Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

We take a look at one of the upcoming defense witnesses for Ghislaine Maxwell: Dr. Elizabeth Loftus, including her ties to the False Memory Syndrome Foundation, the case of Jennifer Freyd, MKUltra, and what it all has to do with Ted Bundy. 

Files

Comments

jay

get silly

James

Memory, money and... massages?!

TchankaSidecar

your dedication to bringing content to us (morons) is so fucking beautiful

Tim Bednar

Thanks for doing this! you guys are machines

Em Zora

Shit that was a good one James.

Em Zora

I'm already excited to listen because I have a passionate disgust for these false memory/"recovered memory" scumbags.

Justin Hubbard

Woah, the most recent QAA was also about the False Memory people/Satanic Panic

Francisco

What a description, All Hail TrueAnon

BruceInAdelaide

science shows us that memory is very "flexible", but the chances of any working class or poor person being able to afford an expert witness of this calibre are zero. Best wishes to all three of you, You are good partisans of working people!

Harry P. Ness

Liz Loftus my favourite Behind the Bastards guest

Litano

It's tough, because there's a grain of truth to the idea that we can all develop false memories. Like, studies have shown that researchers can reliably conduct an interview in which they get study participants to recall pre-selected events in their lives that did not happen. But obviously that real phenomenon gets seized upon by some of the worst people out there to deny testimonials of their crimes

Litano

Oh, you talk about one of these studies later in the ep, ignore me. Trying to get someone to remember a rape that never happened is obviously not a study that any review board would let you carry out, since a success would profoundly harm the patient's mental health. But psychologists have been able to convince people of more serious things than "lost in a mall," and we've seen people who were convinced that they committed certain crimes during police interrogation later proven innocent. IDK what to make of it all

TrueAnon Podcast

Yeah it’s true but false confessions—as Loftus herself pointed out in a couple of interviews I listened to—are different in type than false memories. I agree that it’s possible to implant false memories but yeah I think the water is really muddy around this stuff.

Char Kelly

I love how the ghislaine trials are making Liz sing so much more

BIG VIBES

finally a musical theater episode

Graham Hoese

Got my Bush did 9/11 hat last week, now my wife thinks I'm a conspiracy nut. She'll come around to the truth one of these days. It probably doesn't help that when she asks me to explain I just start yelling about black boxes and passports.

j

Man that NPR riff…

BIG VIBES

the youngest boomers in the game

Maximum Ben

I don't wanna be that guy but this episode was straight up science-denialism. The Epstein/Maxwell case doesn't rely on repressed memories or 'Psychogenic amnesia' and it's a sleazy trick to bring in a shrink to muddy the waters by comparing the memories of these women to those phenomena. The idea that traumatic events are repressed is pseudoscience, and the women in this trial, as far as I know, never claimed to have forgotten about their experiences only to have them unearthed years later. To the contrary, these women have carried these memories consciously their entire lives and it has shaped them. The least they could do in this ep is bring up the satanic panic and the fact that there's never been any solid proof of 'new memories', that psychologists have unearthed in their patients through therapy, weren't implanted through suggestion. There's plenty of proof beyond one study about being lost in a mall, that memories can be implanted. There were 12,000 accusations made during the satanic panic and zero were authenticated, that wasn't 12,000 liars, it was psychologists who went looking for memories that weren't there and eventually the patients started to believe that what they were being asked about was real. Brace saying "there's a big difference between being lost in the mall and being raped" is disengeuopuis, there's no way that in doing research for this episode he didn't come across plenty of cases where people did have false memoried implanted of serious traumatic events. I think the greatest strike against the repressed memory theory is that therapy is usually the opposite. It would be convenient if traumatic events were simply forgotten for our own good but survivors of abuse, wars and violence typically have the opposite problem, that they can't forget their most traumatic memories. Seriously shitty work on this one.

Timothy Massar

Really fucking great episode 👏 👌

Timothy Massar

Repressed memory is in no way "pseudo science ". It's cognitive and behavioral science. Pseudo science is the whole racial bullshit that uses skill measurements to prove intellectual capability, etc... its not chemistry or physics and provable with mathematical formuals, but its not on the same level of what would be considered pseudo science

Maximum Ben

There's a difference between a soft science and pseudo science. There have been thousands of cases of psychics being used in police investigations. The evidence that psychics have provided real value beyond educated guess work is as strong as the evidence to support repressed memory therapy unlocking traumatic events repressed by patients.

Andrew May

The newscaster voice Brace is talking about is called the Transatlantic accent and is seen as the combination of the prestigious* aspects of American and British English

TrueAnon Podcast

We are absolutely not saying the girls have repressed memories and nowhere in the episode did we imply that whatsoever, nobody has ever claimed to have repressed memories—the defense is trying to make it seem like the victims have contaminated memories, not repressed ones later found by a therapist. I mention, too, that there are lots of other studies that have been done that got similar results in the 25-30% range of implanting memories; the only reason that I brought up that study in the first place is the woman who is being called by the defense as an expert witness is the author of that study and had brought it up at the Weinstein trial.

Ethan Hunt

[EDIT: Tbc this is a response to Maximum Ben's comment, not TrueAnon's.] I believe that there were really cases of planted false memories during the 1980s satanic panic. However... Abuse carried out by a caretaker has been found to be positively associated with less persistent memories of abuse. [1] The brain has been found to automatically retrieve unwanted memories at a lower rate, leading to reductions in recallability. [2] Forgetting or misremembering are thought to be adaptive, and there is a wide academic literature on this. [3] There are documented victims of confirmed sexual abuse who repressed these memories and only recalled them later. [4] Here are a further 110 corroborated cases of this. [5] This episode embodied the skeptical spirit of good science far better than your comment, which blindly took the side of what you consider the more authoritative position. Siding with authority is the death of science, shattering crappy authority is the whole point. In the "memory wars", both sides had a point, but one side (the false memory researchers) was invested with false authority. In my view, this is likely because intelligence agencies had an incentive to use such research to discredit victims of well-connected child traffickers like Epstein. It's interesting to note that in the Franklin sex abuse ring documentary "Conspiracy of Silence" [6], the ones pushing the satanic panic angle are Paul Bonacci (the least reliable witness, possibly a victim but went on to be a child molester himself), John DeCamp (Republican politician, former aide for the CIA), and William Colby (former CIA Director, former boss of DeCamp). From what I recall, the other victims just describe a child sex abuse ring with eerie similarities to the Epstein case. It could be that the satanic panic stuff was planted to discredit victims as well. Could also be that there were actual satanic front groups for intelligence agencies doing this stuff. To get to the bottom of it, you'd have to read both sides, both the Loftus types and the Dave McGowan types [7] who fully accept the satanic panic accusations, and I don't believe that either you or I have done that homework yet. 1. https://dynamic.uoregon.edu/jjf/articles/fdz.pdf 2. https://doi.apa.org/fulltext/2018-34715-001.html 3. https://dynamic.uoregon.edu/jjf/articles/bttnebraska2012.pdf 4. https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/jts.2490080408 5. https://blogs.brown.edu/recoveredmemory/case-archive/ 6. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qsHs3eOL0mM 7. https://www.goodreads.com/en/book/show/919537.Programmed_to_Kill

Camille Shultz

Hot Damn! I called it! I KNEW that Jolly West would pop up in association with this foundation. Dude, that guy had his hands on everything! I would love to see his files.

Graham Gourley

Malcolm Gladwell cites Loftus, calling her one of the most “respected experts on memory in the world”, in his quasi-defence of Sandusky from one of his recent books

malpertuis

I'll admit I want Liz to sing a lil Christmas stuff.

Elsie Hupp

IIRC the Transatlantic accent is basically the American version of British Received Pronunciation. However, neither accent is necessarily associated with poshness; both of the accents are now-old-fogey fashionable bourgeois affectations that could almost be seen as a way of obscuring the line between the true gentry and the nouveau-riche. In this way one could almost call Received Pronunciation ideologically American: it indirectly promotes the fictional idea of a non-hereditary elite.

TrueAnon Podcast

Fwiw the reason we bring up Jolly West and the airman murder case he was involved with was because he claimed he air man had a “repressed memory” of his cousin molesting him that came up and drove him insane (a claim made to West apparently when the airman was under the influence of sodium Pentothal injections West had given him)—and then joins the board of the FMSF

Elsie Hupp

FWIW it’s my understanding that the more common “media accent” in the US is from the suburban lower Midwest (and, by migration, Southern California, which received a massive influx of “Okies” during the Great Depression), and that the Transatlantic accent has generally remained more of a weird New England thing. Even to this day if you listen to NPR News, though, everything is in this bizarre, placeless “NPR accent” that is neither Lower Midwest (or Southern California) or the Transatlantic accent.

Elsie Hupp

Another interesting thing: my mother progressively lost her hearing while I was growing up, so in order for her to be able to understand me, I developed extremely strong enunciation (ie a louder amplitude for softer, higher-frequency consonants like “f” or “t”). While I gradually softened my enunciation as I progressed into adulthood, to this day I’ve sort of gotten used to the fact that most people are hard to understand, so I used closed captioning whenever possible, and I’ve completely given up on song lyrics.

Elsie Hupp

Another way of describing the difference is that “posh” British English is what you get with an insular, inbred social group like the English aristocracy, while Received Pronunciation is what you get in a society with active public discourse, especially on the radio and other auditory media.

Elsie Hupp

Part of the gist of the video (which I’m still watching) is that RP is “international British English”, so in a sense one could call it “Commonwealth English” or (less charitably) “Imperial English”.

Elsie Hupp

FYI the funny part of the video starts around the 20-minute mark. “The Bentley broke down on the way to the Opera, so I had to take the Underground with the Oiks. Never again!” (…and so on)

hannah

Question to real heads: Which Anthrax or Slayer songs are particularly about the "MALL EFFECT"

hannah

Loftus's mommy "Just Drowned One Day" would love to know that story!!!!! So weeeird

Elsie Hupp

“Academics should be tagged and bagged” “I mean tagged and monitored” You mean like how biologists put GPS trackers on wolves, migratory birds, and feral cats?

Maximum Ben

I appreciate the reply I didn't mean to imply that there were suggestions that the victims had repressed memories. Third paragraph should have started "but, the idea that..." I was trying to point out that there's no reason to defend repressed memories, and that bringing in this psychologist to testify and talk about the topic is indeed a dirty trick, but it's a shit move because it equates the bullshit of psychogenic amnesia with the easily substantiated memories that these women have. Whatever the reason you brought up the 'lost in the mall' study, bringing it up in isolation and downplaying how robust the research around implanting memories has been (even memories of abuse/rape/molestation) and then talking about cortisol and completely misrepresenting how memory consolidation works is just dishonest. I don't think you guys came into this without doing plenty of research. Traumatic memories are consolidated because they are frequently revisited by the victim, not in spite of it. I stand by my points, presenting a largely disproven pseudo-science with total credulity was unnecessary. Also 25-30% is plenty enough when you only hear of people who believe they had repressed memories, a psychologist looking for repressed memories and finding that a quarter or more of their patients didn't know they were abused as a child would seem like a lot. Anyway, sorry if my comment was ambiguous, didn't mean to imply that you guys have done anything to disparage the victims of this case. I took issue with the take on repressed memories, not victims.

Jon

The only Concorde that ever crashed was actually taken out by a piece of tyre on the runway which had fallen off another plane. It was an insane feat of engineering but an absolute disaster economically for British Airways and Air France.

Jessica S

So basically this organization, the FMLSAFLA or whatever, is saying “trust us, we are experts at false memories” but they leave out the quiet part “because we have successfully created quite a few.” If I remember correctly, I think someone had to tell that psycho to stop bragging about the elephant b/c it creeped out normal people. And I’m sorry, but marrying your step sibling is at least half of a red flag…definitely a yellow. The only way I could fathom it not being weird is if they had no clue the relation until after they were married, Parent Trap style. Otherwise, I’m working off the premise that they’re concept of permissive familial boundaries is a little sus.

Louie Van Patten

Ladies and gentleman, The Roadhouse is proud to welcome... Liz and The Gourmands.

Shiv

@Elsie thx for the RP digression which I am also very much here for

Shiv

most of what I learned about “recovered memories” and the discourse/debünking thereof was from living thru Satanic Panic and from boning up on ufo abduction; but wait there’s p*do parents and presidential assassins and evil witnesses for hire in this mix too?! a real stew

Colin Clark

They always said they had to retire the Concorde after the one crash because it was just too old, they didn't know what might happen, but as the 737 max demonstrated, you can survive killing a few plane loads of NGO officials and government bureaucrats. The liability calculation was way different with condorde passengers. Also the Concorde while it lost money was absolutely central to building the credibility of Airbus back when Boeing was an icon of organizational excellence (lol)

carl

what what about mammaries--now im interested

Øystein Monsen

Maximum Ben the discussion over repressed memories is afaik a major controversy in clinical psychology and by no means a settled issue. Dissociative amnesia was at least a defined and generally accepted clinical term last I checked. This is touching on a whole weird philosophical-ideological debate and all ends with people wanting to fuck/kill their parents, but it's by no means an outrageous position to take, especially for a layperson.

Pear Is A Patsy

I don’t understand how you can be an expert witness on SOMEONE ELSE’S memories? Like I get the defense’s whole job is to gaslight the witnesses and jury but this Dr. isn’t the witness’ psychologist, how can she have any insight to THEIR memories?

Lesley Anne Noelle

~the prosecution had better get its own neurological and psychological expert-expert witnesses. (((🤬))) psychology is so👉🏾broken, that they should attack everything one of those Satanic Panic bullshitters, brought to you by paid psychologists, TORTURE, brought to you by paid psychologists.

orc

Speaking of The Cut, The Intelligencer has a roundtable of "Jeff Epstein Experts" that doesn't include you guys 😒

SF

Whenever I read anything about a guy like Jolly West my mind immediately goes to Dr Pointsman from Gravity’s Rainbow…

Jones Kolbinsky

Liz singing makes me feel something again

Ian H

It's covered pretty extensively in the New Yorker piece they mention. Tellingly, Loftus insists to this day that her chronically depressed, recently institutionalized mother couldn't possibly have killed herself. She also denounces her cousin's memory of the drowning as false, and tainted by that side of the family's dislike for her father. Real physician heal thyself shit.

Ascetic Blur

Moron here. Thanks for the episode.

Brendan Garcia

Anyone who is an “expert witness in a number of high profile cases” is immediately sus.

BTULTRA

Omg Liz, DROP THE ALBUM

gearbox

God I miss the old morning edition music

Bingo Bongo

almost lost it when you started talking about harvard experiments!! this is my jam

Bingo Bongo

and jolly west!!!! oh boy did this get interesting

Lesley Anne Noelle

If you need ‘extra credit’ for a psychology class…you probably shouldn’t be in college. Still, ‘The Prisoners and the Guards’ clearly went far too far…and whilst they made a documentary about it, I watched the (actual footage) on utube.

Lesley Anne Noelle

Lost in a Mall…if done correctly, everyone who was taken as a toddler to the mall, whilst their parent shopped, a percentage of those people, probably older people, may have not been able to see their Mother in a sea of people. Now how many had a moment of heart clutching fear, that’s at LEAST something to manipulate. I remember wandering around the fucking linens/drapes department bored out of my skull, at age three, and my Mother would get irritated. (She was-some people shouldn’t have children)…but i NEV-ER had a fearful moment at a mall. 25%—how many parents reported being worried, how many people: just concurred to👉🏾end the idiocy of the study?

Lesley Anne Noelle

Sorry for so many comments, but was assisting a professor with her tenure, and what we did to those children was introduce them to a state of anxiety that they—it was wrong. She tested them with the Stanford Binet (great for little girls-as a CHILD i was 7, i was thinking, why would a poor black boy know wtf a ‘cameo’ is. It’s the ugliest piece of jewelry that nobody black would ever own. But I QUIT because she kept LYING to me, saying, ‘there’s no right or wrong answer’…part 1

Lesley Anne Noelle

Then she had us sit down with students, little kids, 6,7,8…and show them Newspaper comics. Then, we were to ask (((((real head gaming)))))👉🏾Why is it funny …? Do you know how many children can explain why a comic is funny …? Comfortably…? zErO. 🤦🏻‍♀️ it was utterly cruel and public schools were NOT participating. imagine being asked to break down Peanuts or whatever. CRUELTY.

swervegriffin

In the Elliott Smith ep, you talked abt how he remembered years later that his step dad abused him, though his family denied it and said it was a false memory. I think in the ep you said it wasn’t conclusive but something definitely messed him up as a child.

ClownBabee24

Does anyone have any good reading on MKULTRA and projects like it?

HATERSLAYER420

have you read Chaos, the book they quote from here? it isn't exclusively about MKUltra but it's completely intertwined

Kira

Poisoner in chief

B R

the feminine urge to start singing “memory” and be unable to stop

pulled a muscle yearning

Fascinating as always, there's a fun crank angle to this. Have you guys checked out any UFO shit and abduction stories? There was a guy basically searching for abduction stories, doing hypnotic regression and shit. Now most of those stories are chalked up to false memories, but with this ep, hey what's up with that? A trueanon ufo ep would be tons of fun

Dugan

My little scientist heart broke when Liz said she didn't like scientists 😥 Please reconsider, Liz. Some of us are v nice and don't study sketchy shit.

Ian H

MKUltra angle too: tinyurl.com/y7jzmwvn

Leguminous Goth

Strongly recommend reading "the controllers" if you haven't yet. MKUltra stuff that pairs pretty well with the TrueAnon take on RFK

Svid

Luv when Liz serenades me

uleg0

wasnt the methodology on that “getting lost in the mall”-study like absolute dogshit too? Like it basically shoudnt be considered scientific at all?

Michael

No one with a brain actually believes in satanic ritual abuse right? The satanic shit is a distraction, the pedophiles running the world aren't satanists, they're catholic and protestant lmao which is why you should NEVER trust a Catholic or a protestant 👀

Molly L.

Flip the script!!!!!

Fiddypea

Has this defence ever worked in court? It seems so ridiculous, outside of academic psychology factoids. I guess it must do if there are enough creeps willing to shell out $700 an hour for it.

Tan Tan

so it's like becoming a professional gasslighter. i think i know some people who would be good at that.

jay

BRACE did you go to drama camp in maine and then farm camp in vermont? 👀

a clash of purple

This doesn't make up for five days of failing to provide daily coverage of events in the courtroom.

Mateo Ortiz Ambrosio

that false memory at the mall study was part of a question on my MCAT lol

joan

Remember, too, the Boy Scouts hid their pedos for decades.

joan

Yes, my little scientist heart broke, too. Most scientists and researchers are unassuming people trying to study nature. Hyper-sensationalism and over-generalization of cherry picked studies is misleading- it breeds mistrust and corruption. The key questions re: Loftis' memory study are: 1. Was it replicated? And 2. As Brace indicated, can her results be generalized to sexual abuse given the fact that trauma has significant effects on recall? BTW, this was a fascinating episode. Thanks. I am old (I know can't help it) and I lived through the hysteria surrounding the McMartin preschool. The Christian right & the Reagan administration hated the idea of childcare- in particular Head Start, that provided infant & toddler care to low income families. Anything that could potentially liberate women was discredited by Republicans and the Christian Right. Mix in the ginned up satanic cult hysteria and it became a perfect storm for false accusations against any entity that the right wingnuts deemed evil. They're using the same playbook today with their anti-mask & vaccine crusades. Let's face it, Evangelical Christianity is an apocalyptic death cult.

bugsick

yeah wtf I just look at fish

bugsick

yo can anyone tell me the MKUltra writer recommended in this episode? Not Tom O'Neill or McGowan, someone else

Ian H

Just read it on your recommendation, great read thanks.

The Cheerful Comrade

Om gosh Liz, your voice is amazing when singing! Would love to hear your record that song for real, you sound great!

Patrick

Yeah I’m not Oooh