Patreon Q&A #3: Prosody, Other Lives, Archives, and Songs, Songs, Songs (Patreon)
Downloads
Some files exceed the archive size limit and weren't saved: 1 file. Please note these limits are in place to keep this site running long term, without costing a fortune. You can favorite the creator though, certain milestones increase the limit.
Content
Friends!
Pleased to share with you the last installment of the Patreon Q&A. This one took a while, not only because the questions were so thought-provoking, but because I decided to make it fancy(er). I hope you enjoy my little experiment.
A couple folks asked me to create an RSS feed so that you could listen to audio dispatches more easily; you should've received a notification on that this morning with a link.
Here's the transcript. Thanks again for your incredible support. xotg
TRANSCRIPT
Hey everybody, welcome to the third and final installment of the Patreon Q&A. In this one, I’ll answer questions related to performance, memoir, songs I wish I’d written, other lives I might’ve had, the Dave Carter archives, new album prospects, and more. Buckle up, settle in, get comfortable; this one’s gonna be a doozy. [music]
Ron Greitzer asks: I’ve always been curious — with the paucity of repeating choruses and overly-dense lyrics in Dave Carter songs, how did you keep it all straight in your head and your mouth? Between shows I actually attended or just videos I’ve seen, I can count the number of times you messed up on the fingers of one hand. Did you have mnemonic devices that you relied on?
Well, Ron, consider where I come from. In fourth grade, I got cast as The Modern Major General in Pirates of Penzance. [sample] And then in the fifth grade, I was cast as the Duke of Plaza Toro in The Gondoliers. [sample] I think it’s fair to say that my earliest musical experiences set me up perfectly to sing Dave Carter songs.
I tell people the way I remember the songs is by actively watching the movie of the song as it plays out in my head. That’s true most of the time. Sometimes, I can hear the album recording playing along, so that in performance I am really just singing with a track nobody else can hear. Other times, photographic memory kicks in and I “see” the lyrics on a page.
Part of the memory is physical. Lyrics become anchored in gestures — a strum, a stop, a chord — which are tied to an inflection in the delivery. After you do a song a certain way for a while, all the pieces lock in so tightly together that you almost can’t get it wrong unless you fall asleep in the middle of the song. I won’t call it auto-pilot — I maintain that presence is critical to delivering a song with the full force of your life behind it — but a kind of whole-body memory. The songs become cellular.
It helps that Dave Carter was a masterful writer. Consider how well his lyrics roll off the tongue. Prosody — the art of fitting words to music— was one of his superpowers. The vowels and consonants flow, they are logical both as units of story and as movements of the lips and tongue, all perfectly mated with their underlying music. You don’t get tongue-tied. He just didn’t write that way. [music]
I’m not likely to forget songs that I play often but for others, like “236-6132,” I will sometimes make notes in the set list book — the first word of each verse for example — to make sure I get them in the right order. That’s all I need. [music]
Now, there have been phases in my solo career where I’ve forgotten Dave’s words. Usually this is because I’ve lost my connection to the song. In rare instances, my body just won't let me sing it. I don’t question it when this happens. For me, performing Dave’s songs goes well beyond the simple mechanics of singing and storytelling. There’s so much history wrapped into each song — and so much psychological weight and conflict in my journey with this music — that sometimes, I blank. That’s my cue to stop singing a song until it feels fresh and alive to me again. Great question, Ron, thank you so much. [music]
David Mahaffey asks: What have you learned about yourself as you've worked on your memoir?
This is such a great question, thank you for this.
I set out to write the memoir without a clear idea of where the story starts and ends; I just knew I had a record I wanted to set straight. My motivations were not the love and wonder that brought me back to the stage. I began from a fearful, defensive place, trying to answer the slings and arrows leveled at me in the months after Dave died by some of the folks closest to him. I also wanted to balance the fairytale we’d built with a fuller picture of what a relationship with Dave Carter looked like. It wasn’t until last year, when I wrote about my childhood, that I became aware of the dysfunctional relationships I was unwittingly replicating with my detractors, my characters, and my readers. So I’ve learned to examine where my storytelling impulses are coming from; to analyze which God I’m answering to; and make sure that I am, in fact, serving the highest good, which I see as twofold: writing my truth with clarity, compassion, and conviction; and healing myself in the process.
I’ve also learned that writing in community is essential. I’ve been in two long-term writers workshops — one in Pennsylvania, one here in western Massachusetts — and have curated a handful of writers around the country whose feedback I value above all others. Their input has been essential to my growth. When they told me they didn’t like the character of Dave Carter — and some even felt angry with him — I knew I had a problem. It’s true our relationship was insanely complicated, but Dave Carter was my favorite person. That’s what I always said. So I’ve had to dig deeper into what that means, whether it’s true, and if it is, why my story didn’t square with that.
I started working on this memoir in 2007 and have thrown myself at it in fits and starts ever since. Sometimes I’ve run from the work because it was heavy and seemed to be keeping me from advancing my life, my love, my creativity in other areas. I still feel this way sometimes and have, over the years, wondered if my dedication to both the musical legacy and the story are why I never found a partner, had children, or achieved the potential I felt I had in me. And yet — and yet — whenever I dove back in to work on the story, I was at home in my words, even when the words were hard to write, and ultimately, I enjoyed the work.
In 2015 or 2016, a counselor suggested I drop the memoir forever — allow that it was a healing practice, had served its purpose, and from that point forward, let myself off the hook. I remember feeling a rush of freedom wash through my body when he said that. And then I went home and got back to work. There’s something in this journey, in this story, in the practice of writing and in this sandbox where I dig and dig to find myself that matters to me; or maybe I’m just running from some demon I have yet to identify, I don’t know. But the story I started telling isn’t the one I’m ending up with, and I’m still too curious about it to let it go. Thanks for the question, David. [music]
Scott Price asks: If you didn't continue to be a folksinger after Dave's passing, what career path might you have followed?
From 1993 until 1997, I worked as an administrator, editor, and graphic designer for UC Berkeley and then Portland General Electric. I love working with words, images, and layout, and could’ve been very happy with a career in publications; bonus points for being hired by a university because I love campus energy.
I dreamed of getting an MFA in creative writing but I couldn’t figure out how to balance touring with more school. Honestly, though, I was too chicken to submit creative writing samples as part of the application process because I didn’t think of myself as a storyteller, couldn’t fathom where fiction comes from, and in my mind, that’s what creative writing was. But I knew I had a knack for straightening crooked narratives and simplifying complicated language, so editing — prose and songwriting especially — is still one of my favorite things to do, and definitely another option for a career path.
Once I got into recording, I discovered a fascination for mixing, for setting levels, highlighting motifs, extracting parts that didn’t serve the whole — all of which felt to me like an auditory form of editing and ultimately, storytelling. So to answer your question: any job where I could work with found materials to create or improve a story would’ve made me happy — editor, mix engineer, even collage artist. Luckily, I get to do a little of all these things as a folksinger.
Of course, there were other dreams — primate anthropologist. Farmer. Actor. Archaeologist. Poet. Surgeon. Animal behaviorist. Calligrapher. Painter. Potter. Travel blogger. Publisher of small books… the list goes on. When opportunities arise in any of these fields I take them, small though they may be, and I’m grateful every day that my life in music supports this. Thanks for the question. [music]
Now, Debbie Cairns had a whole slew of questions, so we’ll go through these quickly! She says: I’m always impressed with people who can tune their instrument by ear. How do you learn to do that, or are you born with many of those kind of skills?
Debbie, I found you a great video! The link is in the written portion of this Q&A. Let me know if you find this helpful. This is for tuning a guitar by ear: https://youtu.be/GY3KLVoIU_8
Second question: Are you planning to finish your memoir?
Yes, though I don’t know what shape it will take. It is looking less like one story and more like a series of snapshots from 2002-2003.
She wants to know: Did you live in the Portland area early in your career?
Portland: yes, I moved there in 1996 and met Dave Carter within three weeks of my arrival.
She asks: How did you decide to stop writing for RealWomenRealSongs? It seemed like some people suggested that you just do what you can in one week. That seemed hard.
Yeah! I didn’t get through all 52 weeks of the project, but I’m thrilled with the 26 songs I put together. When I participated in RealWomenRealSongs in 2014, I got 18 songs, and culled nine of them for the LOW TIDE album. I’m looking at my new work and starting to think about what story they tell, and which ones would make a nice collection.You’re right that the ethos of RWRS is to present what you can each week, polished or not. But I’m not really a “polished or not” person as it turns out, so if I couldn’t find the time to write and produce a recording I was happy with, I passed. I also had a hard time with the prompts. In 2014 they were feeling tones but in 2021 they were concrete household items — hope chest, twinkle lights, frying pan, for instance. Some weeks just left me cold. Eventually my daily rhythm changed and my artistic focus pivoted to memoir. I never stopped writing; I write every day. I just stopped producing work for that project. Thanks for the questions, Debbie!
Speaking of songs that came from RWRS 2014, Jack Eppington wants to know about the relationship between "Daffodil Days" and "Were You Ever Here?" He says: I think of the songs as sisters, and I even wonder if one is a revised write of the other, as I suspect your wrote them around the same time.
Well. They appear side by side on the album intentionally. They’re both felt in 6/8 time and follow a similar chord progression, which naturally makes one feel like an extension of the other. "Daffodil" is a concrete telling of the breakup story where the singer is in her power, full of fire, more angry and fed up than heartbroken. [music] In "Were You Ever Here," though, that heartbreak catches up with her. We learn that he’s the one who broke it off, and for all her swagger, she misses him, she loves him, and she has questions. [music] "Were You Ever Here" feels like the sad shadow of "Daffodil Days" — that span of days after she drives away when the hurt sets in. One is not a re-write of the other; the are two sides of the same sad breakup coin is all. Thanks for the question. [music]
Again on the topic of songs and songwriting, Joe Sanchez asks: What famous song do you wish you wrote?
You’re probably not going to like this answer, Joe, but there are no songs, famous or otherwise, that I wish I’d written. To write a certain song, or create any piece of art, really, an artist has to have been subject to a very particular set of experiences and relationships across a particular place and time. It’s just not possible for any of us to stand squarely in another’s life experience and write the truth. Plus, to me, the idea of wishing I’d written a song someone else labored over bears a whiff of envy, which I don’t feel.
But give me any song on Frank Tedesso’s EINSTEIN’S VIOLIN, for instance, and I become very still and quiet on the inside. This simple guitar/vocal album is pure art, top to bottom, coming from a place that feels so true to me that it hurts. Which isn’t to say all the songs are sad; they aren’t. They’re just true. Frank’s language is wild and rich; his chords are unexpected and entrancing. His subjects are unique, his compassion is bottomless, he’s clever, and he’s faithful to his metaphors. When I hear “Margaret” or “Stumpy’s Last Dance,” or “Another Bruce Springsteen,” I never think: man. I wish I’d thought of that; I wish I’d written it. I happen to have seen firsthand how great art often comes from shattering pain and inner turmoil; that though it is often the product of great joy, it is just as often the product of utter brokenness. So I don’t think: I wish I’d written, that because I’d have to inhabit the headspace and the broken heart space of the artist — impossible.
Instead, I think: how can I get access to my own depths, tone the singularity of my vision, own my own metaphors, access my unique stories, and deploy my own bent language in service of something that feels as true and as inevitable as THAT. How can I write from the absolute center of all that I am? It’s a feeling I’m after; a feeling of having written at a level of skill, clarity, and alignment that I find elusive most of the time but seems available to me, and to each of us, once we learn how to gain access to our own secrets. Thank you for the question! [music]
Okay, here’s the home stretch. We’ve got two question from Karl, and the first is: What is the status of Dave Carter archive? And the second: What are the prospects for the next album?
The next phase of the Dave Carter / Dave Carter & Tracy Grammer archive will involve digitizing a box of about 100 interviews and live show CDs. One challenge I face is determining how best to organize the recordings and their contents. Another challenge is figuring out where in the house to set up this project. But I plan to begin in April and would be thrilled to be finished by August.
Album-wise, I have several new songs from RWRS3 that need polishing, plus a list of cover songs as long as my arm that I’ve wanted to record for years. I see the next album as being a mix … a few themes are starting to emerge … and I hope to get into the studio later this year.
Thank you for the questions, and thanks, everybody, for participating in the Patreon Q&A. It was a real pleasure to think about these things and to know what’s on your mind. If you have any follow-up questions, feel free to leave them in the Comments section; otherwise, we push on! Thanks everybody! [music]
# # #