Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Ohhhh baby! I think this episode will definitely spark some discussion. I know this episode generates some VERY strong opinions, so I'm curious how you will react to our thoughts!

Password: whoisright?

Files

Watch o2z5hb | Streamable

Watch this video on Streamable.

Comments

MasterPpv

I was waiting for this one, I know there's gonna be some discussion hahaha

Smash Bran'Discootch

Oh man, I'm looking forward to this discussion. I'm also curious to see if Sarah still feels the way she did the first time around 😂

Girish

really great episodes are coming up. Very excited for the discussions!!

MasterPpv

Okay, now that I've finished watching, I have some things to say. First of all, this episode more than any other so far, I'm so glad that you guys are doing this joint reaction series together. In Sarah's first watch, because it's only one person, you only have your immediate thoughts and reactions, which are very entertaining and honest and raw, but you don't get to have a proper, nuanced discussion. And because of how fired up Sarah got over it (in her own words, "I was *mad*"), the comments were similarly passionate in their defense of Hinata, and that's almost never cause for productive discussion. With both of you here, even though Adam almost entirely agrees with Sarah's viewpoint, being able to immediately have a calm discussion with some back and forth is extremely useful. I do understand what you guys are saying about the practice matches not being the right time for Hinata to immediately try and implement his idea. And being able to go past the basic argument of "who's in the right?" and have a more nuanced discussion about, "Okay, both viewpoints are understandable, but what's the best way to handle the situation in a way that both helps the team AND helps Hinata grow individually?" led to a much more interesting discussion here. Love it!

Sam Ninegar

Ultimately, I think this episode is best viewed through the lens of Hinata and Kageyama being our main characters for the series, and Hinata ultimately being the “main” main character. The attitude of committing to stubborn growth, regardless of how it affects his teammates is a big impetus that drives the rest of the series. We see that desire for growth here in a pretty unproductive and unrefined form. It gets better pretty quickly and helps elevate everyone around him not long after this episode. But his very simple straightforward desire to improve is the engine for a lot of growth within himself and within the team. He is a dumb stubborn kid who wants to elevate himself, and ends up pulling up the rest of the team, even if a lot of that pulling is done unintentionally.

MasterPpv

Also, I just want to take a minute and point out a few character moments that I love. First of all, can we just give it up for Takeda-sensei?! That reframing of the situation for the boys was SO well done. They were teetering on a very fine edge from where things could have gone south very easily, and he helped them understand how to think about it productively instead. Absolute GOAT. Also, two small but important moments for Hinata. First, when he's taken out of the match by Ukai. Given what we know of him, we might expect to see him whine, or sulk, or at least make a frustrated face. He does none of those things, and not only that, is actively cheering from the sideline immediately (before then having a more internal moment). He understands that Ukai is absolutely right in his call because of how that play with Asahi went, and readily accepts that he needs to go chill out. Finally, and I'm actually kind of shocked that Adam didn't comment on this, I absolutely love how the episode ends, with him going directly to Ukai and asking, "Coach, how exactly am I supposed to practice?" To me, that was such a mature thing to do, and shows a willingness to listen to more experienced people instead of just chasing what his own instincts tell him to. As a coach, I feel like Adam would have absolutely loved that moment.

Kim Kjell Khan

After I've seen the episode, I wonder what Adams advice would be to Hinata in that last scene. Based on what he has seen and his own experiences, I wonder how he would respond as a coach to an enthusiastic kid with a sense of wanting to improve his game alot.

april 🍏

Love the discussions for this one. I think there is so much nuance in this situation and hearing it in a conversation format with a high-level player and a coach was such an interesting dynamic. Overall I think Hinata wanting to grow is inevitable and a good choice for his personal game, but should that be prioritized on the spot at a team-based training camp? Probably not. I think the next episodes are going to be soooo interesting to hear your thoughts on.

Jake Thompson

These conflicts are both my favorite and my most disliked, because neither side is really in the wrong. It comes down to specialization vs generalization; Kageyama wants Hinata to become a better all around player by focusing on his shortcomings, while Hinata wants to polish his one skill to the absolute limit. It's also interesting that Kageyama, Sugawara and Coach Ukai (all setters) end up sharing the same opinion because they don't quite have a spiker's perspective on what HInata is describing.

Baduizm

Hinata is more at fault here than Kageyama. Have always thought this.

Ciara DLC

Yeah, I've always thought Hinata was very selfish and greedy in this episode. It was sprinkled in the previous episode with him back on his "Ace" bullshit, and now with the way he looks at Lev with envy and thinking only about his own progression. I mean he is young, and it's normal.. but it always bothered me that he only seems to care about being on the court and not the overall good of the team. The only thing Hinata has to offer is his quick so I get him wanting to polish that, but I think it would help his team even more by working on the basics (serving, blocking, receiving) instead. Which would make him a more balanced player instead of a one trick pony. But as other's have stated, I think Hinata's progression and growth is necessary and will benefit the team overall eventually. But - it shouldn't be a priority at a training camp, and is more appropriate at a later date.

Sharles Davis Kendy

I think it's both greedy AND subconscious. Hinata went for the ball because of all those events but he also was not thinking "I'm gonna steal this ball from Asahi"

Sharles Davis Kendy

One the interesting parts about their fight is that Hinata and Kageyama both think way too similarly just from different perspectives. Hinata sees the quick getting stopped as his failure. It's his attack and it keeps getting stoped and he blames himself for it. HE is the reason they lost to Seijoh so HE needs to fix that. Kageyama sees the quick getting stopped as his failure. It's HIS attack (Hinata's will isn't needed for this) and it keeps geting stopped and he also vlames himself for their loss to Seijoh. Hinata thinks that no matter how good Kageyama gets, there is no toss that can't be blocked. Kageyama thinks that Hinata can't figure out the quick toss in a way that would let him readjust. They're both certain they're right and incredibly frustrated that the other doesn't see it.

Sarah Pavan

I think I was a little more toward neutral than I was on the first watch... maybe 😂

Sarah Pavan

I'm appreciating this part of the series waaaaaaay more now than I did the first time. Solid episodes all around

Sarah Pavan

I really appreciate both of these comments. First of all, I completely understand what you are saying in the first one. Even though my opinion didn't change too much, being able to explain my point of view by having a discussion about it makes it more palatable for viewers. You're right... my passion probably evoked equally passionate responses when I was watching on my own. As for the Adam observation in comment 2, I think he often sees things from both an athlete and coach perspective, so while I do understand what you're saying, I feel like the athlete side came out in this instance.

Sarah Pavan

I understand what you're saying here, and I understand people's unwavering support of Hinata no matter what, given that he is the "main" main character. I can't help but view the majority of what happens on the court from an athlete perspective, putting myself on the court with them. Does that make sense?

Sarah Pavan

Thank you!!! The majority of people take Hinata's side in this, so it's nice to see this perspective. I can't help but feel like a traitor to Karasuno sometimes with my opinions, even though I love them

Sarah Pavan

You're the second person who brought this up, so I'm going to have to ask him about this

Sarah Pavan

We definitely focus on the nuance and reality of the on-court situations, even if they differ from popular opinion. This particular episode is very polarizing.

Sarah Pavan

But what would you choose? Polish all of your skills to become better all-around, or focus on just one?

Sarah Pavan

True. For me, it still represents a single-minded focus on himself at the expense of the people around him. It wasn't malicious, but it wasn't team-focused in that moment

Sharles Davis Kendy

I do appreciate that the show never decides which options is the "right" one. In the end, they decided to hone his strengths instead of shoring up his weaknesses, but the show never says this is the one true way to train or anything like that. It's just the way THIS team chose to go.

MasterPpv

Well hello! If there's one thing I've learned in my lifetime, it's that people tend to respond in kind to what they receive, and that's even more true over the internet. That said, I still really enjoyed the heated discussion that was had in the comments of your original watch through, but the benefit of this, comparatively, was the ability to have a back and forth. With comments, you get the reaction from the video, a comment in response, maybe a reply if you happen to read and reply, and that's about it. Maybe the commenter will respond to the reply, but that may or may not get read, and even if it does, it would be too time-consuming to keep responding back and forth. But that ability to have multiple layers of back and forth discussion was so good here.

Jake Thompson

As former military, the quote "diversity is the key to victory, specialization is the way to defeat" is something I think influenced me a lot. Being able to perform multiple tasks at a competent level was always more important than being excellent in a single pursuit. "Jack of all trades" is often used in a demeaning way, but it's versatility that will keep someone valuable when styles or strategies change.

WaschbaerWario

I feel like everyone Ive seen who reacted to this has had really good discussions about it, but I think some are missing the point. It is true that Hinata sucks at basically everything. I mean he isnt even a good spiker in itself, so whats the point of having him on the court instead of someone who is a little bit more an allrounder, like Narita or Ennoshita? The ONLY reason he gets to play is because of Kageyama´s insane and to be fair completely not realistic setting skills. Hinata just runs around, jumps and suddenly there is a ball while he is hitting with his eyes closed. And at this point we had seen this insane fast and "godlike" quick being stopped again and again even at super crucial points like in the Seijoh match. So I think Hinata is somewhat panicking that he wont get to play anymore, because he is an overall bad player at volleyball and the one thing that he is on the court for doesnt seem to be working anymore. So he decides that he has to improve, but how? Flshback to the practice match against Seijoh where Oikawa says that you cant improve receiving overnight and several comments from Daichi that it basically took him 3 years to be this good at receiving. So for Hinata to become a reliable defender is out of the question at this point. I agree that he could work on his serves, but that really impacts like one play out of every full rotation so maybe not the best thing to focus on. So in Hinatas mind the only thing he can improve on is the thing why he is on the court in the first place, the quick with Kageyama. We have seen in the Seijoh match that they dealt with the quick by not blocking it, because Hinata cannot control the ball because its insane fast and he has his eyes closed. So taking all these points into account for Hinata who is extremely obsessed with playing on the court all the time the only way to improve is by controlling the ball in midair. Most people interpret his saying "I want to fight by myself" as selfish but I see it as an desire of him to be able to fight in the air against the other team. Its not that Hinata is selfish but currently he has no part in this quick at all, he can just swing and hope. And dont tell me that would not be super unsatisfying for any attacker. So his "selfish" proclaim to want to fight by himself is actually him wanting to be an active part of the team and not just a "bystander" who just swings blind randomly and sometimes there is a ball. He desperatly wants to be part of the team as a whole. Thanks for coming to my TED talk.