The Hot Stranger I Met on Halloween | E7 (Patreon)
Content
All characters in this story are over 18 years of age.
Previous part here
We Went Back for More Than Dessert.
The next evening, John and I walked to James's house without any excuse.
There was no candy anymore. No costumes. No pretending it was an accident or some stupid Halloween joke that had gotten out of control. We both knew why we were going there.
And that was exactly why every step felt heavier.
All day, I couldn't stop thinking about his words.
"The kind where whipped cream alone won't be enough."
He hadn't said exactly what he meant. He didn't have to. After he'd licked our asses in his bedroom, after he'd seen us hot, relaxed, and hard on his bed, everything was too obvious.
John walked beside me, trying to joke.
"If he pulls out the whipped cream again, I'm not complaining."
I laughed, but it came out nervously.
"I don't think I would either."
John looked at me from the side.
"But do you think that's what he meant?"
I didn't answer right away.
I could feel the tension low in my stomach. This wasn't just about wanting to look at him, touch him, or taste him anymore. It was something deeper. Ever since that first night, when I'd seen his cock in the living room, some part of me had wondered what it would feel like to really take him.
Finally, we stopped in front of his door.
I knocked.
James opened almost immediately.
He was wearing only boxers. He stood in the doorway calm and confident, as if he'd known perfectly well that we'd come back. He looked at me, then at John, and smiled slowly.
"Right on time."
He let us inside.
This time, nobody mentioned candy.
I stopped in the living room and asked immediately,
"Yesterday you said you had an idea."
James nodded.
"I do."
John swallowed.
"What kind?"
James looked at both of us for a moment, calm but very direct.
"Yesterday I tasted your asses," he said. "Today I'd like to find out if they're as good as they tasted."
Heat rushed through me.
"You mean..." I started. "Fucking us?"
James nodded.
"Yeah. But only if you both want it. No pressure."
John answered first.
"I want it."
I looked at James.
"I want it too."
James smiled.
"Then come to the bedroom."
Everything in the bedroom felt different from the day before.
Back then, we could still pretend it was just another stage of this strange Halloween game. Whipped cream, laughter, dessert, jokes that let us avoid saying out loud what we really wanted.
Now there was nothing left to hide.
James closed the door behind us and looked at us calmly.
"Get undressed."
It didn't sound harsh. More like a simple instruction that both of us immediately wanted to follow.
John took off his shirt first, a little too quickly, as if he was afraid that if he started thinking about it, he'd get nervous again. I undressed more slowly, feeling James's eyes on my body. A moment later, we were both standing naked in front of him, hard and visibly tense.
James took off his boxers too.
When his cock slipped free, heavy and already half-hard, I felt the same shock I'd felt the first night. Only this time, I wasn't going to touch it or take it into my mouth.
This time, it was going inside me.
"On the bed," he said. "Both of you."
We climbed onto the sheets and knelt side by side. John was so close that our shoulders almost touched. I could hear his breathing. I could tell he was just as turned on and nervous as I was.
"Me first," I said immediately.
John looked at me.
"Seriously?"
"I knocked on the door."
For a second, he looked like he wanted to argue, but then he exhaled.
"Fine. But I'm next."
James laughed softly.
"You'll both get your turn."
He picked up some lube from the nightstand and stood behind us. I heard the cap click open, then felt the coolness against my skin. He touched me with one hand and John with the other. He spread the lube slowly, without rushing, as if he wanted us to experience the whole thing together from the beginning.
I gripped the sheets.
John hissed quietly beside me.
"Breathe," James said. "I'm not going to rush."
At first, he only touched us on the outside, carefully checking our reactions. Then he started preparing us more deeply, first me, then John, moving back and forth between us so calmly that it felt like he had all night.
"You okay?" he asked.
"Yeah," I answered quickly.
John nodded.
"Yeah."
James's hand settled on my hip.
"All right, Matt," he said. "You're first."
My heart beat so hard that for a moment I couldn't hear anything except my own breathing.
James positioned himself behind me.
I immediately felt the change in the air. Before, there had been his hands, the lube, the preparation, the slow touching I could still think of as a preview. Now I knew the preview was over.
John knelt beside me, quiet and hard, watching from close by. I could feel his eyes on my back, my hips, my face. It should have embarrassed me.
Instead, it turned me on even more.
James placed his hands on my hips.
"Easy," he said. "Slowly."
I felt his cock between my cheeks. He didn't push in right away. First, he slid it against me, spreading the lube, letting me feel the weight, length, and warmth I'd been thinking about since that first night.
I clenched my hands in the sheets.
"Fuck," I whispered.
James leaned slightly over me.
"This is what you wanted, right?"
I didn't answer immediately, because at that exact moment he started pushing in.
Just a little at first.
My body tensed automatically, and my breath caught in my throat. James stopped immediately. One hand stroked my hip while the other held me steady, without rushing.
"Breathe, Matt."
I tried.
Slowly.
When my body finally relaxed, he pushed deeper.
I could feel all of him. His length, his thickness, the slow stretch that was intense but exactly what I'd imagined. Maybe even better.
Now he was really inside me.
"You're taking me well," James murmured.
I moaned before I could stop myself.
John let out a shaky breath beside me.
James started moving.
Slowly at first. Long strokes, pulling almost all the way out before sliding back in so calmly that I could feel every inch from beginning to end. Then a little harder. More confidently. His hands tightened on my hips, and I started responding with my body, pushing back slightly against him.
"Yeah," James said. "Just like that."
With every passing minute, it got easier. My body relaxed around him, and the pleasure began pushing through the tension more and more strongly. John watched from beside us, slowly stroking his own cock, his face full of disbelief.
James sped up.
Not brutally. Controlled. Hard, but in a way that always made me feel like he was guiding me through it rather than just taking what he wanted. Every movement stripped away a little more embarrassment, a little more thought, a little more control.
Eventually, I moaned loudly and dropped my head onto the sheets.
James only slowed down after a few harder thrusts.
Then he pulled out slowly.
I almost protested.
But before I could say anything, I heard his voice.
"Now John."
John looked like he'd been waiting to hear those two words the whole time and was also more afraid of them than anything else.
James moved behind him.
I stayed beside them, still hot, my body remembering every movement I'd just felt. I was breathing heavily, propped up on my hands, watching James place his hands on John's hips.
"Ready?" he asked.
John nodded.
"Yeah."
His voice trembled.
James didn't comment on it. He simply leaned forward and did exactly what he'd done with me. First, he slid his cock slowly between John's cheeks, calmly spreading the lube and letting him feel what was about to happen.
John sucked in a breath.
"Oh fuck."
James paused against him.
"Breathe."
John tried. I could see his back rising and falling, his hands tightening in the sheets, his whole body caught between tension and desire.
Then James started pushing in.
Slowly.
John moaned immediately, louder than I had. His shoulders tensed, his head dropped lower, and I felt a strange rush of arousal watching him experience exactly what I had only moments before.
James stopped after the first push.
"Easy," he said. "You've got time."
John nodded, but didn't answer. He didn't look capable of it.
Only when his body began to relax did James push deeper. John let out a broken sound, and I couldn't take my eyes off him. I watched his face, his tense back, his hands gripping the sheets, and the way he slowly stopped fighting the feeling and started accepting it instead.
James found a rhythm.
Calm at first. Then harder. He held John by the hips and moved with increasing confidence, while John became louder with every passing minute, less embarrassed, more consumed by what was happening to him.
"See?" James murmured. "You just had to relax."
John only moaned.
James sped up.
This time, I could tell he was losing his calm too. His breathing became heavier, his hands tightened more firmly on John's hips, and his movements became shorter, faster, more tense. I knew he was close.
Finally, he pulled out of John and breathed heavily.
"Fuck, guys," he said. "I'm coming."
John and I looked at each other.
"Come on us," I said.
John immediately added,
"Yeah. On us."
James smiled, tense and flushed.
"All right."
We knelt side by side, leaning forward slightly. James stood behind us, and after a few quick strokes, he came on our backs. First, I felt the warmth on my skin, then I saw him leave the same streak across John.
For a moment, all three of us just breathed.
Then James leaned down and lightly kissed my back, right where he'd left his cum. Then he did the same to John.
"You guys are amazing," he said quietly.
"So are you," I replied, still shaking.
John looked at me, then at James. In his eyes, I saw the same thought that had just entered my own head.
"James..." I started.
He looked up.
"What?"
John finished for me.
"Could we fuck you too?"
James looked at us for a second.
Then he smiled slowly.