Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

All characters in this story are over 18 years of age.

Previous part here

My Horny College Roommate Asked to Rate My Cock

Cody was still standing in front of me, naked, relaxed after his orgasm, wearing that shameless smile like he'd just won some kind of game whose rules I still didn't completely understand.

I was still close to him. Too close to pretend that after everything that had happened, I could simply stand up, fix my clothes, and go back to a normal day. Especially since normal had stopped existing somewhere around the moment Cody told me to get on my knees.

His eyes moved lower.

To my shorts.

He didn't have to look for long. The fabric was stretched so obviously that denying anything would have been pathetic.

"Looks like I wasn't the only one enjoying that review," he said.

I felt heat rise to my face, but this time I didn't try to back away.

"A cock like that makes an impression."

Cody's smile widened.

"Then maybe now I should rate yours."

For a moment, I genuinely wasn't sure I'd heard him correctly.

I'd fantasized about plenty of things since Cody walked into my room with his bag and that calm, shameless look in his eyes. But fantasies were safe. You could keep them in your head. You could pretend they didn't exist.

And Cody had just said it out loud.

"You want to rate mine?" I asked, because I needed to hear the answer again.

Cody shrugged like it was the most logical thing in the world.

"Fair is fair. You rated mine with your eyes, your hand, and your mouth."

His gaze dropped to my shorts again.

"I can at least start with the first two."

The word "start" hit me almost as hard as everything else.

He wasn't talking about his mouth yet.

Not now.

But he'd left the idea hanging between us like a promise that might come back later.

"Cody," I said quietly.

"What?"

He looked at me calmly, but he didn't touch me. He didn't reach for my shorts. He didn't make the decision for me.

He waited.

And that somehow made it even more intense.

"If you want this," he said.

I was breathing harder than I should have been.

"I do."

Cody tilted his head, satisfied.

"Then show me what I'm supposed to rate."

I slowly stood up.

Suddenly, I realized this felt completely different from looking at Cody. He'd had that shameless ease about him from the beginning. He stood naked in front of the mirror, let me rate him, touch him, taste him, as if his body were something he could share without any weight attached to it.

I was aware of every movement I made.

First, I grabbed the bottom of my shirt and pulled it over my head. Cody watched closely, no jokes now. Then I unfastened my shorts. The fabric slid down my hips, and for a second I stood in front of him wearing nothing but my boxers, so hard there was no hiding it.

Cody looked at me and smiled slightly.

"Okay," he said. "You were hiding more than I thought."

"I wasn't hiding anything."

"You had shorts on. That counts."

I snorted quietly, but the sound caught in my throat when I pulled my boxers down.

My cock sprang free, completely hard, with a small drop at the tip. I stood completely naked in front of Cody while his eyes moved over me slowly, without any hurry. He wasn't looking by accident. He wasn't sneaking glances.

He was rating me just as directly as I'd rated him earlier.

And it affected me more than I'd expected.

Cody stepped closer, but still didn't touch me.

First, he looked.

At my chest. My stomach. My hips. Then lower, at what was waiting between my thighs.

"You're harder than I expected," he said.

I was breathing heavily.

"You just came in my mouth. What did you expect?"

Cody looked me in the eyes and smiled wider.

"Good answer."

He stopped right in front of me. He was still naked, still relaxed after his own orgasm, but there was something new in his expression now.

Curiosity.

The same kind I'd had earlier.

Only now I was the one being judged.

"All right," he said slowly. "Visually, this is already interesting."

I swallowed.

"Only interesting?"

Cody looked down again.

"Good length. Thicker than I expected. Nice shape. And a very sensitive head, if that drop means anything."

I could feel my body reacting to every word.

Cody noticed.

"Oh yeah," he murmured. "Rating you is going to be interesting."

Cody stood so close in front of me that I could feel the heat from his body.

He still wasn't touching me.

And that was the worst part.

His eyes moved over me slowly, stopping exactly where I wanted to feel his hand. He knew I could see him looking. He also knew that just watching me was making me even more worked up.

Finally, he lifted his eyes to my face.

"Can I?"

One short question.

And yet it hit harder than anything he'd said before.

"Yes," I answered immediately.

Cody smiled slightly and wrapped his hand around me.

I sucked in a breath through my teeth.

His touch was confident but not fast. At first, he simply held me, like he was checking the weight and hardness. Then he slowly moved his hand upward until his thumb brushed the head.

"Warm," he said quietly. "Hard. Really hard."

I didn't know why, but hearing him say it was almost as arousing as the touch itself.

He moved his hand again, slower this time. He watched me closely as he did it, like my face was part of the review.

"Good shape," he added. "Feels good in my hand. And you react faster than I expected."

"Kind of hard not to react when you talk like that."

Cody laughed softly.

"That's useful too. A good review needs reactions."

He dragged his thumb over the tip, smearing the drop of precum that had collected there. That one movement hit me so hard that I had to put a hand on his shoulder.

"Fuck, Cody."

His smile widened.

"I'm counting that as positive feedback."

He started moving his hand more confidently, but still not in a way that would bring me to the edge too quickly.

He was testing me.

Figuring out what pressure made my fingers tighten against his skin. What kind of movement made my breath catch in my throat. How I reacted when he slowed down around the head and when he gripped me more firmly near the base.

"Okay," he said after a moment. "Now I get it."

"What?"

He looked me in the eyes, still moving his hand along my cock.

"Why you liked rating me so much."

I couldn't answer.

Because he was right.

And now, standing naked in front of him, hard and being evaluated by his hand, I was beginning to understand that Cody didn't just like being watched.

He liked seeing what his touch did to another guy.

Cody continued the review like he had something in front of him he genuinely wanted to remember.

His hand moved over me slowly, sometimes firmer, sometimes lighter, always with the same careful attention. He didn't rush. He didn't try to make me come right away.

It was more like he was testing how much he could get out of me with nothing but rhythm, pressure, and that calm stare.

"Visually," he said after a moment, "very good."

I was breathing heavily.

"And by touch?"

Cody tightened his grip a little more and moved his hand downward until I felt his fingers near the base.

"Even better. Feels good in my hand."

I closed my eyes for a second.

It was ridiculous. Cody was talking about my cock like he was genuinely reviewing it, and I reacted to every word as if he'd chosen them specifically to break me down.

Maybe that was exactly what he was doing.

"And you're very easy to read," he added.

I opened my eyes.

"What?"

He slowly moved his thumb across the head.

My hips twitched before I could stop them.

Cody smiled.

"See? That's what I'm talking about."

"Are you planning to torture me like this?"

"No. I'm being thorough."

His hand sped up only slightly.

It was enough for me to feel the tension gathering lower in my body, stronger and harder to hide with every movement. I put my other hand on his shoulder and tightened my fingers against his skin.

Cody looked at the drop that had appeared on the tip again.

"That helps with the review too."

"Cody..."

"What?"

"If you keep doing that, I'm going to come."

And then he slowed down.

I almost groaned in frustration.

"Why did you stop?"

Cody didn't take his hand away completely. He still held me, but without moving, deliberately leaving me right on the edge.

"Because I'm not done with the review yet."

I looked at him, trying to catch my breath.

"What else is left?"

His gaze dropped to the head of my cock, then returned to my face.

"The same category you rated on me."

I knew immediately.

And yet I still asked.

"Taste?"

Cody smiled calmly.

"Exactly."

My heart beat harder.

He moved his thumb through the wet drop, but instead of taking me any further, he slowly let go.

"You rated mine," he said. "So now I want to know what yours tastes like."

Next Part

Comments

Patrick

So fucking hot.