Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Your 'fireside rankings chat with Edd Straw' is back! In a slightly different form, as Edd takes on the challenge of judging YOUR Monaco Grand Prix driver rankings.

As we mentioned last week, now that Edd's usual Q&A answering various member questions about his post-race rankings has evolved into a new, more detailed podcast in its own right, we wanted to bring you something a little cosier just for the Members' Club.

So here's Edd's first reaction to the Champions' driver rankings we've also started running this season! Listen to hear what Edd makes of the process, how the choices compared to his, and what he disagreed with most.

And for reference, here's how the Champions voted, with Edd's ranking and the difference in brackets. Just to be as clear as possible 'up 2' means the Champions voted the driver higher by two places, 'down 2' would mean they voted the driver lower!

Champions' ranking: Monaco GP

1st Kimi Antonelli (1st - no change)

2nd Lewis Hamilton (4th - up 2)

3rd Pierre Gasly (5th - up 2)

4th Liam Lawson (3rd - down 1)

5th Isack Hadjar (10th - up 5)

6th Max Verstappen (2nd - down 4)

7th Oscar Piastri (9th - up 2)

8th Arvid Lindblad (12th - up 4)

9th Alex Albon (7th - down 2)

10th Fernando Alonso (6th - down 4)

11th Carlos Sainz (8th - down 3)

12th Esteban Ocon (13th - up 1)

13th Lando Norris (11th - down 2)

14th Sergio Perez (15th - up 1)

15th Charles Leclerc (16th - up 1)

16th George Russell (14th - down 2)

17th Nico Hulkenberg (19th - up 2)

18th Franco Colapinto (18th - no change)

19th Gabriel Bortoleto (22nd - up 3)

20th Ollie Bearman (17th - down 3)

21st Valtteri Bottas (20th - down 1)

22nd Lance Stroll (21st - down 1)

Thanks to all the Champions who voted this time: 928pilot, Laura Davis, Vin Narayan, Simon, Johnny Lones, dorynickel, Luke Sherman, Gabriel Buteler, thorarinn Gunnarsson, Shrinkinator, #37, Tyler Thompson, TimMartland, Nickthks, Andrew McTaggart, Kevin Miller, Ed g, Harri Evans, Alex Hindley, Ed R Gaming, Elliott Baker, Vesa Koivunen, Richard Matera, Benjamin, Simon Emms, Gavin Cameron @theloftworkshop, Michael Holden, Fatboy, Robert Chambers.

We'll be doing it all again this weekend after the Barcelona race, so if you want to take part just make sure you're in the Champions tier by Sunday!

Files

Comments

Simon Emms

I want Edd to name and shame. If only in a comical/friendly way of trolling is in the way that we troll him. And it might remind me where I voted (I use the Anderson vibes method). Also, I typically find 12-18th really hard. Not shit, not brilliant, often anonymous.

Laura Davis

Enjoying the new format of these. Like Simon I found the middle of the pack really hard to rate, they often end up in a random order, also reading Edd’s ranking reminds me of things I’d completely forgotten by the time I’ve done my rankings…

Alex Hindley

Name and shame us, Edd! I’d completely forgotten that Lindblad effectively got a free stop under the red flag. Also, who came closest to matching your rankings — or did anyone get them exactly right — for the Edd Straw Award?

Michael Holden

This was such an interesting listen ... Couldn't believe some of the wide ranging placings. I did struggle with consistency when considering penalities for drivers. I was harsher on Gasly than others simply because he got 2. And I was also tough on Perez, simply because he his penalty was a lot more costly. Bring on Spain.

Ed R Gaming

Agreed, in the way only Edd can do, especially as I'm sure I'll regret all of mine that I did in 20s

Ed R Gaming

I understand the pro/con format on the article and it made it far easier to understand the why but personally I preferred the little paragraph detailing your reasoning as felt there was often little extra details and it was a more enjoyable read for me

Ed R Gaming

Agree with both you and Simon, I wondered whether it's due to people watching (I'm assuming) the TV broadcasts where they often don't show the drivers having average races, focusing on those doing well or struggling as I find the top and bottom few easier to rank

Robert Chambers

1. Feel free to call is out individually on our rankings. We certainly give you a hatd time. If we can dish it out, we should be able to take it. 2. If one of us mystifies you, send us an email and ask for an explanation. Might be fun for you to pick out one of us each week and make us explain a certain questinable ranking.

Thorarinn Gunnarsson

I absolutely loved this episode. A love letter to the members club.

Thorarinn Gunnarsson

That being said. I really don't mind being named. I put Alonso first, I saw the brilliance in his drive and I stand by it.

Simon Emms

We need an even more meta podcast Champions Disagreeing With Their Own Rankings

Simon Emms

We're not properly Champions until we spend Monday and Tuesday watching all the driver onboards. As Damon said about racing with a Scotch egg in your pocket, "you've got to take it seriously"

Simon Emms

That's a great idea. Make us work for it

Kevin Miller

Yup, liked the new format for this. Not sure on the pros/cons format for your main rankings as I liked the more conversational style reasoning in the older format. The new one is quite abrupt.

Benjamin

Loved this format — keep it up, Edd!! And I have no problem with you calling out my name if my choices leave you less than impressed, or in the unlikely event that I might have done a half-decent job, hahaha… As for the pros-and-cons business, my inattentive brain loved it! That said, would it be possible to have both the pros and cons and the old column-style paragraphs? Because I really love the slightly informal way you’d write those. I realise this would come at the expense of even more of your already limited time, so I completely understand if this wouldn’t be very feasible.

Laura Davis

Yeah, I think so, quite often get to the midfield and think not a clue I barely saw you, end up going on their finishing position/their teammate/general vibes

Laura Davis

Ha, if Edd is naming and shaming us I might have to take it a bit more seriously!

Stuart Coulter

First of all, thank you Edd and The Race for listening to our feedback on the new format - it does mean that poor Edd has to record two podcasts instead of one, but this one is particularly appreciated. Just to pick up on some of the feedback on the new "pros" and "cons" narrative on the rankings themselves, I must admit I quite liked the change as I am quite time poor (unfortunately) so it helps me quickly understand how Edd reaches his conclusions on each driver. Perhaps there's a middle ground somewhere that keeps everyone happy (wishful thinking!)

Adam Ryall-Waite

Did vote this time but more than happy to be named and shamed!

Edd Straw

I can see a new segment called ‘Simon Emms Shaming Corner’ working well in future episodes!

Simon Emms

Don't give me ideas Straw!

Gavin Cameron @ the_loft_workshop

Happy to be named and ridiculed. As for feedback, I prefer a paragraph over the pros and cons. I find it provokes more thought than bullet points can

Lane

Even though as a non-champion (it hurts to write that out you know…!) I don’t get a vote, I do nevertheless vote for ‘name and shame’ my fellow members!! Also, I am REALLY happy you did this pod, Edd as I did miss your ‘ramblings’ last week! And that’s not to say that I didn’t like the contributions from Ben but that format is a bit ‘like everything else’. I really enjoy the way you can free wheel and enter into dialogue with us (in effect) when you’re going solo. and your occasional digressions (which aren’t really digressions) are always so enjoyable to listen to. I also preferred the previous format of the paragraph summaries on each ranking.

Benefsheh Verell

Definitely like and appreciate this format. I have every intention of trying the rankings each weekend and then quite frankly get overwhelmed with the enormity of the task 🤣 I realize I need to find some sort of my own methodology that clearly won’t involve hours of onboards 🤔

Simon

Definitely enjoyed listening to this, though I struggled to remember how I ranked some drivers! Like others have noted, for some the middle ranks, it was a little tough to differentiate. I also think I took the vibes approach, with a little bit of refinement.

Chris Parrott

Enjoyed Edd’s impression of the chap who used to read out the football results on five live.