Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Happy December. December is always my favorite because it is the only real romantic winter month, it's all kind of downhill after the first week of February. In January, you can trick yourself into tolerating most everything thanks to the eternal return of New Year delusional optimism. February is just a slide into March, when the madness really sets in, before we all grow bitter from April's false hope. So December it is. It is important to savor December's wintry mix while we can still forestall the reality of time and, you know, bake a bunch of cookies, cakes, little pies, roasts and do all our basic bitch holiday rituals. It's been fun but also personally annoying to watch everyone collectively obsess over Martha, only because she was an extremely important object for me as a child. I used to have to steal away my aunt's issues of LIVING during Thanksgiving and Christmas and it's around the holidays that my spectre of Martha looms large. Anyway, that's a personal matter. If you love something, let it go ....

ELONGEIST 

I think about Elon Musk way more than any self-respecting person should. Last week, Brace wrote that he could see traces of him everywhere, "leaking out all over the world like the yellow bile of an exploding kidney." Gross. He's right. I see him everywhere, in everything. It's Reddit now to say that Elon is Reddit, but at one point that felt like an accurate description. I'm not so sure anymore. There's a sort of chicken or the egg situation with Elon. Is he leaving his mark on us or have we left our mark on him?

I close my eyes and I see him: part man, part machine. His heart pumps memes into his blood-feed; his eyes scroll, he wets his lips; his body is slick, seamless; he doesn't think, he enjoys. He ingests and spits back out half-digested content. He's a human algorithm, a solipsistic loop of slop. Elon is a product of the internet but the internet is product of all of us. America made him and now he's remaking America in his image. In AI models, this type of recursive generation produces distortions to the point of collapse. But let's not get our hopes up.

Not that Elon collapsing would be a good thing for America. We got into this a little bit in the Tesla series, though I'll admit at that point I still hoped there was a point of safe return. Looking back through our old notes from those episodes, it felt like Tesla was a way to unlock something essential about the American economy: taking over a company and remaking it in your own twisted image, leveraging state tax credits into production theater just to facilitate securitization and lever up on the stock market through social media pumped vol plays and an MLM populist-affiliate network. Whew. It's almost quaint now that fully maturated markets are structured similarly, whether it's the various appendages of the social media influence machine or microblogging networks, obviously crypto. Theres even a new book coming out on a similar phenomenon. Tesla really is everything. I have this from our old notes:

At this moment, the Middle-Class-Tesla-Owner subject arises out of the awakening of social media and its attendant revenue networks. These wars between the bulls and the bears, the shorts and the longs, play out on cable financial news networks and blogs and among social influencers driven by their own fantasies of big clout paydays. The polarization of these factions and the ensuing content mine are a necessary byproduct of the drive for cheap profits. The volatility, whether in the financial or content marketplaces, is what fuels the quick gains. It's a dizzying cacophonous symphony orchestrated by a truly phenomenal maestro, each successive movement crescendos into larger and larger payouts—so long as the band can keep playing on.

Even I must admit that he's basically figured it all out. Tesla is still doing weird shit and it doesn't matter. Elon hacked the system and generated a self-reinforcing valuation loop. Tesla's most profitable product is its stock and the stocks most valuable asset is Elon. Warren Buffet, but slopified. And now $TSLA has institutional protection, guardian angels in the form of asset management stewards with their own agendas in maintaining the stock price and overseeing the world's capital flows.

This is why Elon's highly cultivated image of 20th century industrialist never sat right with me. It's the kind of unsettling anachronism an AI image generator would produce, an exquisite corpse reanimated by the psychotic collective prayers of a decadent middle class. Kamala is a capital L Loser but she was right to say We Are Not Going Back. There is no RVTRN. But the dirty secret about fantasy is that it is productive and Elon's outmoded Fordist appearance in part smuggles in the disturbing reality of highly socialized forms of capital developing underneath the surface.

I'm talking about the Big Three: BlackRock, Vanguard and State Street. In 2008, these management firms fused to the central bank so completely that, not unlike the human centipede, it is impossible to tell where Larry Fink begins and Jay Powell ends. Structurally speaking. The big asset management companies' scale and breadth of investment allocation requires them to take the reins of the totality of the system, steering and steadying the ship. They are extremely risk adverse but play with active hands. Corporate tax breaks are middle class electoral coalition bribes, prosciutto money for world-system movers. They need to ensure macro conditions remain steady because their portfolio—which is to say our portfolio, the state, the capitalist system in total—thinks in centuries. I said Big Three, but it's wrong not to include JPMC here. Word is that Jamie Dimon has been on the phone with Trump nightly since the election. Patriots in control.

PORTBOU

I recently had occasion to make the pilgrimage to Portbou, the tiny Spanish seaside town on the border of France where Walter Benjamin killed himself. He was buried there, or was buried there at one point, in an arrestingly beautiful cemetery, high up on the hill of the town, overlooking the Balearic sea. The graves are stacked up on terraces, ensconced in sun-bleached concrete like a freezer, facing outwards toward the water. I say was buried because I think it's unclear what happened to his body. When Hannah Arendt visited the site a few months after Benjamin's death, she wrote to Gershom Scholem that it was "one of the most fantastic and beautiful spots I have ever seen in my life" but that Benjamin's grave was nowhere to be found. Henry Gurland, Benjamin's fellow traveler, supposedly paid the little Catholic Church for the gravesite for five years, but that didn't seem to take. Benjamin wrote Gurland the night he killed himself, a heart wrenching letter that is reproduced at the site:

In a situation with no way out, I have no other choice but to make an end of it. It is in a small village in the Pyrenees, where no one knows me, that my life will come to a close. I ask you to give my regards to my friend Adorno and to explain to him the situation in which I find myself placed. There is not enough time left for me to write all the letters I should have wished to write.

In lieu of an actual grave, a large stone was placed at the end of a cemetery row, where visitors have placed little stones and plastic flowers next to a plaque that reads WALTER BENJAMIN BERLIN, 1892 — PORTBOU, 1940 along with a line from the 7th Thesis on the Philosophy of History, in both the original German and site-specific Catalan (but here in English, from Illuminations):

There is no document of civilization which is not at the same time a document of barbarism.

There is also a memorial itself, completed in 1994, a steel box wedged into the side of a cliff called Passage, a Homage to Walter Benjamin. I was surprised, though I shouldn't have been, at how moving it was. Housed inside the steel box is a steep staircase that takes you down maybe fifteen feet. It's a lonely walk, really built just for one, and you descend the stairs in relative darkness until the whole thing opens up and light breaks in and you approach a glass plane revealing the crashing waves below.

The etching on the glass reads:

It is more difficult to honor the anonymous than the renowned. Historical construction is devoted to the memory of the anonymous. Walter Benjamin, On the Concept of History (1940)

An odd feature of the Portbou experience is that every marker is more Benjaminian imprint than artifact: you can't visit the actual grave of Benjamin and you also can't visit the actual site of his death. It was a hotel, now a private residence, and there's only a little plaque featuring a truly adorable pair of glasses to mark the site for religious-types like ourselves, but that's about it. I was trying to find the actual address of the place, which was a bit of an absurd task in a town of a bout six or seven winding cobblestone streets, and I came across a brief from CatalanNews.com: Portbou, in the years since the Schengen Agreement and the establishment of free movement throughout Europe, is having a hard time attracting tourists to the historic border town, now rendered geographically and politically useless. In a bid to draw them in, a local musician wanted to set up a Walter Benjamin Escape Experience, "similar to an escape room but lasting 24 hours and including accommodation, dinner and breakfast." The release goes on to say that "the aim is to escape Portbou and help Walter Benjamin do so, amid Francoists and Nazis."

The whole thing is set up to reproduce the curious moment Walter Benjamin found himself in, a tragedy of history he couldn't escape. Benjamin left Marseille by train in September 1940 trying to get out of France with his final manuscript in tow. The plan was to escape via the Pyrenees, through Spain to Portugal but without an exit visa from Vichy governed France, crossing the border would be impossible. Along with Joseph and Henry Gurland, Benjamin met up with Lisa and Hans Fittko, German anti-Nazis who were helping the group escape. They needed to get to Portbou, but the main road was managed by German soldiers and so they had to hike down the rugged vineyard cliffs of Banyuls to reach the crossing. It's here that the image of Walter Benjamin slowly treading down the rocky mediterranean coastline, with his little glasses and his heart condition and his heavy, overflowing attaché, spilling out the pages of the posthumously published Arcades Project, is comically heartbreaking.

When they finally reached Portbou they found the Spanish had, for unknown reasons, closed the border. The crew was told they would be forcibly returned to France the next day. Benjamin's heart couldn't take it so he turned to morphine. Hannah Arendt noted the historically-specific timing, writing "one day earlier Benjamin would have got through without any trouble; one day later the people in Marseille would have known that for the time being it was impossible to pass through Spain. Only on that particular day was the catastrophe possible." The day after his death, the Spanish reopened the border.

Free movement in Europe followed agreements on free trade, treaties themselves a part of the integration of the continent that sprung out of the political crisis of World War II. Today, when you pass through the border from Spain to France, there's nothing but a small sign on the side of the road to mark it. What is a border town when there are no borders?

That Benjamin is memorialized in the place of his death makes sense; that he is memorialized in that town which is now completely unmoored by the developments of history, left to impotently reenact its significance as the crucible of his death, makes me cry.

See you next year.

Yours,

Liz.

Files

Comments

Matt Jolo

Elon is a finance giant. The bigger they are the harder they fall.

ruby

Liz 🫶🏻 thank you

Bill Vog

This was a lovely read. Thoroughly enjoyed

carts

what a nice little Angelus

Iwan Heneghan

I visited Berlin for the first time in April last year and went to check out the Walter Benjamin archive as my own kind of ‘pilgrimage’. It was closed, lol, it was very anticlimactic. Don’t know what I expected anyway it isn’t like a museum. Very moving tribute, I’d never seen that text where he asked to pass on his regards to Adorno before, thanks

jay alan

That was lovely. Happy holidays Liz. ❄️

.

Thank you Liz

Shaggy

Happy trails, Mom.

Egg B

Loved this one. Crackpots is a highlight of my week, I read it aloud to my boyfriend and this one was really nice to hear out loud.

Shiv

Merci, Liz and happiest of holidays. It’s at least a comfort to know I am not alone in thinking about Elon more than a person should - tho it increasingly feels warranted! 🥧 🍰 🌲 🍪

A Kalman

that was really lovely Liz, thank you.

Pelican Grief

Is Jamie Dimon giving Trump microdoses of the Ned Beatty Network speech every night before bed?

Antipaganda

No port-boos from this reader. Lovely.

Dym

Thank you Liz, that was lovely

Tom Clarke

That was lovely. And unusually I have something moderately relevant to comment. You may have heard it already but Dan and Kasia of Cursed Objects - a very good podcast - did an episode about Portbou and Walter Benjamin. You can listen to it here: https://www.patreon.com/posts/bonus-episode-69883586 Hope you had a good time in Catalonia.

Tim Gorin

Beautiful piece. Thanks for sharing it.

Will Camfield

Thank you for this bittersweet treat. I very much enjoyed reading it.

JB

Incredibly moving, even third hand. Thank you liz.

James Kent

Thanks Liz, fantastic. I was there too this year. Had a similar experience to you looking for the hotel, and was especially moved by the memorial. My gf and I actually did the walk/hike across the Pyrenees with our young son in a special hiking backpack for kids (lol). It was fairly straightforward with some tough parts, but I found the whole day profoundly moving. The swim at the end felt remarkable.