Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

We examine two parallel cases of public mythmaking: Victor Marx and Jason Arday. We trace their wild stories, fabulism allegations, and the institutions that helped turn their personal mythology into public authority.

Hit the tip line: (646) 801-1129 | [email protected]

Discover more episodes at podcast.trueanon.com

Files

Comments

roz pea

yay first comment thanks guys

K

Happy Monday!

Mungo Franczak

What’s up truthers who’s up with their dad killing people as a child #VictorMarxMaxxing

Leonardo DiCaprizoliano

I was just eating such a good honeycrisp apple and then this episode dropped. What a day!

John Lemieux

My fantasy is that everyone reading this has a good day.

Brie Henry

That opening is some Starship Troopers shit

Abbas Araghchi

Yall forgot us after Monday I was starting to get worried

John Lemieux

Also; two chicks at the same time.

Kai

W faps!

tyler

producer yungchomsky

Woke Batou

Love seeing a Victor Marx lawn sign. I'm like "oh a loon lives there."

ploob

You are three times a lady Liz!

chris cheshire

Goin to town on them aurally. I’m here for it.

collin

So glad there isn't an Australian conservative guest on this episode

Erik Bourre

thanks YC!! you da bomb. and your pictures are pretty nice too!

Reece Coren

Opened this too early and thought the picture was guy fiere without the glasses

Kane Shirley

i see so many victor marx signs around town and i need to know if these people velieve his story

B

feeling very marxian

John Lemieux

I can disarm faster than victor marx simply with my smile

Mungo Franczak

Victor Marx’s dad didn’t literally become a warlock, he just switched from being a titan main

Blessed Papa

My fantasy is that they release 3 episodes a week

fioe06 t

Brace was 3 times in all those places for pleasure, not battle

Zoe Hart

This episode really needs input from TrueAnon nemesis and Lafayette extraordinaire Jacques Gonsoulin

ectoslavia

They're talking like something happened to Charlie Kirk anyone know anything about that?

tuff shed

You guys should do an ep on the Hamilton Morris Symposia MDMA drama. It involves evil rich guys, crazy freako lefty guys and drugs. Your favorite stuff.

casey

jessica krug pronounced her last name “cruz”

PottyJohn

Fucker sounds like Macho Man

Jerimiah

Victor Marx's dad, Karl, invented Cajun Karate. This is true.

Graham Hoese

Grew up listening to NPR on every car ride. Long story short, car talk, prairie home companion. I wonder if thats why I am the way I am.

James Rossi

you don't need a million dollars to do that

ploob

WeeWoo WeeWoo

Sillycrow123

I saw a guy in some random youtube short about tourism in Afghanistan that looked sorta like brace with a wig and sunglasses.

D

Thank you. And to you I hope your whole woods are glitched up today.

Your Mum

Victor Marx’s book is reminiscent of the hit 2003 film ‘Big Fish’, starring Ewin Mcgregor

ectoslavia

"we had some jokes prepared"

PickleHydra

prarie home companion was peak, thanks Grandma.

Swaggypeepaw

Foreign actvist political staff?

lfaxsrxldz

They can't cuz Hamilton knows Brace and they probably live 3 blocks from each other but yes Symposia is a DEA front maybe, or convenient idiots at least. In other words, i believe there is already some crossover between the TA/HM cinematic universes. Edit: ... Jesus Christ podcasts are such insidious parasocial brainrot I'm cooked I need to go read books and get laid

ChigBungus

“All I knew was he had just exercised superhuman strength. And now? It was time to fuck.”

ChigBungus

Honeycrisp are so damn good Truly the best apple

Banjo

Wrong Urban brother, Keith Urban is the country singer who married Gwen Stefani, Karl Urban is the actor on The Boys.

bob

Victor Marx’s yarns sound like Tom Clancy novels but about himself

subhmskalien

A sorcerer has magical powers by birth, whereas a warlock who has pledged his or herself to a diety channels the magic of that diety. I’m a well adjusted bipedal human person male.

Kevin M

My daughter, Auraaalye.

Ramses

my bush did 911 hat broke within a year of wear. can i get a replacement on the real??

K

Cannot be understated how heinous the British media caste is and how poisonously incestuous it is with the political caste, im not gonna claim it was certain that it was a full blown lynching by the media ghouls but i can certainly say the whole lotta them fucking suck and i hope Mr K finds em treats em like a cat 🙀

Shane-A112

woke 2 is woke but pro IRGC

ems

Still struggling to grasp the differences between warlocks and sorcerers.

Shiv

As someone who has family in Denver, cracking up at the accurate list of Colorado items

elizabethonline

James fishback’s IG comment sections is one of the best places on earth cause it’s full of people who are still fighting in the groyper wars like those guys in WWII who didn’t know shit had ended

Joelio

Give a cosmic crisp a try, quite the apple

bob

Also I love when Liz cracks out the Freud. Always a banger.

Lucy

la cosa mesta resort is in carlsbad near san diego - my aunt lives 10 mins from there. it is am omni resort now

Throw Away

3 times pimpy 3 times Afghanistan

Brenton

If you'll be my bodyguard I can be your long lost pal

JB Bowser

"Pause" (this whole episode) I love you 💜

NovalisGuy

They taught the "africa aids tweet" in uni

Markus Kraköwski

why are all the podcasts I listen to just the same podcast, QAA was talking about Victor marx like this week (im not complaining it's just interesting)

GG Allin Dulles

aaaand TWIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIINNNNNNNNNNNNNNS

Father Slime

Interesting… another Louisiana episode

Jen Jones

TruAnon ministries sounds AMAZING! Sign me up!

PT

My fantasy is James Fishback’s utter humiliation and downfall. I’m sick of him.

Calvert

Proto-woke.

Leanders

My mother, who is certifiably insane (by my standards), sent manic texts for 3 days about how her favorite cat died and she was determined to turn the skin into a hat or at least have the cat tail attached to a hat. She was so upset her ex/ unwilling houser wouldn’t cut the tail off for her. Anyway Victor Marx vibes but exception she actually caught the tail eventually.

Cara

It's very uncomfortable for me listening to this, because I don't think it is at all clear that he was a fraud. I agree with the points about incentives and sure the Liberal intelligencia sucks. But there isn't that much evidence that he lied about his childhood. On this pod you say the plagiarism wasn't investigated but I've read in the news today that it was and he was exonerated. So in that instance I'm fairly sure you've repeated a lie from an avowed eugenicist.

beepboop

I think its interesting to note that Arday reached out to the Guardian first. Saying he was the victim of a racist attack (partially true, one of the guys who would accuse him of plagiarism is an insane racist) and then made all these claims about a knived intruder breaking into his office twice, the pigs head, etc. When the guardian tried to validate his stories - he was taken aback saying "Oh I thought you'd just believe me". Pretty telling of the situation this guy was in where until now it seems the bigger the lie he told, the bigger the reward. And all of this happened at a time when he was in a press cycle to promote his memoir. It seemed like he felt he just had to squash the "bad" racist press by telling more lies to the "good" liberal press and he'd be able to control the situation. Sadly not. And I know there will be more things written about him that i'm sure he knew were coming. Sad situation all round.

Evan

Liz's thing about the teleology of identity farming was so good

Woke Batou

Entire state of Louisiana molested this guy

D

A cajun hand to gun combat specialist hired by Brian Wilson to be his personal karate teacher and bodyguard sounds like a story I would have written in my 20s after I read all of Kem Nunns books back to back.

avery parkway

You goddam freaks aught to do an ep on Perez Hilton self mutilating on TikTok live due to sepsis hysteria(?) genuinely insane news story and there are a lot of interesting through-lines there that connect to the kind of general schizo malaise and degenerative culture disease of the world today you folx can pick apart like vultures 🦅

Sampz

I used to duck hunt with a couple warlocks down in LA

Lojban Chauvinist

"self harming" this, "self-mutilating" that, will somebody just tell me what the man did?

Austin Williams

You don't need a fantasy to do that. Shit, look at my cousin in Ridgewood.

kk

Why do I get the feeling that Liz is a Victor Marx supporter?

Austin Williams

Read some of the guy that took down the Cambridge professor's substack. Being smart and ugly and a bad hang really does a number on some people.

avery parkway

Goes live on TikTok completely nude covered with blood and slashes himself in the face and the arms and the stomach basically everywhere with a large kitchen knife all while moaning and rubbing his nipples and talking about how good it felt. Since you wanted the full experience sick o

Mostafa Rajaai

Shit take on Arday. Could have looked at what comrades in Britain have been saying.

Pranjal Dwivedi

Arday is symptomatic of the mentality among liberal institutions to diversify and remove any possible standards to increase that, which then incentivises the likes of Arday to exaggerate their own stories and fake racism attacks to the Guardian and running 30 marathons. All of this is rewarded since none of these institutions have the guts to actually address issues regarding education so we get this silly tragic window dressing

Blake

I grew up next to Overland Park and that's just how we all talk here in Johnson County

Michael S. Judge

the "wearing YOUR head as a hat" bit is straight-up from Steve Buscemi in CON AIR

Emily

Blake Shelton

Chrissy

My fantasy is that I’m 5’8”

k

Prison smooths out the warlock

Pete

Perfect episode

Tor i

ENZO MENTION

Michael S. Judge

Brian Wilson 1988 Karate is all shrugs and pratfalls. They never got to striking

ben s

Richey rich over here

big man

My family used to vacation at La Costa when I was a kid ……. No one taught me karate

Keith

A warlock is a male witch and can unionize; whereas a sorcerer is management and aspires to necromancy.

Z F

back in 2013, I vaguely remember people calling it "call-out culture"

Z F

Justine Sacco way back in 2013

YIMBY 4 HEAVEN

"gun disarm video" kinda says it all

Timothy Buttons

What's the source you saw on the plagiarism accusations being false? His dissertation and many of his subsequent articles have massive chunks that were copied word-for-word from other academics. They weren't presented as quotes and their authors weren't cited, it's pretty cut and dry that he was deliberately plagiarizing. You don't need to take the racist guy's word for it, he extensively cited the material in question and you can double check for yourself. That's what I did and it all lines up

Homalek

Wets duss say I got it fwum a guy who didn’t need it anymore

SF

Nathan Cofnas sock account

SF

It was a lynching instigated by a psychotic race realist

Misha K

Rip bungo

Pranjal Dwivedi

Sorry that you are Nathan Cofnas’ sock account

E

To set the matter straight, prison does not smooth out a warlock. Once a warlock always a warlock. Thought you all knew this.

Marcus

Recordsetter.com might be the greatest website in existence. And not just because someone is finally giving Guinness some competition.

Blank

Really good ep. It’s interesting to hear Brace say there isn’t a narrative to his life, when it seems to me there’s a clear one that could be imposed (death of parent, perceived bad kid, The Game, punk/developing politics alongside addiction (details of the sf punk scene à la Just Kids), recovery, redemption and politics realized/consummated through 1. service abroad 2. organizing anchor union and 3. Finally founding uber successful podcast that draws on all of these threads, resolution with brace living a fulfilled life cooking chicken livers from the farmers market). Also has SF and NYC as bookends. That might be an awful and/or inaccurate narrative for a number of reasons, and I could completely understand Brace wanting to avoid it but it seems like the obvious one. I also take the pt that we don’t live our lives in ways that feel linear

jjj

Loved to hear YC getting loose with the sound effects today

Robert Armstrong

🎶Satan is real, Living in power, You can see him, and know him, In this world day by day. Satan is real, Living in spirit, He will tempt you and lead you astray.🎶

GB

Steven Segal and John C Riley had a baby

D

Damn it'd be funny as hell if that's the story.

GB

1% chance

Soda enthusiast

Victor Marx's stepfather was a man named Ferdinand lassalle

buttface

I got bored and couldnt follow this one

Mackenzie parvin

No lie my dad learned how to magic card tricks in jail , is that kinda like a warlock ?

Baby J

Can someone with real autism lie? Doesn’t lying require a level of mind-reading that is fundamentally flawed?

ethan

Brace I can assure you there are worse states to live in than Colorado

Jacobo

Recently graduated from a master’s program and had to show my friends Jess la Bombalera. What a gem. I read fugitive modernities and it sucked ass

jopi

colorado mentioned 🦅🦅🦅

Joelio

Bang bang

tuff shed

Podcasts are the 7-oh of the masses.

Jeremy Oliver

woke1 is my favorite sunn O))) album

elmin

Liz batting 1000 on this one. Agnostic or a gnostic??? are you kidding me???

adam22

Skill issue

L DILLA

Agreed. Quite a good apple. Aside: My old boss had one of their trees and pays a yearly subscription fee for the pleasure of having one.

Adam

The victor marx form of lying sounds like the dramatic and improbable Christian testimony stories one hears as a teenager. Certain evangelical churches really reward guest speakers with the most lurid tales of sin and depravity followed by salvation. That’s why he is so comfortable sharing. It’s how he got to where he is.

Tea for the Tillerman

Beat on the brat Beat on the brat Beat on the brat with the warlock dad

Dan

1:08:38 " Gwen Stefani from the 'The Voice'". Ouch. Are there that many Gen Z here, that we have to use "The Voice" as the point of reference for the lead singer of No Doubt?

Super dooper

But they’re everywhere, you drive down any road in Weld County and you see a gajillion of them. How many of the people in this state are just fucking insane???!!!!

Vic Perry

I believe you, Mr. Wilson. I believe you anyway.

fioe06 t

I really hate when they try to talk about Islam

Bryson Martinez

He ripped that “ my dad was a cia mind control agent “ thing from someone it’s not Manson or Ted k. That story was lifted. I cannot think of the book I was reading that mentioned it. I will find it.

Leslie seaton

“Yeah there’s a ton of guys named Matt there”

That Guy

Brace needs to dive into Kajukenbo which is like Karate if your form combos were like 50% kicks to the nuts and your black belt test is getting jumped by 3 guys in a bar fight

Major Pisano

I know one of Tom waits first girlfriends older brother.. he’s old too… Tom, Drank and smoked as much whisky and smoked as much camels Marlboro to manifest the sound he desired. It’s life long goal to establish such gravel, it’s not an undertaking for the false intrepid or lacking the fortitude.

alex

so, nothing about cofnas?

Axel H.

Inland Empire clip was perfect. 👌

Major Pisano

Like Liz said. You need to find Islam.

Timothy Buttons

That's not evidence, that's someone on Twitter saying he was cleared. His thesis from 2015 is filled with full phrases and paragraphs copied verbatim from a thesis that was published in 2009. You're the one giving oxygen to this whole ordeal by denying what is obviously true and provoking pointless argument

Digby Tomei

"I'm calling bluff" on Woke 1.0 "with the bubble wand!"

Digby Tomei

Franczak Jordies aka Chazwazza

Em

Sure and you have shown the same energy to all other plagiarism accusations? And sure I can dig for you later when I have time after visit in hospital and work. But I'm sure you work in academicia and know what you are talking about....

Timothy Buttons

You should acknowledge up front that he plagiarized and then focus on the disproportionate reaction and racial hate campaign. Do the bare minimum and look at the evidence so that you know which arguments are worth having

David Haigh

Yeah hopefully without sounding too callous, I feel he'd made this "gamble" on his life(story) a long time ago and he knew the stakes, but he beat the odds to a point where he almost snowballed. Presumably his book and professorship combined would have codified his exagerations and fabrications to a substantial degree, so i don't get the arguement it wasn't in the public interest. I feel a lot of the British reporting/hand wringing after reporting (Novara) takes away a lot of the agency he had (albeit agency in a fucked up system that rewards lying successfully until it suddenly doesn't) but nevertheless.

Cara

of course people with autism can lie

Jonah Stocks ladd

big yeah cosmic crisp are what got me from a naysayer to a oneadayer

cyberbasque

real “apples and oranges” episode lol. you’d think “JEWISH NAZI” would get at least like, a couple minutes

MirrorOooMirror

As a veteran of the eternal war between good and evil, and having served multiple tours of duty (both above and below abroad), my time on the Front Lines of Ministry came rushing back to me all at once, and hit me in the gut just like the time Satan head butted me in the stomach during a little hand to hand combat showdown, devil tango style. Unfortunately the PTSD hit me hard during this listen…images flashing back to me of those times slaying demons disguised as muslims has kept me awake the last couple nights. But I fight on, I walk chin up, I walk tall. My therapist says it’s good that I recount my time served in the Great War, so for this, I thank you Trueanon. 🫡

LiberalGroyper

We need an official comment on the beautiful Nancy Mace’s new tattoos

Laura

See as

James

The UK media occasionally like to destroy a person's life. So they destroyed his. The previous Chancellor was guilty of plagiarism and fabricating her CV - the media asked her about how she makes her own sandwiches and likes chess because she is in the club. Most of Britain's elite are where they are due to bullshit, nepotism and jobs for the boys from particular public schools or universities - and they never get called out for the shite. The UK has a poisonous, evil, cruel media who take a break from calling for austerity that will kill people, or demands for more bombs and wars which will kill people - to go all out for hounding individuals, with very little real significance or power, to their deaths for indiscretions that the media is up to their eyeballs in. The libs have their faults but they are nothing compared to the UK elite. Fucking monsters who could ignore Petie Mandelson's behaviour for decades, but not this sociologist's. 2.5 articles a day in the "newspapers of record" about a sociologist 99.9% of the population had never even heard of because it was in the public interest - bullshit. The same newspapers that would get Petie on to act the wise old sage, or for soft soap "I made mistakes" even after the emails and birthday book were out in the open.

KHL

1:27:25 I’d get Brace’s memoir, and see the inevitable movie adaptation. Anyone else see Stav as Brace and Adam as YC?

T

something interesting at the end of the episode about self mythologizing is that it’s not just an independent drive (though it often is) but it’s also highly rewarded. even outside of academia or politics where that plays a pretty significant role even when talking about true aspects of your life, there’s also elements of this in business, etc where it’s all echoing similar drives. I used to occasionally do interviews for a pretty big company and part of the rule for interviewing was to ask someone about a time they failed, however, that failure needed to be an inflection or change point for some greater success or interesting pivot in their thinking. the creation of the idealized and complete self is also part of the intoxicating and destructive effect of social media, where people’s lives being manicured and groomed vehicles for either portraying a specific vision of their life or influencing/ selling something. it’s all very individualized society of the spectacle and it’s sad to see especially in cases like arday’s

drewb

goobernatorial

Big L

warlocks are the blue collar, boots on the ground type of witchers

Rocky

As a Coloradan this has convinced me to vote for Victor Marx. Thank you. I hate cats.

Ian H

I think one reason that academia and the military are such fonts of created identities is that they both take 18 yr olds away from home for the first time. I feel like almost everyone lies about themselves at least a little bit during that initial clumsy attempt at adult identity formation, if only because children often have pretty uninteresting lives, and a big part of maturing in your twenties is figuring out who you *actually are* as an adult and reconciling that self-image with your background. Some people just stake too much on or get too rewarded for the false narrative and never grow out of it.

Abiham

Prison warlock is Damien Echols and it worked for him

cmason105

Holy shit, that first lady was from my home town of overland Park????

Ian H

@ 1:36:20 I've always felt that Raquel Saraswati (aka Rachel Elizabeth Seidel) was representative of this. One of the hiring officers for the Friends Service Committee where she worked when presenting as a queer, South Asian/Latina, Muslim woman specifically noted that her identity "touched on all the points" they were looking for.

Laura

This reminds me of a story that you briefly mentioned Brace, the story with the severely autistic boy who uses “facilitated communication” (a widely discredited method) to write a novel when clearly it was his mother. (Woody Brown is his name, there is an astonishing today show video featuring Jenna Bush). It would be a great episode to look into the “Telepathy Tapes” podcast and more into the Facilitated Communication world. Similar vibe with this story- there is something depressing about this idea that within every severely autistic person there is a secret genius, which Arday’s narrative reinforces. And I’m not saying there aren’t wild things that can happen in this world, miracles can happen, but these prominent stories seem so blatantly false and are a similar manifestation of the “secret princess” fantasy Liz spoke of. On one hand I really feel for the parents of these kids. the available services for these families are abysmal and I think most of these parents are desperate and not cynical actors. I think they believe it to be real and what it says about larger questions of disability and they way it’s dealt with in our society is more interesting then whether they are lying or not. It’s a fascinating rabbit hole to go down, Anna Stubblefield, the Telepathy podcast, this recent novel, there’s so much

Xavier

Anything I pay this pod is worth it just to hear Brace say Puerto Rico over and over again.

Christopher Price

brace, the guards are going to take one look at your schnoz and put you with the Muslims

Robert

I think there are some good points in this episode about how the military and acadmia work as mirrors to each other, and how each encourages people within them to self-mythologise and how that being rewarded encourages further self mythology. I think the Jason Arday part feels jarring becuase ultimately, whatever exagerrations or plagiarism or anything, the stakes are so small. He got to be a professor at Cambridge... cool man, that's very prestigious. Then, a man who got fired for saying black people aren't intelligent writes a substack about how he thinks this specific black person isn't intelligent and suddenly it's a national news story for weeks? There's enough noise that it's breaking through to the states? It's an academic spat that's been leveraged by the media as a criticism of DEI. I think the strength of pro-Arday feeling isn't because people believe everything he's ever said but becuase they can see how it's being used to tear down a black, autistic public figure, and how gleeful and bloodthirsty most of the press are to do that. I don't know man, Trump's the president, politicians stand up everyday and say that Israel isn't committing a genocide. If Victor Marx got into power, would he do good things, would he face consequences for his bullshit? Perhaps Jason Arday did get over-promoted, and maybe he lied on his CV, maybe he wasn't a great professor. He's dead now and the people who hounded him and published vitriol about him daily will carry on writing and publishing and not face any consequences

Alex Leo Swenson

Brace I am begging you to take one of these book deals and populate it with Child Called It lies. You could do it better than anyone’s ever done it

Killer Dan

they should have discussed Esteban

Killer Dan

i’m a slave to my bassist impulses

Daniel Chamberlain

Need to find a ghostwriter to help me Big Fish my way into Congress.

Alex Gullen

Classic episode. This Viktor character sounds awesome, in a LiverKing pre-pipe way, with just a blue tongue.

Jules Wang

the issue is that all the other people (not black) that plgiarized and got away with it despite mounting evidence received no media backlash. this was a deliberate attempt to destroy a black academic's life. sure, one who made shit up, but I don't think this needed to be anything more than a one off article and/or just a niche scandal in academic forums. it was damning of Novara, except for ash sakar who did made a sincere apology, to not do the basic research (ironically) and realize whatever the merit of the plagiarism, the whole thing was instigated by a fucking known racist fraud on a revenge quest. them not issuing a collective apology is a mistake.

beepboop

Yeah racism absolutely played a huge part in how big it was. It became a whole anti DEI thing. But also a big reach to say he just did a bit of plagerism. The entire basis of his career was that he couldn't read and write until he was 18, was non verbal until he was 11, was told he would live in a care home and was smearing feaces on the wall. And then ..he just got better, achieved a phd, had a stroke, had locked in syndrome... the list goes on. And this was the inspirational story that accompanied his appointment to cambridge. This was why he was supposed to be so remarkable and an expert on education. He spoke at events for parents of children with level 3 autism. He gave them hope. You don't just get better from that. not possible. That's also why the response was so big. It was a total house of cards. He also proactively wrote and published a memoir repeating these enormous, disprovable claims. Also worth noting many people have had their careers ended by plagerism accusations. For example the ex PM of Hungary and that French physicist. Both had massive media backlash at the time.

Joey

3x erect

Alexandria

As a mother I can say with authority a 3 year old simply CANNOT kill a cat, especially with a knife. Perhaps a gun if he/she has the proper training. But killing a cat with a knife? I don't even believe he could HOLD the cat long enough to kill it. What I'm saying basically is that the cat for sure would have killed him before he killed the cat

Alexandria

MY dad really knows what he's doing!

Alexandria

You put my feelings into words completely. The pro Arday reaction-faction does not deny the plagarism or whatever allegations are out there substantiated and otherwise. One clearly envious psychotic academic executed a targeted campaign against Arday and the public ate it right up now he's dead and we're still talking about the plagarism. I should call the tip line but in my career in academia I witnessed and experienced some of the most insane behavior from these exact types. It's cut throat and attracts unwell Machiavellianist self aggrandizers who get away with crazy shit

Alexandria

Keith Urban is an Australian country singer who married (and divorced this very year) Nicole Kidman, the actress. Blake Shelton is an American country singer on The Voice who married Gwen Stefani

Alexandria

Sadly Gwen made her choices and now she's "from The Voice"

Alexandria

The Telepathy Tapes podcast atmosphere is so sad and dark. I too really feel for the parents and also the kids

Florina Tudose

Or at least a bit more compassion for a mentally unwell person who killed themselves…

C.M. Worthington

I think the thing that bothers me most about tracing the modern origin of this stuff back to “woke” and social media is that it completely obscures the central role played by Oprah Winfrey in all of this in the pre-internet 1990’s. Someone really needs to do a deep dive into how much havoc she’s wreaked upon us all.

ITSRON

one of the only essays that i go back to often and which i always turn to tears at (only because it makes reminds me of how cool lying is) is oscar wilde's the decay of lying, good companion to liz fave f for fake, we need more florid inspired liars its what good art is and its also the only artform some crazy people excel at https://archive.org/details/bwb_O7-BPF-111/page/10/mode/2up

Isaac

At least we still have genuine scholars like Dan Ariely and Neri Oxman

Vanessa K

I’m high functioning autistic and was selectively mute as a period when I was a kid. I knew how to speak but has moments/days where it felt impossible. Mutism is distinct from being non verbal, so that may explain some of the differing accts of his childhood.

Bananab

Think it’s kind of wild the difference in outcomes on this one however…. right wing fabulist wins his primary, fabulist celebrated by liberals gets demolished in media and kills himself. not trying to stick up for liberals but i think that a propensity for lying is rewarded more weightily on one side than the other

August Gardener

I believe sorcery is manifesting from morally neutral deities, as opposed to warlocks manifesting from evil ones expressly.

Banjo

Oh shit, you're right. Wasn't even one of the Urbans. 😄

claire

YC really put in the work on this one

Shmeliot

https://titorenko.github.io/analysethat/posts/thesis-overlap-analysis/ This has some data analysis on the overlap between the two thesis. Arday took 7,000-11,000 words from the other thesis. This is out of the total around 146,000 words in his thesis. Its important to note that the overlap occurs almost entirely in the introduction and literature review parts of Arday's thesis. This is where one discusses the other work done in a neighborhood of research inquiry to delineate where your research fits in.

Shmeliot

He shouldn't have just lifted the stuff in the way that he did. But the plagarism doesn't come from the meat and potatoes of his research.

DW Mault

Liz’s obsession with Karate in the 80s reminds of that scene in Boogie Nights where DD shows off his Karate influenced bedroom… 😂😂😂

Jules Wang

I'm referring specifically to the media environment in the UK and how it operates with regard to non normative people in its institutions. even with the made up life story, I still don't think outlets like Novara, the ones in which I felt the most disappointment, should've followed the herd and gone after ardy. that story was far from the types covered by them anyway! the minute the UK mainstream smelled blood there was only one way this story could've ended. this reminds me, in some ways, of the book passing for perfect by erin khue ninh, which is more about the desperations and monstrosities that the model minority family can breed accidentally as proof that racialized & neolib capitalism still has merit. I do wonder what drove ardy to the protracted, often deranged fabulations, but to me anyway this whole thing was ultimately about how the UK loathes its others. just deeply sad all around.

Andrew Wacker

I've never seen this man, but his voice sounds like John C Riley doing a bit.

Zac

Meritocratic Romance was *chef’s kiss*

Leah

Haha this was my thought exactly as the parent of 2 kids. A 3 year old couldn’t stab a cat with a knife let alone cut its head off. A 3 year old weighs like 30-40 pounds, they don’t have that kind of strength!

Zac

Of course, it’s french

Mikachu

I'm not sure that Jason Arday is a plagiarist and I think you guys should have expounded on that more rather than lean into the framing of the hate campaign against him.

Zac

Victor Marx is a decent storyteller but I thought for sure he was setting up a climactic gun-disarming moment when the Satan-possessed ISIS guy broke out of his handcuffs

August Gardener

TrueAnon Rule No. 1: Be normal. TrueAnon Rule No. 2: Don’t kill yourself.

Ian H

My daughter will be 4 in a month, loves to help in the kitchen, and she can get just enough grip and force on a (child-safe, plastic) knife to make it through a mushroom or zucchini. I'm also a chef who's done a fair bit of butchery, spines are *tough*, even in surprisingly small animals like rabbits. Immediate scoff from me too

That Guy

Y'all need a better grocer: Macintosh > Opal > Every apple you listed > red delicious

pizzapope

a warlock obviously is someone who makes a contract with eldritch forces who then grant the warlock some of their power to be able to conjure a devastating eldritch blast

pizzapope

so glad i already took my chapo sub money and put it straight into crackpots

beepboop

Britis media can be the most brutal on earth. Wouldn't wish having their sights turned on my worst enemy. And yeah, Ash and Aaron I think shared some jokes about Arday on twitter, which goes beyond factually reporting on his claims - something I think any outlet is entitled to do. Ultimately I think its dangerous to say "there was only one way this could have gone" i think it steps towards glamorousing suicide and simplifying a complex issue (there are victims of Ardays for sure, doest mean he deserved to die though) into absolving him of any wrongdoing because he is dead. From an article I appreciated on this: "What I propose is that the public give Arday a courtesy in death that he was often denied in life: Let’s treat him like a person. Not like Cambridge’s magical negro, or like Simon & Schuster’s golden goose, or like the fetish object of internet racists, but like a flawed human being who should still be alive but is not. That requires being honest about who Arday was, not despite his tragic death but because of it. After all, it was systemic, ritualized dishonesty—his own and others’—that undid him" The blame lies with his friends and colleagues. Many of whom doubted his claims openly amongst themselves and to the media for many, many years. But not to his face. They should have quietly challenged him on this and allowed him to quietly step aside, apologise and move on with his life. It felt like his supporters were only able to support him conditional on the coverage about him being untrue. Imagine if his cambridge colleagues said, it's okay, you can get through this, you can take responsibility and move forward. They doubled down and said every claim the media made was racist. And for what it's worth, I don't think anyone lied about him, even vile right wing outlets. I think they were very cruel and nasty about him and it's unacceptable and they need to ask serious questions about the impact that has on people.

Ian Thomas

prime example of why no one is doing podcasts quite like trueanon.

gg

Michael Ouderkirk

Jake Gyllenhaal was at one point attached to play Brace in a film about his time in Syria. Someone bought the film rights to that article about him from 2017 in, was it Rolling Stone?

Blank

I could see Jake gyllenhaal tbh, one could certainly do a lot worse. I’m curious who brace (and YC and Liz) would select to play him/them

August

You gotta hit the tipline

N P

What is this in reference to

Josh Watkins

I hadn't heard of Jason Arday until this episode and for the first few minutes of the segment I became paranoid that it was some kind of Borgesian trick

Tessa

Definitely not true that the pro-Arday faction does not deny the plagiarism and fabrication allegations. Many of the loudest voices speaking in defense of him are doing just that.

Tessa

It is entirely clear he was a fraud. His plagiarism is well documented. Inside Higher Ed was all set to publish a story about his plagiarism (before the racist guy with an axe to grind wrote his post), which had been intensely vetted by a bunch of plagiarism experts, before Arday called the cops on the author of the piece for no reason and threatened the outlet with the most aggressive libel firm in the UK. They pulled the story because they felt they couldn’t afford the legal battle. But concerns about Arday’s dissertation and papers preceded all of this—quite a few people in the field had raised concerns prior to this, including instances where he blatantly fabricated quotes for a few papers. Additionally, he was clearly caught out lying on several of the grandiose aspects of his life story—consult the Atlantic and Guardian’s (the latter outlet is one he approached!) reporting for the specifics—that are totally separate from the plagiarism allegations. It’s a tragedy that he killed himself, but the man was a pathological liar, and no one with the facts of the case can really dispute that.

Tessa

The media obviously jumped at the opportunity to do racist, anti-DEI shit, but I think we should be clear that they were only able to do that because Arday had already destroyed his own life by being a pathological, self-aggrandizing liar. He was the architect of his circumstances.

MirrorOooMirror

Her total lack of interest in mountains brought her average down to 200. Come on Liz! The Rocky Mountains > NYC, it’s not even close.

Robert

Look, to echo what Alexandria said above: a man has been hounded by the media to the point where he has killed himself and you're talking about plagiarism. Who fucking cares?!? Maybe he did, and he got a couple of jobs he shouldn't, doesn't look great for the institutions that hired him but how does that affect your life? Do you think that the punishment for plagiarism should be every newspaper does a deep dive on every aspect of your life, looking for any inconsistencies so they can print them out and call you a liar? Do you think when people in a comments section push back on accusations from a eugenicist and parrotted by the entire media, those people in the comment section are as loud a voice? Did they become as loud because they shared an instagram post from Novara? 'Um, actually, he did do plagiarism, so everythin else that happened was justified and proportionate. Or maybe it wasn't, but let's keep the focus on the fact the he lied.' Incredible take, I look forward to that standard being applied equally across all walks of life

Wojciech

Original second half will be in the lost media compilations for decades

Tessa

It’s a little disingenuous to say he was hounded by the media without acknowledging that he sought out the media to tell the grandiose version of his life story he wanted told. Arday chose to approach the Guardian a few months back and tell a reporter a bunch of easily disproved lies (I suggest you read their reporting on this, btw). He chose to write a memoir with a bunch of lies about his life. The media didn’t make him do that. They didn’t make him lie about raising millions of pounds for charity, they didn’t make him lie about running 600 miles in 6 days, they didn’t make him lie about running 30 marathons in 35 days, 10 of which he supposedly did with a broken leg. As an academic, I actually do think it’s a big deal when there’s fraud in the industry that discredits us in the public eye. If people used their heads about this case, it would be obvious to them, too. It does affect public trust in academia when we elevate as department chair an under qualified, pathological liar who also happened to plagiarize and fabricate portions of his academic work. I never said the racist media coverage was justified. But we do no one any favors in these situations when we lie about the situations that led to this outcome.

chorchy

And four times à lady:)

Robert

Hounding is pretty accurate, even if he wasn't as good a jogger as he said. I think the efforts that the Times, Telegraph and Mail have made to scrub google and their own archives suggest that they also know how badly they overreached. I think the amount of time the guardian took to put out on op-ed on Arday, and the fact that comments are turned off suggests they also know they jumped on the band wagon and were not, in fact, doing good journalism. I'm not an academic, but here's a few things I think discredit academia: -hiring a eugenicist to your philosophy department -having your hiring practices be so lax that someone can, apparently, plagiarise half of all their writing and still be made a professor -having your hiring practices be so lax that you hire a eugenicist as a professor -having so few people of colour in your faculty that you hastily hire someone underqualified when social justice becomes a news item -being so craven that when a rightwing witch hunt gets stirred up you completely abandon a member of your faculty in an effort to distance yourself from controversy. I wonder, what lie are you telling about Jason Arday's situation to square with the fact that he is dead now? That plagiarism is so egregious a crime that it deserved that level of media attention? That anyone who plagiarised and exagerrated would receive this level of scrutiny? That the investigations into him were fair? That the way he was treated by Cambridge, either in tokenistically hiring him or later abandoning him, was fair? That no other department heads are underqualified? Or liars? So look, I don't want to talk about this anymore. There is no lie or exagerration or cheating or plagiarising that Jason Arday could have done which justifies the level of scrutiny and harassment he got. If the conjecture is that he's a grifter, then the ceiling of his grift was a professorship and a book deal. This might seem like untold power and influence to an academic but I assure you it's not.

James

I’VE ABANDONED MY MUNGO

EEEEM

Is there a term for the opposite of a sin eater? Someone who takes on the role of embodying social hopes and desires? Seems like a pretty bad gig.

Tessa

I’m not sure why you’re getting so upset over this, so I agree it’s probably a good idea for you to disengage, but I actually don’t have to square anything with respect to Arday’s death. It’s not remotely surprising it ended this way, to me—pathological liars actually kill themselves fairly frequently when their houses of cards collapse because 1) it’s their worst nightmare and 2) it’s their last chance to take back control of the narrative, which you’ve demonstrated here that Arday has done very effectively. No one has anything to apologize for for discovering or pointing out that Arday was a liar. This is a reasonable thing to do when someone writes a memoir with countless self-aggrandizing lies and then, unprompted, seeks out the press for more attention. Obviously certain outlets and the eugenicist former academic you’re talking about were acting in bad faith and affording this an inappropriate amount of coverage, to say the least, but there are good reporters who broke facts on this story who did nothing remotely like “hounding” Arday to death, and it’s frankly offensive to both their work and Arday’s own agency to suggest otherwise. You’ve got to take a step back from this and be rational about it, man.

Tessa

Young academics are also heavily encouraged to create a grand narrative that their life and academic/research interests feed into—and by heavily encouraged, I mean they’re often told “You need to create a narrative for how all of this is connected in a way that will inspire admissions teams, funders, etc., or you’ll get nowhere in this industry.” I once got rejected for an OxBridge grant because the committee felt I didn’t have a “personal connection” to the topic I was studying (interest in it/passion for it was insufficient).

Himalayan Michaels

as a jeb bush style sorcerer, we disavow warlocks. theyre too reactionary

Himalayan Michaels

It appears victor became a paladin later in life which is common for the spawn of warlocks

Em

This is my point. This whole thing is disproportionate and he should imho not have been included in this episode. Like if you want to look into the whole academic bs sure. But I don't think this episode is done in a way to bring needed nuance into this convo. Also I already blocked few people as they keep iterating what a huge fraud he was without getting the context at all.

Robert

So, going back to my original comment, there are actually a lot of pathological liars who don't face anything like the scrutiny Arday did. And their houses of cards don't come tumbling down because they are the 'right kind of person.' Boris Johnson, Nigel Farage, Peter Mandelson, Andrew Mountbatten, all have told much more consequential lies and have paid little or no price for that. The Spectator recently published an article arguing that Andrew has suffered enough, at the same time as they were relishing in tearing down Arday. I am upset because when I look at Jason Arday I see institutional powers in the UK delighting in the misery they can pile on this guy, in a way that they never do when it's one of their mates in government or media who's spouting bullshit, or easily disproven fantasy. I see a clear message going out to everyone outside the club that this can happen to them if they step out of line, or stop being useful. Nicolas Cofnas is not a former academic. He's working at the university of Ghent. Presumably he will continue getting jobs. If he gets accused of plagiarism, I doubt it will become a national news story, certainly it won't get the 'inappropriate amount of coverage.' I doubt any of the myriad acedemics who are embroiled in plagiarism accusations, or sexual assault allegations or any other rotten thing you can think will get that amount of coverage. I think the anger I'm feeling is pretty rational. If you're able to look at the whole Jason Arday situation and come away thinking the person who acted worst was Jason Arday, I don't think you're being rational, I don't think you're being a human being

Dr. Ron Jambo

Apparently 'warlock' originally meant simply 'liar'. So they are a family of warlocks. I believe that.

Tessa

I’m not reading all this, man.

Robert

You're a credit to academia

Tessa

It’s interesting how nasty you’re being about this.

Tessa

I’m a liar, I’m not a human being, I’m an idiot because I’m declining to engage with you further. Why are you talking to me this way?

Robert

Do you recognise any nastiness coming from yourself in calling Jason Arday a pathological liar? Or saying he killed himself to take back control of the narrative? Do you recognise any nastiness in the means or motives of the people who started and continued the witch hunt of the guy? Do you think at any point you've engaged with any of the points I've tried to make? Or have you been glib and dismissive and determined to get another kick in on this guy who spent the last month of his life getting crucified by the press? Please look at how you've talked to me for clues on why I might find you unpleasant

Tessa

Robert, he was a pathological liar. That is not in dispute, and it’s not nasty to acknowledge what anyone who looks honestly at this situation can see. Two things can be true at once: it’s a tragedy he killed himself and the racist right should be ashamed of themselves for their conduct and contributed to this outcome, AND the man was undeniably a pathological liar whose last act was almost certainly motivated, at least in part, by the self-aggrandizing impulse which drove him through life. Liz and Brace said all of this themselves on the podcast. I can’t engage with your argument here because you don’t have one. This is why I told you I’m not going into this with you anymore—you can call me an inhuman idiot all you want, but I can recognize when someone is so emotionally invested in a story that they won’t be persuaded to see reason. That’s what’s happening here, and there’s no point arguing with you because of it.

Alexandros

American & British libs will never learn lol. Same shit that's happening with COVID, dying on the hill of "Fauci did nothing wrong" because they feel they have to take the exact opposite stance of everything the chuds say. How many had heard of Jason Arday before the scandal broke out 2-3 weeks ago? Yes, obviously he was hounded by the media and obviously it was racially motivated but you don't have to stake your worldview on some random academic's reputation you didn't even know existed 1 month ago.

Robert

Okay, I think you saying that he wasn't hounded by the media makes you a liar, or at least a rube. I thinking acting like this is a story about plagiarism rather than a eugenicist who has written that black people should not be present in higher education successfully starting a campaign that removes a prominent black academic from higher education is a bad take. I think Liz and Brace got this one wrong and I'm frustrated because what should be a story about how reckless and dangerous the British press are becomes an investigation into whether a black academic was telling the truth. I don't think lying should come with this as a punishment and the point I have tried to make again and again is that there are plenty of liars who don't face even a fraction of the scrutiny Arday did. Can you engage with that? Or does it not matter? Because plagiarism

Alexandros

Lol what's the point of this comment? Do you suspect Brace and Liz secretly agree with Cofnas' ideology? Do you think TrueAnon listeners with an average daily 12h of screentime don't know the basics of this story and who Cofnas is?

Robert

Feel like I have been pretty clear that I don't care whether Arday was or was not a good scholar. I hadn't heard of him before this, when I did hear about hmy only thought was why is this in the news? I think the British media and academia are rotten and racist institutions and that's what the Jason Arday story should be about, not what he wrote in his memoir

Tessa

Robert, you’re misrepresenting what I said: “it’s disingenuous to say he was hounded by the media without also acknowledging…” is not the same as “he wasn’t hounded by the media.” But I won’t continue to argue with someone misrepresenting me, calling me a liar, idiot, rube, not a human being, etc. You need to learn how to differ with respect.

cyberbasque

there are many, many instances of plagiarism in academia. if you think that it isn’t worth contextualizing the Arday case with the people who made it a priority to blow *this* story up and feed it to the racist news media I don’t know what to tell you. the Arday story is obviously not the same as Victor Marx and it is strange to juxtapose them as if they are. if “shit you’d see being online” would disqualify a topic from being discussed most of this lefty podcast scene wouldn’t be able to post anything!

A Horse In A Man Costume

Beach Boys fan chiming into to say that I completely believe this guy became Brian Wilson's karate instructor/bodyguard. Victor Marx wouldn't even be in the top 1000 weirdest guys associated with the Beach Boys lol

Alexandria

As a person in academia some of the worst misconduct I've witnessed has been because of powerful and successful people with unstoppable envy who cannot help but destroy a colleague. I've seen tenured department chairs absolutely destroy the careers of young researchers applying for their first academic job! Punching down in crazy ways. I hope all the academics out there right now using this opportunity to align with Confas are prepared for their history to be questioned in the same way. Like Robert said, the stakes here are low. He got some jobs and some book deals and maybe even an entire career off of untruths then paid the price with his life. That's all. That does not affect your grant funding!

Tessa

I think you should tell this to the sociologists in race studies in the UK who have told reporters this will set their field back by years. It’s really not difficult to understand that something doesn’t have to be the biggest thing that’s ever happened to still have real consequences. This is such childish reasoning.

B

It’s all about the Pork Chop on a stick

mrakobesiye

I'm dying listening to Liz reading from The Dangerous Gentleman

Robert

Tess! Wait! This may shock and appal you but your out of hand dismissal of Alexandria's argument as childish may not meet the standard of respectful difference that you hold dear! I have come to realise how important this is to debate! I would hate if Bad Actors mischaracterised you as someone who only uses ideas of Respect and Politeness as a shield for your own moral bankruptcy in the argument. I would hate for you, a paragon of rational, level headed debate to fall foul of such Cynical and Unkind readings of your work!

R D

Cops said the case was VERY cold, Many such cases since then

Dr. Ron Jambo

But seriously, I believe Zizek wrote about this phrnomenon

Lauren Olamina

Wow, that Jessica Krug accent was so bad. Who fell for that?

MirrorOooMirror

The point is, lying is one thing, and everyone lies all the fucking time, but these freaks aren’t liars. They’re delusional psychopaths, who in a normal society would be immediately recognized by all as potentially dangerous and severely mentally ill.

Fidolith

Brace, you would love SZA she be lying her ass off.

Kern Mailer

La Bombalera’s accent is insane but still here to support Woke 2’s commitment to a supportive, inclusive, tolerant and caring environment for race transitioning

Shaurya Oberoi

The conversation about how we need to draw a distinction between Arday’s lie and Marx’s lie to see what/who its lying to reminds me of Season of Migration to the North by Tayeb Salih!

MB

Thank you!

Jordan Deeney

It's cool that people can pretend their life is just The Witcher

Austin Orecchio

A warlock derives their power from a demonic or otherworldly compact. A wizard derives power from careful study. In dnd, anyways.

FeloniousUnc

Vic Marx sounds like Darryl Hammond impersonating Bill Clinton

Areti

Among practising witches, warlocks have a reputation for being deceptive/“oath breakers”. I am a slightly less well adjusted but mostly normal human person

Kevin C

jewish to afro latina pipeline

chorchy

I love that victor marx wrote ‘an audible sound’

Horse Badorties

Now I'm imagining Jake hanging with Brace like Depp hanging with HST, developing the imitation.

Horse Badorties

I did not know that there is a Clever Hans syndrome for severely autistic kids

Horse Badorties

A friend thinks his dad was a victim in the first round of CIA in-house LSD fun.

CJ

Righteous Beat poetry man 🙌