, but I am me. I am Sam, Sam-I-Am. I'm not a puppet, and I don't subscribe to the notion that most trans women have for themselves that this was who I always was and was always meant to be, but for all my imperfections and my inability to be a perfect being or even be who I used to be, that man full of S-I-N, this is me now. I'm not perfect, and I never will be, and that's okay.

At least there are no strings on me.


Y'all are probably tired of me rambling about myself, and I've still got some thinking to do about who I am before I can say more so I'm going to be quieter about my own journey than I have been in the past few months as I move forward. I might briefly post about me moving into a new place or what coming out for a social transition might look like, but I didn't want to fall ass-backward into a rabbit hole of my own identity. I just wanted to write a porn game, so that's what I'm going to focus on again.

In fact, I never stopped focusing on it, and you can read about what I've been doing for it here. 

Comments

Kasumin

Thanks for the update, Cap and to me it's fine if you take your time to move out. As I said already on Discord before, I hope you can find your peace or at least a semblance thereof. Even if this post reads a good bit more stable than earlier stuff in the last year, a safe environment is important and I wish you all the best.

Kasumin

Also, I think you shouldn't think your writing destroys people. If people have self-discoveries through R:D, because they feel it resonates, it's not like you forcefully cracked them and dragged them out into the kind of limbo you seemed to live in. So I hope you can try not to think too negatively about your own work. And yes, I didn't figure out that enter posts my writing instead of making a line break.

Maylee

Hay you do what right for you and as a fan i will be here to suport if i can love your work. All i want is people to he happy ill leave it at that

BadCass

So, I cannot relate to a lot of this as I went pretty fast down the gender pipeline myself. What I can relate to though is bad parents. We are not beholden to them, as much as a part of us almost has to love them for some reason, that inkling within that will always love them in some small unfortunate way, we never have to be ok with what they've done to us. Love and Loathing can exist equidistant to one another. Do not forget, do not forgive, but remember that the best vengeance is to live well. Be joyous and let the people who have hurt you know that they have no right to partake in that joy. Show them your brightest smile and let them burn in it.