Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Joshua Citarella is an artist and internet culture writer. He is the host of Doomscroll. He appeared on TrueAnon episode 425.

*****

Memetic Histories & Neoliberalism

Some years ago, I began to study and theorize the political phenomena that was taking place over social media. The early origins of this project began with the long form essay Politigram & the Post-left that was first published in 2018. Primarily, my work has focused on the social media activity of young Gen Z meme posters, ages 12 - 25. I’ve watched how these posters evolve in their political views and how they now make decisions later in life. My practice became an extensive research project into the underground of online political groups. 

Studying fringe movements and watching their rise into mainstream prominence is important. It can help to explain how we arrived at today’s political common sense. While neoliberalism served as the consensus ideology for the past 40 years, it was once a niche intellectual movement on the theoretical fringes. Given the appropriate time and resources, many of today’s new ideological strains could follow a similar trajectory. 

After years of immersing myself in this field, I’ve uncovered that many supposedly silly memes are actually part of a multi-decade propaganda campaign. Their underlying philosophies have worked to shape our very conception of political alignment. In this text we will explore a brief history of two of the most popular online formats and their liberal ideological origins.

The Political Compass

Memes, grids and other political models are powerful ideological frames. Memetic diagrams, such as the political compass, horseshoe theory, fishhook theory, or even a 3D mobius strip of infinite hot takes, are all rudimentary tools that seek to impart a basic idea. Their power comes from their ability to reduce complex philosophical problems into simple visual solutions. While they may often appear silly and dismissable, their influence should not be underestimated. 

The political compass is the most widely used ideological diagram on today’s internet. (If you’re reading this newsletter you are undoubtedly already familiar with this format.) The X-axis maps a spectrum of Left to Right, along conventional notions of collective to private ownership. The Y-axis maps Authoritarianism to Libertarianism and asks; what is the appropriate role of the state? This shitpost meme, mostly used by edgelord teenagers, has a deep history that is not commonly known.

In 1968, the summer issue of the Rampart Journal of Individualist Thought published a remarkable article; “The Political Spectrum: A Bi-Dimensional Approach”. Responding to a piece from an earlier issue in 1967, authors Maurice Bryson and William McDill grapple with the limitations of a traditional “Left - Right” political spectrum. On a two dimensional graph, right-wing ideas like fascism and libertarianism appear visually close to one another while left-wing positions like anarchism and communism are similarly clustered to the opposite side. The two dimensional political spectrum fails to differentiate important distinctions on the poles and is unable to represent the alleged similarities between totalitarian philosophies. In an attempt to map these various political positions, the authors propose this diagram:

From these humble beginnings, a drawing published in a niche intellectual journal nearly 60 years ago, the diagram has grown to become the most widely distributed political meme of the modern era. Today it exists in almost every country and has been translated into every major language. It now proliferates at a scale that would have been unimaginable to its creators.

I first stumbled across this article while searching the archives of the Mises Institute. If you’re not familiar, Ludwig Von Mises is the Austrian economist who wrote Economic Calculation in the Socialist Commonwealth. In the western canon, this text is widely regarded as the critical work that discredits the feasibility of economic planning. Mises was a lifelong adherent of neoliberal ideology. He was among the founding members of the Mont Pelerin Society in Europe. Today the eponymous institute exists to educate the public and to spread free market ideas. (Spoiler alert: they are also friendly with a lot of racist guys – crazy, I know!)

In 1969, David Nolan, an American libertarian activist, created “The Nolan Chart”, a streamlined and more graphic designed XY grid of political positions. In 1970, Nolan adapted this image into a playful multiple choice game called “The World’s Smallest Political Quiz”. The ten step questionnaire would gauge your responses and use these measurements to locate you at certain coordinates along the XY grid. This catchy meme was commonly handed out as take-away literature at libertarian meetups. Fittingly, in 1971, Nolan became a founding member of the libertarian party in the United States.

In 2001, the website politicalcompass.org went live and has since seeped into every imaginable online subculture. 

Importantly, the design of the Political Compass is meant to individuate and atomize quiz takers. Its purpose is to visually illustrate the minute differences between members of any potential coalition. Rather than grouping like-minded subjects into a similar zone, it has the implicit effect of magnifying the small differences between people who are relatively closely aligned. The organizational unit of this meme is the individual. Its intended purpose is to break apart solidarities among those who might otherwise work together. It’s a powerful ideological frame that's been working for more than half a century.

“Horseshoe Theory”

The so-called “Horseshoe Theory” of politics periodically resurfaces on the internet. Horseshoe theory is the mistaken idea that the left and right ends of the political spectrum bend inwards toward each other. This model, visualized as a U shape, suggests that the far left and far right are; ‘not so different after all – haha I am very intelligent’. (I’m sure you know this type of guy.) It's a catchy bit of propaganda that still circulates widely. Like all things on the internet, this meme has rapidly degraded into nonsensical posts. Meme makers both parody and endorse the framework while propelling the idea to new audiences.

The horseshoe theory diagram retrofits the conventional “Left to Right” spectrum, mapped along an X axis, over an unlabeled but implicit Y axis of “Individualism to Collectivism”. In doing so, it attempts to collapse the important distinctions between the different collectivities proposed by the right and left. 

Right-wing collectivities, such as the nation, are drawn from myth and metaphysical structures. The nation, as a supposed historical subject, is a memetic and highly transmittable idea. It attempts to create a narrative consensus amongst a large group of people and seeks to mobilize material forces to reify this mutually agreed upon fiction.

Meanwhile, Left-wing collectivities, i.e. class, are grounded in an analysis of the real world. The working class, the actual subject of history, is the source of society’s wealth and the force that moves history forward. Whether or not these workers agree on the narrative premise of a “nation” does not affect their role as the creators of value. The material world is not up for debate as to whether it is fact or fiction. There are workers without nations but there are no nations without workers.

These theoretical frameworks are mutually exclusive and incompatible. Only one can be correct. The power of the horseshoe theory meme is that it skillfully conflates these ideas and stalls us from differentiating the underlying concepts.

Alternatively, liberal political philosophy would posit the individual as its own historical subject. While discussions around the horseshoe theory meme tend to focus on the alleged similarities between right and left collectivities, they tend to omit its most important claim. Horseshoe theory frames individualism as its “center” or default position. The seed of this idea was planted over 80 years ago.

Friedrich Hayek was a founding theorist and economist behind the political ideology known as neoliberalism. Neoliberalism kicked off in 1947 with the inaugural meeting of the Mont Pelerin society in Switzerland. At that time, liberals faced the actually-existing threat of European fascism and Soviet communism. The neoliberals sought to safeguard liberty and market freedoms through an international order of private property. Their vision was global in scale but organized around the philosophical unit of the sovereign individual.

The Road to Serfdom, published a few years earlier in 1944, is widely regarded as Hayek’s masterwork. In this canonical text, he argues that centralized forms of government necessarily lack the information and decision making power of decentralized markets. For Hayek, prices represented the sum total of human wants and needs. He claims that the irreducible complexity of the market meant that it could not be “out-thought” because no individual economic planner could have access to all the world’s information. 

In Hayek’s view, any centralized entity, including Soviet-style central planning, fascist nationalization of industry, or even meager social democratic welfare states, would inevitably result in severe economic crashes when they attempted to intervene in the market. In his book, Hayek argues that in order to maintain power, these states would inevitably be forced to conscript citizens into involuntary labor and ultimately into servitude. In The Road to Serfdom, we find the origins of this familiar liberal argument; any hierarchical social formation, whether from left or right, must inevitably lead to the same authoritarianism.

The horseshoe theory meme is a comedic restatement of Hayek’s nearly century old vision that has recently been reformatted for today’s social media. It's an attempt to collapse the distinctions between all collectivities and to further an underlying neoliberal philosophy. It's not a new idea that just popped up on the internet – it’s some old school boomer propaganda. 

Posting: An Infantile Disorder

The purpose of analyzing these popular images is to better understand the ideological frames that encase today’s political discourse. Often, posters on the left will try to remix and spin off these meme formats with the hopes to brand new political movements and to further spread their ideas. But if we choose to accept these underlying neoliberal frames, we have already conceded to the dominance of their ideas. 

What would a memetic diagram that took the working class as its “center” or default position look like? I have some of my own ideas but I’d like to see yours as well.

The great irony of our political era is that the total victory of global neoliberalism has demonstrated the exact opposite of what mid-century theorists sought to advance. Rather than a planetary-scale system of prices and markets, the largest and most efficient corporations deploy economic planning on a scale that is geographically larger and more productive than the height of the Soviet Union. Transnational entities such as Google, Amazon and Walmart have realized the synthesis of the Cold War dichotomy in a way that must have Hayek rolling in his grave. But if we keep thinking within neoliberal diagrams and posting their old memes, we may never escape their ideological frame.

If you want to share some original drawings and diagrams in the comments, I’ll watch this thread and reply!

Files

Comments

ploob!

Oh gawd, the flags

RanCarter

I think the main problem with how most people see politics nowadays is the linear, polarised, adversarial framing. You can't say anything nowadays without people making huge sweeping assumptions about your political stance which you then have to waste time and effort defending yourself from. You'd think that the idea of people being able to understand political takes as a diffuse, contradictory web with various ideas and ideologies as a basis was 'too complicated' until you consider how basically everyone has encyclopedic knowledge of some fictional universe or another, or some celebrity beef. We've been stewing in the 'good vs evil' narrative for so long now that I feel we're just going to have to ride it out rather than try to convince anyone that any nuance or historical context exists in the world. I hope any of this makes any sense, I'm sorry I wrote this while nurturing a hangover.

BeanCurd

I completely agree that these diagrams are ideologically reproducing neoliberalism. They foreclose the idea that politics might allow us to think about the world entirely differently and bring about massive (dare I say, revolutionary) change. The irony is that "left" and "right" emerged from seating arrangements at the National Assembly during the French Revolution, which was decidedly NOT a spectrum. This original use of left-right was much more Schmittian in its conception of politics: either you were on one side or the other; you were a friend of the revolution or its enemy. I can't help but think this (relatively) newer x-y axis way of understanding political identity is yet another way everything is being datafied. It's just as debased as identifying as your credit score or your IQ.

Angel Reed

Honestly with the way the world is churnin and burnin these days, my perfect memetic diagram would be the spinner from the game Twister. Just write in different ideologies for each color or appendage. Then spin baby spin! I know, it’s typical of me to avoid reinventing the wheel (pun intended?), but the Twister spinner is immediately where my mind went. And no, you’ll never have to tag two friends to get a free tattoo / send to five friends in twenty-four hours or you will die in seven days. Just flick the spinner to activate your new political compass! Spice it up with a best out of three spins! On a more serious note, I really appreciate you delving into the power of memes/memetic diagrams. I love memes as much as the next guy. However I’m not naive to the cultural hold and relevance they have brought to the internet age and how quickly these memes saturate with each share or like other commenters have stated ‘reproduce ideologies’. One type of meme that sticks with me is the “Change my mind” meme with YouTube’s Steven Crowder. Now, it’s known he is a scumbag abuser (didn’t see that coming *sarcasm*). But then, folks could just easily create a meme with his “Change my mind” pattern. And admittedly, even now, you can still create that knowing the guys a scumbag abuser, but you’d be late to the trend. Just one way I remind myself that sure memes are funny but they can be powerful and even monetized. We see it with TikTok trends, dances, and music snip-bits. Different medium, sure. We all saw how Kamala’s BRAT 2025 went… I appreciate your discourse and contribution, Joshua. Pardon the lack of brevity.

Bill Vog

Good stuff. Love these posts. The guest writers are always great

Max Schweiger

Do we really think that the form of the internet meme is capable of the revolutionary purpose your call-to-action implies? If posting is an infantile disorder, can posting be the cure?

Max Schweiger

Even if we re-base our memes to have 'worker-centrist' structures, in my view, Materialist analysis is -- never was -- about public opinion or changing minds. Ultimately, it's about feeding people, no matter what they think, right? and therefore it's definitively not about changing minds? We can expose the truth, but we can't force-feed it to people, or lie or obfuscate to make them learn. Maybe every online meme is a reduction of the truth and therefore in some way a lie. Personally, I think we're having even this conversation in enemy territory. I don't recognize any meaningful political coalitions that formed (or even function entirely) online. At least not revolutionarily successful ones. The idea of a better meme being the solution just feels too convenient for me to not be suspicious of it, no matter how different the better meme is. I think the effective work is still being done in person, in conversation, in meetings, not online or through ANY media for that matter.