The Hot Stranger I Met on Halloween | E8 (Patreon)
Content
All characters in this story are over 18 years of age.
Previous part here
We Finally Got to Fuck James
For a moment, I thought maybe we'd gone too far.
James was silent, and suddenly I could feel my heart beating harder. All I could see in my head was his body. Broad shoulders, powerful chest, abs, thighs, and that perfect ass that hadn't left my mind since the first time I'd really noticed it.
Finally, James smiled slowly.
"Sure."
John and I froze.
"Really?" I asked before I could stop myself.
James laughed quietly.
"After everything we've done? You think I don't want to feel both of you?"
That hit me harder than anything before.
James didn't look embarrassed. He didn't back away. He didn't lose his confidence. He simply looked at us like he'd known from the beginning that the night was going to end exactly this way.
Then he turned around and slowly got onto all fours on the bed.
The sight almost took my breath away.
Broad back, narrow waist, powerful thighs, and that ass pushed directly toward us. The same one we'd licked whipped cream from. The same one I'd been staring at for days with a thought I hadn't had the courage to say out loud.
John looked at me.
"You first?"
I shook my head, even though it cost me more than I wanted to admit.
"No. You first. I had him in my mouth first."
John swallowed and smiled nervously.
"Thanks."
James looked back over his shoulder.
"Then come here, John."
John moved behind James.
I could immediately tell he was trying to look confident, but his hands gave everything away. They were a little too careful, a little too tense as he reached for the lube. This was completely different from everything that had happened before. Until now, James had been the one leading. James had opened each new door. James had been the one telling us what we could do.
Now John was the one who had to touch him.
James looked back over his shoulder.
"Don't rush."
John nodded.
"Okay."
I sat beside them, my heart beating too fast, and watched.
John spread the lube over his fingers, then started by touching James on the outside, slowly and carefully. James let out a quiet breath but didn't pull away. Just the opposite. His hips moved slightly backward, as if he wanted to show John that he could keep going.
"You okay?" John asked.
"Yeah," James said. "Keep going."
John gained a little confidence.
He prepared him patiently, lightly at first, then deeper, constantly watching James's reactions. I could see James's back tense at a firmer touch, his hands tightening in the sheets, the way this confident man had to slow his breathing for the first time that night just to keep control.
It was incredible.
James was still James. Strong, calm, beautiful. But now he was taking John. Letting him lead. And the sight made me hard all over again.
After a while, James said quietly,
"Okay. Try. Slowly."
John swallowed, applied more lube to his cock, and positioned himself behind him. For a second, he just stared at James's perfect ass like he couldn't believe he really had the chance.
Then he started pushing in.
Slowly.
James tensed immediately, so John stopped, exactly the way he should have. He placed a hand on James's hip and waited.
"More," James said after a moment.
John pushed deeper.
This time, James let out a heavier breath and lowered his head. John looked like his whole body had suddenly understood what he was doing. He was entering the man he'd thought was an unreal fantasy only a short time ago.
"Yeah," James murmured. "Just like that. You're doing it right."
John started moving.
Slowly at first, carefully, visibly focused. Then with more confidence. His hands found James's hips, the rhythm became deeper, and I sat beside them watching, feeling like I was going to lose my mind from impatience.
John became less careful with every movement.
At first, each thrust was deliberate, almost uncertain, as if he still couldn't believe James was kneeling in front of him on the bed. But the longer he moved, the more his body took over. His hands tightened more firmly on James's hips, his breathing became heavier, and his movements became deeper.
James didn't tell him to slow down.
Just the opposite.
He pushed his hips slightly backward, taking him more confidently, as if he wanted to show him he really wanted it. His back tensed with every harder thrust, and his hands gripped the sheets.
"Yeah," James murmured. "Just like that."
I sat beside them watching, my throat dry with arousal.
It wasn't bad jealousy. I didn't want to interrupt John. I didn't want to take the moment away from him. But seeing his cock moving into James's perfect ass made every second of waiting feel too long.
John moaned quietly.
"James..." he forced out. "I'm gonna come."
I expected him to pull out.
John probably did too.
But James looked back over his shoulder, his face tense with pleasure and his voice lower than before.
"Don't pull out."
John froze.
"What?"
"Come inside me."
For a second, nobody moved.
I felt my whole body react to those words. John looked at me with wide eyes like he needed confirmation that he'd really heard them.
James moved his hips slightly backward.
"I want to feel it," he said.
That broke John.
His hands tightened on James's hips, his movements becoming shorter, faster, more desperate. A few seconds later, he came inside him with a broken moan, his whole body folding forward. He dropped against James's back, breathing heavily, shaky and stunned.
I watched, unable to move.
James took him with his face lowered toward the sheets, breathing just as heavily.
After a moment, John slowly pulled away, still trembling.
I couldn't take it anymore.
"Okay," I said, moving closer. "My turn."
James looked back at me over his shoulder.
His smile was tired, flushed, and absolutely shameless.
"Yeah, Matt," he said quietly. "Your turn."
I moved behind James and just looked at him for a moment.
John shifted to the side, still shaken by what he'd just done. He lay on the bed breathing heavily, watching me the way I'd been watching him before. I was kneeling behind James now, with his perfect ass right in front of me, warm, relaxed, and ready.
I took the lube.
I didn't want to rush, even though my whole body was screaming at me to finally feel him for real. I put more on my fingers and ran my hand between his cheeks. James shivered slightly but didn't move away. Just the opposite. He pushed his hips back a little.
"Yeah," he said quietly. "Just like that."
I prepared him again, carefully but more confidently than John had. I already knew James really wanted this. I knew he wasn't just letting us enter him. He wanted it himself. Then I rubbed some lube onto my cock.
After a moment, I positioned myself behind him.
My heart was pounding so hard that for a second, I could hear nothing but my own breathing.
Only a few days earlier, I'd been standing outside his door asking for candy. Then I'd seen him in a towel. Touched him. Taken him into my mouth. Licked whipped cream from his ass. Felt him fuck me in this same bedroom.
And now I was about to enter him.
I pressed against him slowly.
James lowered his head and tightened his hands in the sheets.
I started pushing in.
Just a little at first. His body was warm, tight, and so intense that I had to stop after the first movement. James let out a heavy breath but didn't say stop.
"Keep going," he murmured.
I pushed deeper.
John moaned quietly beside me as he watched. James's breathing became heavier, and I could feel him slowly taking all of me. When I was finally deep inside him, I leaned over him, my hands holding his hips.
"James..." I whispered.
"Move, Matt."
That was enough.
I started slowly, with long movements, feeling him from beginning to end. Then with more confidence. James pushed his hips back as if he wanted more, and every short breath he let out took away another piece of my control.
"Yeah," he said quietly. "Show me how badly you wanted this."
I sped up.
I held him more firmly, moving deeper, faster, more desperately. John watched from beside us, touching my shoulder as if he wanted to be part of that final moment. Everything that had happened since the first knock on the door seemed to gather inside me all at once.
"James," I moaned. "I'm gonna come too."
He didn't hesitate.
"Only fair," he said heavily. "You too. Inside me."
That broke me.
I came hard inside him, collapsing against his back, my breathing broken and my body completely drained. John placed a hand on my back, while James breathed heavily beneath us, flushed and calm.
Afterward, we collapsed together onto the bed.
For a moment, nobody said anything.
Then James laughed softly.
"You know Halloween only comes once a year, right?"
I looked at him, exhausted and happy.
"That's a shame."
James smiled.
"My door doesn't."
I looked at John, then at James.
And I knew it was the best house I'd ever knocked on.